Firehall Pizza

I quite enjoyed the food here. The ingredients were incredibly fresh, including the mushrooms on top of the pizza. The risotto ball appetizer was really tasty! Order it — you won’t be disappointed! The only qualm I have with this place is the slower than acceptable service. We had to go in to find out waitress to ask for refills and the bill. This is not the place to come if you’re in a pinch for time.

Great restaurant for families. The menu is pretty large so there was something for everyone. Good pizza, good pasta and good burgers. Check out the chocolate store next door for desert.

Nice service and place, but the pizza wasn’t anything special. The nachos also seemed like they just threw some cheese over a bag of nachos and threw them in the microwave.

Ok pizza though not outstanding. Better Pizza if you head over to Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint. (Our go to place from now on)
We had two pizza’s, one was nicely done the other could have used a few more minutes in the oven. Can’t imagine what the quality would be like if it was busy!

We ordered two kids meals and we shared 1 lb of wings and a pizza. All of the food even the kids pasta (which is hard to mess up) was way below average. I had high expectations for the pizza and was disappointed. Very bland. I would never go back to this place. The wings were very tasteless and we ordered the second level of spice which translated to no spice at all. The hostesses weren’t friendly and we were made to wait 15 mins for a table that we could see was free and clean when we first arrived. They told a party of 8 that they would have to wait 40 mins but when we got in and the whole time we were there a table for 8 was free. Our waitress was nice enough hence the second star. AVOID this place!

This is a great place to go to for a casual dinner/​lunch. They have a wide variety of pizzas (thin crust, super flavourful) and great appetizers to share (I recommend the calamari or onion rings). Service is quick and they are really friendly — prices are affordable as well. Located right in the village.

Food and service was great. They had a great variety of drinks and pizzas to choose from. The garlic bread order was a bit small but was super delicious.

Great atmosphere in the village. Went with our family of 3. My son and I shared the spanokopizza and chicken wings. Hubby had the chicken fettuccine. Everything was tasty. Waiter was very friendly and was very attentive. No complaints here. Great place for the family if you are visiting Blue.

Great food great place. Chicken club was awesome. Nachos were excellent. Pizzas were ok, cheese pizza and pepperoni/​mushroom for the kids were ok.
Will definitely order again.

My first Unilocal review! YAY!
Went in on a Monday afternoon with the wife. I had the Meathead pizza and she had the Jonny Lombardi pizza.
Atmosphere/​Ambience: love the look of this place. Old school fire hall look. Absolutely great. 4.5÷5.
Service: waitress (Stephanie) was really nice, prompt service, checked on us frequently and always smiling. Food came out quick and hot and it was pretty busy. ⁵⁄₅.
Food/​Drinks: Good selection of beers and alcohol. we both had a couple pints of beer. Now the food, pizzas were awesome! lots of toppings, the dough was perfect. Very filling, very fresh. No negatives at all. ⁵⁄₅
Overall: Definitely recommend this place. I’ve been to a few places here in the village and this is by far the best.

Go to spot in the village! Decently priced and freshly made! They are always ready for walk in, and they will text you when your table is ready!
You must try the sweet potato fries– they are perfectly seasoned and crispy!

This place had pretty good food. I went here last night with a friend and the restaurant looks very neat and trendy. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs while my friend ordered bbq chicken pizza. The spaghetti was delicious and the portions were quite decent. It was nice that there was garlic bread to go along with it. The pizza was big enough that there were leftovers. I ate some this morning and it tasted so good! There were a couple of waitresses who were chatting around not doing any work, however the waitress that served my table did a good job. Like all the places at Blue Mountain, the food was a bit on the pricy side, but it was one of the better places overall.

Came here with my boyfriend last weekend for the first time. It was around lunch time on a Saturday and the place was very full and busy. The décor and feel of the place was pretty cool, they have a few big tvs playing all the sports games.
I ordered a burger called the «Gladiator» which had provolone cheese, proscuitto, arugula and bruschetta mix, and substituted the regular fries for sweet potato fries which was an extra 2 dollars, so my meal came out to 18 dollars. Honestly, I was not super impressed. The burger itself was pretty thin and rather greasy, I was expecting a thicker, meatier burger. The patty actually seemed pre-​made and not made in-​house but I could be wrong. The sweet potato fries were crispy and good.
My boyfriend had a margherita pizza, and maybe my standards for pizza are high because of lots of travelling in Italy and eating some really good pizza in Toronto, but we both found it pretty lackluster especially for a place that is supposed to specialize in pizza. The crust was pretty thin but also doughy and dense and kind of chewy. The sauce and cheese were ok. He has a side of sweet potato fries as well and they were really crispy and a large portion. But overall, I found the meal to be pretty overpriced. I don’t think I would come back in the future.

Good atmosphere in the heart of the Village. Good variation of pizzas and pastas — a consistent staple of good eats that you can count on whenever visiting Blue Mountains. it’s pretty busy on weekends and I also see a lot of take out orders come in.

Ok, so I will start off by saying this might not be a completely fair review as we are from the Buffalo, NY region and are surrounded by awesome places for pizza and wings.
The pizza — was OK at best, and judging by the other reviews, it might have been an off night? We got the margherita which was just sauce & cheese, however it tasted doughy and undercooked and mostly a Neapolitan style .
The wings — tasted like the one and only time I had them delivered from Dominos lol. They are microwaved/​baked and _​not_​deep fried. Very chewy and the blue cheese is a watery dressing, nothing like real buffalo wings.
I’ve seen a lot of decent reviews for this place, we might give it another shot sometime and try something different.

Nice restaurant that is not worth the overinflated prices. Pizza was good, not great, and was just enough to feed 2 adults. Garlic bread was very good.
Overall, not entirely disappointing but certainly won’t be the most memorable meal we had at Blue Mountain.

A pretty neat restaurant located at the back center of Blue Mountain Resort. This restaurant features its delicious pizza. What I like most is that all the pizzas are thin-​crust. I would say this restaurant is comparable to pizza libretto.
My friend and I ordered Hawaiian Five O and Johnny Lombardi. Hawaiian Five O is just the standard hawaiian pizza — nothing special except it has thin-​crust. However, Johnny Lombardi has good prosciutto, arugula and with spicy tomato sauce. The spiciness is perfect. The restaurant also cuts and divides the pizza nicely for you.

If Boston Pizza was a hit or miss, I’d say this is like BP on a hit night. The pizza was good and the atmosphere is friendly. I’d say it deserves 3.5 stars, but since I can only give 3 or 4, because of the great and super fast service, I give it 4.

What we had:
— Arancini
— French Onion Soup
— Hot Wings
— Meathead Pizza
— Spaghetti and Meatballs
The arancini and the pizza was alright, the pasta and the soup was bad, and the wings were awesome! The guy serving us bumped this from a two-​star to a three-​star… Super nice guy!

I came here for my best friend’s bachelorette party last week. I will say that the service was pretty impressive. They did not take reservations which meant that we had to wait about 45 minutes for a table of 11 people. The good news was they give out pagers that work in the entire village and so we were able to go to a nearby bar and grab drinks while we waited. The servers were patient with us as we ordered and easily accommodated our request for separate bills.
The actual menu/​food was not as impressive. Prices seemed a little much for what it was and selection was not great. I wouldn’t expect much from a wine list at a place like this but their choices were especially boring. As a bit of a cocktail enthusiast, their cocktail list had concoctions that all seemed like they would go terribly together. The one exception to this was the Cucumber Fizz, which I ordered. It was a well-​balanced cocktail that was not overly sweet and uses St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur, which is very hot right now.
As for food, I shared the calamari with a friend. We both found is remarkably salty. For my entrée, I had the agnolotti. Again, it was incredibly salty. Such a shame since both dishes tasted pretty good besides that.
In the end, I might give this place another try in a few years but there are too many restaurants in the village to pay slightly exaggerated prices for mediocre food.