Tiff’s Treats

4 words: Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip… enough said. Even the strongest of dieters fall prey to this genius (warm) delectable cookie! I can’t get enough

Unimpressed. For a $ 1.25 a cookie and the hassle of finding parking not worth it! I can make the cookies at home and have more then one!
We got oatmeal choc chip, m&ms for the boy, snicker doodle, and peanut butter choc chip. I am left wanting more. Should’ve went somewhere else.

I used to love going to Tiff’s treats. This is my first time at this location and I was underwhelmed. The cookies were small and appeared like they had been sitting out for hours. We got chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, and oatmeal raisin-​all were good, but not great. I just remember thinking they used to melt in my mouth at other locations.

I don’t know why, but I expected so much more. I thought they had a bigger selection of cookies, thought they would have a variety of different flavored ice creams for the cookie sandwiches. The cookies were good and freshly made. But wasn’t wowed by anything specific. I hate admitting this since so many people have raved about this place. Oh well… Maybe I’ll give their brownies if there’s a next go around.

I’ve always loved this place ever since the good olé college days at UT (Austin of course) when they used to be a one shop establishment. I’m pretty glad they have them now in strategic places as they are my go-​to place for sweets after lunch/​dinner. My usual is the Tiffwich using the white chocolate almond cookies, gooooood stuff! They did once have a bacon flavored cookie and that was also pretty darn good, but I have never seen it displayed ever since that one time =(. Only reason why I knocked off 1 star is because the cookies themselves can get a bit overly sweet. That’s probably the reason why I get the Tiffwich to mellow out the sweetness with ice cream. Nonetheless it’s always a pleasure visiting Tiff’s Treats to grab my Tiffwich craving.

Walking in you may think that this place doesnt have a good rep, but that is completely wrong. Wanting some cookies for tonight i searched for places and this seemed to be the best bet in the area. Its a small store but dont let that fool you as this place is AWESOME. The staff is extremely kind and even though there was a line it went by extremely fast. I ordered a dozen cookies and walked out minutes later. 6 Chocolate chip and 6 M&m and theyre incredible. Would definitely recommend going here! Cheers.

First off the warm cookies are amazing! This would easily be a 5 star if they had a place to sit and enjoy them. I had them oatmeal raisin and snickerdoodle and was in heaven! I will be back for more but would love this place to move and have an indoor area.

My job always orders cookies and milk from here. I’ve only tried the chocolate chip and sugar cookies and they are delicious. Melt in your mouth type of deal ! I love that it’s delivered in a insulated box so the cookies stay warm and the milk is cold. They do have a distinct taste more so after taste in my opinion. But all in all I’m ready for another delivery !

After my previous review, the marketing manager at Tiff’s Treats contacted me to ask me to give them another shot to impress me! He informed me that the Tiffwich (ice cream sandwich) is supposed to be made with warmed cookies before putting ice cream in between, so I will try that again next time. He arranged for two dozen (!!!) warm, fresh cookies to be delivered to my office for me and my staff. We received chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle and white chocolate chip almond. They were delivered exactly at the pre-​arranged time and were warm, soft and fresh, as promised. I found a new favorite as well, snickerdoodle. I am definitely impressed, both with the cookies, and with Tiff’s Treats’ willingness to listen to feedback and ensure customers have a good experience. Will certainly be back to the storefront as well as have cookies delivered!

It may not be the best value for cookies, but I’ve never had a more delicious, warm, chocolate chip and oatmeal cookie ever! What a treat!

These cookies are a dollar each… and I will gladly pay it. They are worth every penny. I love these cookies, they are buttery and moist with crispy edges. I wish they weren’t so small! I also wish they sold the dough… all i need is a spoon… tiff if u are reading this… sell us the dough!

I’ve ordered Tiff’s treats to be delivered as a gift multiple times and I always seem to mess up an address or time for delivery. But the Tiff’s treats employees always help me fix my mistakes and never give me any problems or attitude. They’re always very understanding and always deliver within the time period requested, even with a redelivery! Its not always easy to deliver to someone as a surprise without asking directly for an address but even if you get it wrong the first time they’re very accommodating. If you’re someone that wants to deliver this as a gift I definitely recommend it! They work with you to make it right! On top of that the cookies are fresh and delicious, every time they were delivered to me they were still warm. This is a great concept with great customer service!

I LOVE Tiff’s Treats! As soon as I walk into the door the smell of warm delicious cookies hits my nose. If you order them there to go they warm them which are the most amazing thing ever. I have also had them delivered and they are exactly on time and super pleasant. They have the most amazing chocolate chip cooks, snicker doodle is my favorite and you should definitely give their Tiffsblitz a try. BEST THING ever. All in all Tiff’s treat is the best in town if you need a fast simple tasty treat!

I’m kind of on the border between 3 and 4 stars with Tiff’s Treats. I came here twice while we were in TX. In addition to cookies, they have brownies, ice cream, and drinks.
FIRST EXPERIENCE
— — — — — — — — — -
The first time we came here for dessert after dinner around 8:00PM on April 20^th. My husband and I ordered the Tiffwich ice cream sandwich ($ 2.50 each). It’s served with Vanilla Blue Bunny Ice Cream and you can choose 2 different cookies. I went with a Chocolate Chip Cookie and a Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie. I paid in cash and my husband noticed that after the employee handled the money with his bare hands he took the cookies out of the display case without any gloves and went into the back kitchen to prepare the ice cream sandwiches. My husband is always very cautious about this kind of thing so he was freaking out a bit. He doesn’t like how we weren’t able to watch him prepare the ice cream sandwiches. He almost threw it in the trash, but I started eating mine and it was delicious so he got over it and ate his too. It was probably the best Ice Cream Sandwich I’ve ever had… (would have gotten a 5 Star easily just for that)
SECOND EXPERIENCE
— — — — — — — — — — —
We were leaving the following day (April 21^st) so I wanted to get some cookies «to go» and another Tiffwich! I don’t think I’ll ever be in TX again anytime soon so I had to take advantage. HAH. Anyway, it was in the morning and as soon as we walked in we could smell cookies baking (heavenly!) There were a lot of employees now in the kitchen and this time we were helped by a girl. I ordered another Tiffwich and she gave me this funny look and told me that unfortunately, they were no longer serving Tiffwiches because the Blue Bunny Ice Cream was recalled as it may be contaminated with Listeria monocytogenes. (oh great… hah) We told her that we were here just last night had ate the ice cream and she replied that they didn’t get the word about pulling it from the menu until 10:00PM (we were there at 8:00PM). Anyway, we researched it and turns out that the recall was mainly for institutional/​food service ice cream cups with tab lids and the folks that reported illness were in a hospital. So we’re not worried.
With that said, we ordered a dozen assorted cookies (Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Chip & Almond, Butterscotch Chip, Sugar) to bring on our road trip. My favorite so far is the Peanutbutter Chocolate Chip Cookie. The Chocolate Chip cookie is okay, but I feel like they under bake it on purpose and it’s too sugary. The Snickerdoodle cookie is also too sweet. I tried the Butterscotch Chip Cookie and it was pretty much inedible as it was waaaay too sweet.
They shop has a nice simple concept, but I feel like overall the cookies are way too sweet. (Either that or someone was heavy handed on the sugar that morning.) I like how they will serve the cookies warm. It really needs the ice cream or a glass of milk because eating them by themselves is tough. LOL
⁷¹⁄₁₀₀ Reviews for 2015

You have got to be kidding me on this place! My husband and I were in the mood for a cookie and Unilocaled a place close. This one came up as 4 stars so we decided to try it. Walked in to this little tiny store front with a case about the size of a cardboard box with cookies. At $ 1 a cookie about 3 inches in size we got 4. We got them warmed up, took our first bite and both had nothing but disappointment! Not worth it. Trust me! I love my desserts and this place sucked.

I ordered a dozen chocolate chip cookies for pick up. I came in the store about half an hour later and was third in line. After one of the other customers was helped and was waiting for their ice cream sandwich, the cashier went to the back. Two other workers came to the front and asked if the other customer had been helped, but didn’t ask me until that customer told them I had not been helped. Maybe this was just an honest oversight but it rubbed me the wrong way.
Still giving it four stars for now because the cookies were so darn good. Warm, moist, sweet… made me want to curl up next to a fireplace with a cold glass of milk.
So four stars, for now.

YUM!!! Someone brought a tray of Tiff’s Treats to a party and I tried several items including the chocolate chip cookie, sugar cookie, and brownie. I don’t normally eat or like baked goods, but these were amazing! Great texture & great flavor. I had to walk away from the desserts… ;-)

Call me crazy but we came when it was less than 30 degrees F outside. Not a soul in sight that night. I was craving something sweet in between a cake and ice-​cream. So despite the blasting arctic front coming in, my boyfriend and I shared a chocolate cookie ice cream sandwich in the car (they don’t have a seating area inside). They have several different types of cookies and their menu is simple enough to comprehend. Ice cream + cookie = good. Just don’t get addicted to them otherwise you will have to spend hours at the gym burning off those cookies.

This place gets 5 stars because it’s so simple. It’s a small shop that sells only a handful of items that they’ve mastered. It’s quick and cheap ($ 2.50 for an ice cream sandwich) and it completely took care of my sweet craving after dinner.
A cookie delivery service?! Craziness! They’ll even bring you coffee drinks and milk.
I’ll have to come back to try the peanut butter cookie sandwich.

this place is so addicting. Probably the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever had in my mouth. They are nice and warm when you pick them up so it’s difficult to not eat one on the way home. I have never had them delivered though, so I can’t comment about that. I do know when you walk into the bakery it smells absolutely amazingly delicious.
I normally get the groupon though and do big orders, they are normally for gifts and then I sneak a cookie from it for myself, haha.