Wally’s Wicked Good Ice Cream and Treats

Look no further for a satisfying scoop or two or three! Wally’s has awesome flavors. Their cookie dough and cookies and cream is by far the best around. Wally’s gives you the biggest pieces of cookie dough and oreo I’ve had around Newton. Rancatore’s is awfully skimpy on cookie dough in comparison. Coconut almond is chock full of coconut not bland like JP Lick’s. The Graham Central Station is loaded with toffee and graham cracker goodness.

Great service, reasonable prices, and amazing ice cream. You can’t go wrong with Wally’s! I have never had a bad experience at Wally’s and would highly recommend that all ice cream lovers stop by. There are many flavor options and you really can’t go wrong with any of them. Ultimately the prices are fair in relation to any place that is offering such high quality, delectable ice cream. Much love Wally’s!

Made a quick family pit stop while biking, fresh smoothies with actual fruit! and delicious ice cream, lots of variety and the staff is more than willing to let you try it. Only downside is it’s a little pricy but your getting great quality product for the price. Outdoor seating available

I was craving a smoothie so I stopped in as its around the corner from me. The website says the smoothies are made with fat free frozen yogurt and fresh fruit. They were out of froyo so the girl working asked if it was OK to use vanilla ice cream and I said sure (it tasted good, it was just more of a milkshake than a smoothie) the «fresh fruit» was obviously frozen fruit that had been thawed. Also they pumped strawberry flavoring into the drink, which I thought was weird. The worst part was that the thing cost $ 6.69. Overall it was good, but not quite what I was looking for and I’m not sure I’d go back

Wally’s was wicked good. Extreme chocolate was pretty intense. Decent variety quality ice cream. I keep 5 stars reserved for I’ve cream shops that make their own ice cream. But this place is great to go with the kids.

Great neighborhood stop, and absolutely necessary. Auburndale would be nothing without this little gem that always has some interesting flavor to taste.
Ice cream seems of average quality, but it always hits the spot. Good portions, GREAT selection of interesting flavors.
The staff is also super nice. For a bunch of teenagers who have to scoop all day, they always have a smile and are SO patient with requests to try every flavor.

Wally’s ice cream is wicked good and rich in flavor.
This place is located in the ‘burbs of Auburndale, Newton. The only reason why you’d be around is either because you have business to do in Auburndale or you live here as there’s absolutely nothing interesting around. I work a few doors down from this place, hence the visit.
A small cup will cost you ~$ 3.
It’s true, this place is run by teens during the summer. The boy was rather rude and had a «I totally wish I was elsewhere» attitude as my bf expressed interest in trying several of their flavors.
Overall, this place needs a more frequent wipe down of every table and seat as ours had sticky residues. Otherwise, the flavors are abundant with funky names and a favorite with youngsters and oldies a like.

I saw all of the good reviews and went in to try it out. Everything was fine until they saw I had plugged my phone into the outlet next to the table and the lady there started yelling at me. I’ve never had that happen before. If the outlet is open next to a table it’s generally ok to use. Anyway there are a lot of good ice cream places where I don’t have to deal with rude people.

Wally’s has some of the best gourmet ice cream in the Auburndale area. Generous sizes and friendly staff. They are closed during the winter months but open early in the spring. I can’t wait for their double chocolate ice cream… my goodness. creamy goodness indeed. Parking in this area can be a challenge but do not give up. It’s worth it.

Try their version of a Chipwich! The cookies are awesome and so is the ice cream. I got it with chocolate and it was delicious.
Great little ice cream shop. The ice cream is tasty, there are a few tables, and there are some toy ice cream things for kids to play with.
The downsides? The girl working there when we went didn’t seem very happy or welcoming and she gave my husband the wrong flavor. Also wish there was some self-​serve water.

I love this place. The ice cream is top notch and the kids who work there are always very friendly. They do get slammed in the summer sometimes when the youth sports teams finish practice.
The woman who owns the store is also one of the nicest businesswomen I’ve met. She even reopened the store after hours when a friend and I were craving some late-​night ice cream and were bummed that Wally’s had closed 20 minutes prior.

Totally psyched there’s an independent ice cream shop in my new neighborhood! And it’s great! Love the name, of course, and the flavors are varied and look pretty inventive. So far I’ve only had the PB fudge frozen yogurt (decadent, hardly diet-​tasting) and the lemon sorbet. Both were excellent. Lone teenage employee was friendly enough and well-​trained to answer questions. Hip-​hop on the PA was questionable, but then again, I’m old.
Kiddie size comes in a sort of milkshake lid thing, one small scoop for ~ $ 2.50; just about perfect. Bottled water seemed a bit on the expensive side and I didn’t see a tap water jug like many ice cream parlors offer, which is a shame. Ice cream makes ya thirsty!
Nicely designed merchandising display with ice-​cream related homegoods, T-​shirts and other small gifts is cute… shop is tiny but well laid-​out and the outdoor tables, while limited, are a sweet touch for a summer-​oriented business.

There is a good amount of ice cream choices here. With the latest froyo trend, I wish they would have more choices with froyo– as it is delicious and healthier than ice cream. The staff is always quick and friendly. My biggest gripe is that there is no medium size here. The small is always too small for me, and the large is too filling. There is a huge difference in sizing in the cups and I think they should definitely offer an in-​between size!

An adorable local ice cream shop with delicious desserts, and not just ice cream — sorbet, frozen yogurt, frappes, raspberry lime rickeys, ice cream sandwiches, things for your dog, the list goes on and on. They’ll let you taste anything you want, and the staff couldn’t be friendlier.

The employees are all SO FRIENDLY!
Graham central station ice cream is amazing. I am a s’mores fanatic, so I get gcs ice cream, marshmallow, and chocolate jimmies. Best ice cream ever.
Also, the parking situation is great as there is on street parking right in front or a lot just around the corner.

This place has the best ice cream and frozen yogurt in the area. The staff and owners are so friendly and the atmosphere is really happy and bright. The only downfall about this place is that it is closed for most of the winter months. For a girl that likes ice cream any time of year, this is not the best thing! But, I still wouldn’t choose to go anywhere else to indulge:)

I guess I am the wrong person to be writing this, since I do not like ice cream! I would take my son here when it was Ice Cream Club for ice cream a few times during the summer. We stopped in last night because I promised him ice cream, he got a Kahula Chip cone, 3 scoops (a small!!) and I got a kids cone of rum raisin which was 2 scoops and way too much ice cream for me. Both were good and creamy, tasted the same as when It was Ice Cream Club.

This is much better than the previous place. The kids working there are delightful!

When Wally’s opened in my neighborhood I knew I had to give it a try. The store is bright and colorful, and the kids behind the counter were friendly and helpful.
I had a lemon sorbet and it was delicious. There were real pieces of lemon zest in the sorbet. I wish they had more flavors of ices or sorbet, but the ones they have are great so I can’t really complain. I know I’ll be a regular this summer.

Not much different than the previous ice cream establishment that had been there. The décor isn’t as nice but everything else is basically the same. The staff seems friendly but some of the kids they have working there could definitely speed it up.
Their prices are a bit too high as well ($ 5 for a frappé) but the ice cream is good quality. There are only about two or three tables inside to sit in and two outside but there are also benches around Auburndale to sit on as well.
Street parking is available, as is parking in the public parking lot just behind the store.