Maple Leaf Fudge

This is the only fudge I’ve ever liked. Since I moved to California I have to get it shipped here by relatives once or twice a year, and no matter how many bars they send the fudge is gone within 24 hours. I hope they bring back chocolate marshmallow without nuts because those were my favorite. Since they stopped making it I have to buy Rocky Road and pick the walnuts out:) No one makes fudge better. No one.

Stopped in for maple candies to take home and they had a great selection, so much more then fudge. They had ice wine candy, teas, and everything maple. Sampled the bacon fudge and it was yummy! The staff was friendly and very helpful. The store smelled and looked great. If you need some sweets or a souvenir check this place out for sure!

Great fudge but I didn’t care for the attitude. We had settled on two types and we were interested in more. However we decided if receiving any type of friendly service was going to be short of drawing blood out of a stone, we cut that short :(
Too bad. This town obviously thrives on tourism and this store seems to be the exception.
One suggestion I would have for this business would be to find out what the customer likes to recommend different flavors. Maybe be a little more focused on customer service by adopting a more open friendly demeanor. You want the customer to explore your store’s products, not make them feel unwelcome.

Fabulous fudge and service is superb! I love the samples — it helps pick out which to buy! Purchased 4 bricks and will be back for more while on vacation!
Great job — keep up the good work — tastes the same as it did over the past 20 years that I’ve been coming for vacations in the summers. Yum!

My first brush with fudge was in this shop a number of years ago, and I’ve been a fiend ever since. I returned to NOTL this past weekend with some girlfriends, and made note that I HAD to stop by this store for some fudge to bring back home.
I opted for the «buy 3 get 1 free» option. Each slab is around $ 6, but you can get half-​slabs to take home more flavours, which is great for indecisive people like me. I decided on a slab of chocolate and pralines & cream, and half slabs of the turtle, rocky road, double chocolate, and chocolate peanut butter flavours. I’ve sampled a bit of them all, and my favourites are still the chocolate and chocolate peanut butter — both were perfectly creamy and delicious, albeit very sweet.
One star off because I was kind of disappointed with the quality of some of the other pieces I bought — a couple of them were old, and nearly rock hard (basically inedible for fudge). Could be my fault for not sampling first, but a place that focuses on fudge should know when to not sell a piece to a customer. Also found the pralines & cream to be much too sweet for my liking, on top of being a rock hard piece — steer clear!

Did you know fudge is not chocolate? Well you will be educated on that fact as soon as you walk in here whether you already knew it or not! But your lesson will be friendly. And you will be stuffing your face with giant samples of all kinds of fudge while you learn it. They make it there and it is very tasty. Get some!

The pralines and cream fudge was delicious. I wanted to make chocolate chip cookies but replace chocolate chips with chunks of the fudge but I ended up eating all the fudge before I could make the cookies. If I’m ever in the area again I will definitely stop in.

Fantastic fudge! They had samples out for you to try various types. They also let you sample as many as you wanted. I could have easily satisfied my desires by the samples but bought some to go. The chocolate with nuts, chocolate/​peanut butter and white chocolate blueberry were my favorite. Definitely worth going. They charged $ 5.59 for a large slice and if you bought 3 the 4^th was free. There are several other shops nearby that looked good too but ended up here.

6 stars. NO, SIX THOUSAND stars!
This place makes the best fudge. Actually. Right there in front of you behind the counter. Yum, Yum, Yum. Every flavour. So melty and creamy and crumbly. Crispy edges, ooey gooey inside.
My recommendation: penuche = brown sugar maple. HELLO!
Worth the drive to Niagara on the Lake.
GO NOW!

A friend of mine is originally from the area, so when she found out I would be up this way she told me I HAD to go to Niagara on the Lake and that I HAD to go to Maple Leaf Fudge.
When I finally arrived to Queen Street (which is more adorable than I can put into words), I happened to find a parking spot right in front of Maple Leaf Fudge. The shop is super cute, and full of candy that will send anyone into a diabetic coma.
The selection is great — a nice mix of real fudge and pre-​packaged goods, in addition to maple syrup, cookbooks, etc. — and I managed to do all of my «souvenir» shopping for my office and my Canadian friend all in one place. The prices seemed alright, but I really wouldn’t know since I don’t eat fudge.
The staff was hit or miss — one woman told me what their most popular fudge was, but seemed very disinterested in helping me further and walked away. The other employees were alright, and the cashier was friendly enough.
They do take US and Canadian dollars (as well as credit cards), so if you didn’t convert your money like I failed to do, you’ll be fine.
If you’re in the area, be sure to stop in here for some treats.