Jerry’s Pizza and Subs

Tried thier pizza for the first time tonight, and we really enjoyed it! We ordered a 20 inch extra large cheese. The crust was on the thinner side, but it add a slight crunch. The ssuce had flavor to it, wich made the pizza very good (in my opinion). We will for sure be having pizza from Jerry’s in Altamonte again soon. I am looking forward to trying the subs and calzones. I would also like to add that the woman that was working behind the counter was very nice.

Fresh pizza and low cost !! I got two slices for 6.85 and a drink. They make the dough fresh and fresh cheese twice a day. It is a place you wouldn’t think to go to but is a hidden gem ! I would definitely recommend going. Great device also topping off the whole experience !

The scenery of this place isn’t over the top, but the food makes up for it. They make excellent pizza, I almost felt like I was eating high end pizza! Service was good and staff are very nice. I had their Mini Pizza and it had a perfect ratio of sauce to cheese! It is a nice quiet location and my family orders here often. I would recommend this pizza place to anybody because its so tasty with reasonable pricing!

Nothing fancy, just a nice neighborhood pizzeria. Clean, fast service, New York style pizza – what is not to like? They offer some good lunch specials and the Italian specialties look pretty good, too.
Service is fine, fast and friendly. I drop in often for lunch when I’m in Longwood and I’d like to try dinner there sometimes.

Originally from NYC. This place is so close to home. I search all over looking for a NY slice of pizza and I’m pretty sure this place is it. I did try their garlic knots and I really wasn’t impressed. But still worth5 stars for sure!!!

Great pizza is here. Forget dominoes, this family owned restaurant makes the best puzza in town. Get 2 slices and a soft drink for only $ 5!!! Great service too.

OMG. The pizza is of the chart. We have become regular patrons. Friendly staff makes this the perfect pizza place

I’ve always had great luck with this place. Great sauce and creamy Italian dressing. I usually order at least once a month. Customer service is great too.

Best Greek salad in town. The older staff know the ‘Doc’s salad’. Extra olives feta and anchovies.

Not bad — but not great either. I live nearby and I was excited by the reviews I’d read that day (I was jonesing for a slice). The staff was very friendly and that’s why I gave this review 3 stars. The space is conveniently located and the restaurant was very clean. But when I picked up my cheese slice to eat, the cheese literally started to slide off. I had never seen that before. I don’t know if the slice was still too hot, but even I don’t want to resort to a knife and fork when having a slice. The problem is I know I can find better pizza (and I’m willing to drive to get it). Their 2 slices and a drink for $ 5 is a great deal that’s hard to beat. I just don’t know when I’ll be interested in returning to take advantage of it.

Great tasting pizza friendly staff. Crust is crispy cheese is nice and hott with the right spices in the pizza sauce. Over all good spot

Love this place! Dawn is the sweetest and the food is the best. I work nearby and come here often. I love the wraps, pizza, salads and subs. I like frequenting family owned businesses because of the people. In this case, food and people!

Ordered for the first time Friday night. A small cheese pizza and hot Italian sub. Both were amazing! It was delivered less than the time told to me which was also amazing. The only thing was the order was not hot. I don’t live far so perhaps there were more deliveries ahead of mine. Food was delicious regardless.

My husband and I ate here today and the pizza was delicious! It’s very hard to find NY-​style pizza with a crispy crust, and friendly service on top. We’ll be back!

Best pizza I have had since I moved from Massachusetts. The wings are good. They seem like a small family business, which is nice but delivery does take a little longer than I would want it to (maybe they are understaffed) but food and prices are good.

My wife and I have been searching for a good pizza place. After going through a few places that certainly have disappointed us, I’m glad to say that Jerry’s is not one of them.
First off, they have an unbelievable special — 2 slices and a coke for $ 5 +tax. We were greeted by a friendly cashier and fountain drinks are self serve. Our pizza slices came out hot, and were thin! The cheese was tasty and the crust was also thin but not too powdery. Dining room is simple, but resembles what a take out pizza joint in NY would be. I grabbed a menu as I will defiantly be ordering pizza from here again and am looking forward to trying their wings and subs.

The best New York pizza in Altamonte. Carry out, amazing coupons in the Altamonte West metro clips mail flyer

Quick Edit: Jerry’s does deliver up to a five mile radius from the Altamonte location. No delivery charge, they just ask for a $ 15 minimum order and that you tip the driver. SUPPORT LOCAL SMALL BUSINESS!!!
Jerry’s is definitely a modest little place. Simple on the inside. I walked in and was greeted by a friendly order taker/​cashier. Order at the counter, find a seat and self-​serve drinks from the cooler or fountain.
The place bears the colors of the Italian flag throughout. Beyond that, the décor is a few pictures of the NY Yankees, Babe Ruth, New York City at night and not much more.
I didn’t come here for the ambience. I came for the food. After reading all the good reviewers and one disgruntled NY pizza snob, I had to judge for myself.
Let me preface this review by saying I’m Italian. Half Siciliano and half Napolitano. I was born in Copiague, NY. I’ve had access to good pizza every time I’ve gone back. I already have several Orlando Mom & Pop Pizza places I enjoy.
When shopping next door at Aldi, I never bothered stopping in to Jerry’s. Today, I’m glad I did. I ordered the lunch special. Two slices of pizza and a drink for $ 5.30(tax included).
The pizza came out hot, fresh and good. The crust was soft at the edge of the slice and crispy underneath. Not soggy like a previous reviewer said. In fact, parts of the crust had an audible crunch on the underside. Not that kind of crunch that’s dry and powdery. Just a good crispness.
I’ll be interested to try more of Jerry’s food in the future.

This place is awesome! We came in before jumping to Aldi’s for groceries and I’m really glad we did. I had been eyeing this place for a couple weeks and just never had the time to go. They have an awesome ramp and stairs option that appealed to me. Score. The guy was bursting with energy and you could see the joy on his face as we came through the door. He and his wife are ridiculously personable and nice. We chatted a couple of minutes and I learned they had 3 locations, all owned by different family members which to me was awesome.
My husband and I did the deal where you can get 2 slices of cheese and a fountain drink for 5 bucks. I would definitely do that again. It was so tasty, it was not dripping of oil by any stretch (which I loved) and the environment reminded me of the small hole in the wall pizzerias back in NY (where i’m from).

I decided to check out this place today since I was nearby and really wanted some pizza. As a long-​time fan of the Jerry’s in Longwood, I almost was obligated to try this as well, especially considering that all of the existing reviews are of the 5-​star variety. This Jerry’s location also had been among my «to try» Unilocal bookmarks for a while and I finally was able to cross it off the list today.
Jerry’s isn’t all that tough to find; it’s a few doors down from the Flanagan’s bar in the shopping center at the corner of S.R. 434 and S.R. 436 (the strip that has the Winn-​Dixie — I think? — in it). The best way to describe both the exterior and interior of the restaurant is as modest and nondescript; there’s nothing at all fancy about it. The Jerry’s in Longwood also is in a small shopping strip, but seems to be slightly more fancy than this one.
Don’t let the lack of flair dissuade you, though. The restaurant makes some very good pizza. I took advantage of the offer listed on a sign outside the front door, which mentioned a 2-​slices-​and-​a-​drink deal for $ 5. Many places around town do something similar, if not identical, so the price was right. I ordered one plain slice and one with pepperoni (one slice with a topping may have added $.20-$.30 to my total, but no big deal). Both were very tasty and what I was hoping to get. The crust was excellent (chewy and not crunchy/​too crispy, although it had the right amount of crispiness), the cheese was great and the pepperoni on the one slice was very good and had the right amount of spiciness.
The customer service was just fine — I was in & out of the shop in about five minutes, so it didn’t take long for my order to be fulfilled. The guy who took my order was polite and courteous.
If you live in this part of town or are just passing through, give this Jerry’s location a try. The slices I had today definitely reminded me of the pizza I’ve had in N.Y., and it looks like previous reviewers felt the same way. I still am not sure what the best pizza in town is, but the slices at Jerry’s definitely are in the running.