A Pie Stop

Really delightful and high quality baked goods! I asked several ignorant questions, and the lady at the counter could not have been kinder or more helpful! I asked for something that was not in the display case, and she actually went back and made me 2 cream pies to order in maybe 10 minutes. I was flabbergasted. Also, they actually know what pasties are, which impresses me. Delicious products made by lovely people at a reasonable price — what could be better?

I came by to get an afternoon snack after running some errands around town. A Pie Stop is located in a strip mall at the corner of Minnesota and Benson behind the City Diner and across from Carrs Aurora Village. The place was hard for me to notice since it is right by the side of Benson and I drive by here repeatedly as I tend to focus on heavy traffic approaching rather than look off to the right side driving east-​bound after grocery shopping at Carrs. After hearing the good reviews on this place, I decided to satisfy my sweet tooth and check this place out. The place has a cozy seating area for anyone wanting to stop in for a quick bite as well as several displays full of pies and desserts right by the cash register.
I saw one of my favorite pies: the Key Lime and it was fantastic. The pie itself was very silky and rich with the right amount of sweetness to go with the lime. It also had a creative display with a dollop of whipped cream and a slice of candied lime on top. The crust was flaky and tender and I literally finished this in just a few minutes. I ordered a slice of Dutch Apple Pie for later and this was also superb with a good amount of sliced apples, crumbles on top, and a rich filling with the distinct taste of butter and cinnamon.
Other delicious pies to choose from include Sweet Potato Pie (a popular flavor with a lot of people during the NC State Fair a couple of years ago), Rhubarb Pie, Whoopie Pie, Derby Pie (my cousin’s wife made an awesome Southern-​style version of this dish back in Raleigh, North Carolina), Bavarian Pear, Bluebarb (a combination of blueberry and rhubarb), Mincemeat Pie, Shoofly Pie, Sundae Pie, and the Turtle Pie. In addition to the pies, they also sell custards with flavors like Buttermilk, Egg, Coconut, Chess, and Lemon as well as daily special pot pies. Mon. is Chicken Pot Pie, Tues.-Bacon, Mac, and Cheese, Wed.-Pot Roast, Thurs.-Mexican, and Fri.-Seafood Pot Pie.
Another hidden gem I wish I had gone to sooner. The lady behind the counter bakes these pies fresh all day and if there is a flavor you don’t see on their menu, you can always call ahead to place a custom order and she will be happy to make it for you. This place is definitely an option for a sweet snack if I don’t feel like having ice cream or frozen yogurt. Speaking of ice cream, it can be added as an ala mode option for $ 2.00 more. Village Inn and Kriner’s has another strong competitor to face when it comes to delicious, homemade pies. I will come back to try the Sweet Potato and Derby Pie as well as show my support for local family-​owned businesses around town.

This is a great place especially if you are like me and cannot bake pies. Several times when I was a guest in someone’s home I brought a pie from here. You can buy a whole pie or just a slice. I always go when I am getting a whole pie but it’s nice to know I could get a piece just for me if I wanted.
The apple is my favorite but then I am not very adventurous. I brought a lemon meringue pie to someone’s house and it was beautiful. I was too full when they served dessert so didn’t have any but everyone said it was good. The Saturday before Easter I went in for an apple pie to take to my sister’s house. They said they didn’t make any that day. I was surprised but everyone liked the triple berry. I would like to try a Whoopi Pie since I never have but that will have to wait as I am trying to eat a little healthier.
As good as the dessert pies are they also make pot pies and pasties. I have not tried the pot pies but the pasties (meat pies without the gravy) are so good. They are as good as my mother used to make.
Both the ladies who own the place are great. Give them a try.
Remember they close at 4 on Saturday so go early.

Pies were very yummy! Customer service was good as well.
We got cherry pie which was nice and warm and would’ve been perfect with a scoop of ice cream (next time)
My only issue was the apple pie, they gave it to us cold. We were eating there and cold apple pie just wasn’t very good, it would’ve been much more enjoyable if they heated it before serving. Took home a savory pie and my dad loved it.

Stopped in on National Pie Day after reading the menu online, and I was determined to find out what was in a «Marion Berry» Pie. I was somewhat disappointed to find out one was not available when it was my turn at the counter. Perhaps I had misheard the clerk’s response of «we sold it» after making my request. «IT». Really? I’m staring at row upon row of pies behind you, yet there was only one of the type I requested? Like I said, perhaps I misheard. Anyway, so as not to depart empty handed after driving across town I purchased a triple berry pie which was very good with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and a spritz of cinnamon.

Stopped by last week for a slice of pie. The crust was phenomenal, apples were slightly crisp. It was bland though. Not enough cinnamon or butter in the filling. Pretty uninspiring. I am giving three stars for the excellent crust though. One thing lots of pie places seem to forget about. I was hoping for more pot pie options. I will probably try them again because I’m a stickler for pies.

So This Place is a GEM!
the Strawberry Rhubarb is WOW!
the Banana Cream Pie is the BOMB!
the Egg Custard is a Must have again!
All the pies are Great… these were our favorites thus far… we are planning a holiday order so it will be Great!
Thanks Ladies! You ROCK!

Really delicious pie and ice cream!!! My favorite was the peanut butter pie and the homemade ice cream, but everything else was delicious too. Definitely a must eat!!!

Pies are delicious! Menu has every pie you can imagine and taste like my mom’s homemade pies. Prices are so reasonable and worth every bit of it!

I came here on a weekday afternoon around 2 pm. They had run out of the pocket pies so I had the pot pie they had for the day, beef Mac and cheese. It wasn’t that good, it was pretty dry and Luke warm. Would’ve been better just as regular beef Mac and cheese. It was too much carbs with no sauce or cheese. And it was $ 7, not worth it bc it wasn’t that good. I also had their Dutch Apple pie a la mode, with their home made vanilla ice cream. This was MUCH BETTER! I would probably only come here again for their dessert pies, but they are a bit pricey: $ 5 for a slice, $ 22 for a whole. Their homemade ice cream was not creamy, more the texture of a sorbet. They also have some small candy bags for sale that come from out of state. I probably won’t be back unless I have a crazy pie craving. I’ll look for some other pie fixes in the meantime.

What a wonderful place to visit and get a piece of pie. I had the cherry, wonderful balance of sweet and tart. I’m not a big fan of sugar sweet pies, prefer to taste the fruit and if I need more sweet I add a scoop of ice cream :)
Looking forward to returning to try a pot pie or other lunch worthy item, maybe just another slice of pie.
Wonderful back-​story, be sure to ask how the partners met, came to AK to share their wonderful pie.

By far the BEST key lime pie ever! If key lime isn’t on your list the coconut cream, cherry and apple are to die for.

I was so Lookin forward to this place, told people about it. Finally got the chance to go here and picked up two chicken pot pies to go.
Started to eat them, crust wasn’t done, potatoes were crunchy. Called them back to inform them. There response was oh, ok. Thank you for letting us know.
Hope everybody has better experience cause this is a good idea for something off the beaten path.

This place is like walking into your grandma’s house. The smell is amazing and I was immediately sold. Once at the counter I ordered a pecan pie which was sitting in the display case. The register was having some issues starting up so while we waited I chatted with the two very kind women at the front. One of them asked me if I had ever had a whoopie pie, I knew my mom loved them but I never had one before. She gave me one on the house to try! Oh man, it was amazing. Initially I thought I wouldnt like it too much but when I took a bite it was like eating a cloud make out of chocolate and vanilla. I had to fight off my boyfriend for the last bite. Anyways, while we were talking one of the women mentioned that dutch apple pies had just came out of the oven (I learned dutch apple is the one with the crumbles on top) so i just couldnt resist. They were gracious in allowing me to switch to the super piping hot apple pie. Being from NY I am used to a larger price tag for quality, so the $ 22.00 didn’t deter me much. When he got home from work my boyfriend tried the pie before I did. Initially he had told me he didnt really like apple pie and he didnt look too excited. Well, after eating a few bites he looked at me and said «This is probably the best pie I have ever had». I felt the same! There were tons of apples inside not that jelly stuff, and it was spiced perfectly. You could tell it was homemade and those women really put their hearts into it. Its dangerous it is so close to my house because I am tempted to go back once a week! My boyfriend has even started asking whats the next flavor we are going to try, =)
We love you Pie Stop !

My dad and I tried the Triple Berry pie. We both concluded that more berries, less cornstarch and a flakier crust would have made it better. I’ll go back and try another flavor but as of our first visit, I feel I can make a better pie. $ 5 a slice is getting a little steep for just a jello like pie when you’re expecting fruit. Other than that it’s a cute little shop decently decorated and smells heavenly. They do espresso but could use some cold beverage cups in addition to hot beverage cups. Still in the works but I’m excited to see how this business grows.

I won a certificate for a free pie through a radio station. This place is now on my list of places to stay away from because I would go broke and get way too fat. The banana cream pie was amazing and I cant wait to go back for more!!!

I’ve stopped by here a couple of times. The lady there is really nice! Thanks for the delicious key lime pie :)

I’ve been hearing about this place on the radio a lot and was excited to try it. Had their lemon meringue on «pi» day that someone had brought into work. Loved how firm it was and oh so tasty.
We then dropped by to pick up a pie for dessert this weekend. We got the peanut butter pie, which is their signature pie. Oh boy! So pretty I «almost» didn’t want to eat it. Unlike many of the peanut butter pies I’ve had, this one is quite delicate and dainty. Peanut butter filling is light and topped off in mounds of wonderful whipped cream goodness. Crust is tasty as well and keeps firm.
Can’t wait to go back and try more. And service is great! Wonderful ladies that work the shop!

I decided to stop by this place with a couple of friends after finding out about it through the local news. This pie shop currently resides in what used to be Superstar Pastry Design. The interior was nicely decorated and there was a simple arrangement of several tables and chairs. The menu itself is simple as well, as you have the option to purchase an entire pie, a slice, or a savory pot pie. According to their website, they also have a DIY cupcake bar, although I didn’t happen to see any indication of that while visiting. I did happen to catch a glimpse of a few whoopie pies and an espresso machine though.
I opted to try a slice of pecan pie, while my friends chose chocolate cream and coconut custard pies. Mine was pretty fantastic, with a sweet and gooey base underneath and a crisp and nutty top layer. The crust was pleasantly flaky and buttery and the homemade qualities of the pie really stood out to me. One friend didn’t care much for his coconut custard, although the other friend seemed to really enjoy the chocolate cream, as he probably finished it off in the span of a minute or two.
The staff was very friendly as well. It is apparent that this is a family-​run business and they take pride in their product. At $ 5 a slice, I was a bit wary at first, but I ended up completely satisfied and not too sugared-​out. Lastly, their website indicates that they are willing to accommodate for parties and other special events – something I’ll have to make note of for the future. It’s nice to have a place in town that specializes in what I feel like is an underappreciated dessert. I’d be more than happy to revisit A Pie Stop as long as I can maintain my girlish figure and I’ll probably update this review once I sample one of their pot pies.