Thats Amore Pizza

Pizzas ok. A little pricey. Staff not that friendly. I would honestly recommend satellite over this place. Satellite is around the same price but definitely worth it

Great pizza, love that I can get a small pie for two people it’s great. Fast service.

This is good little pizza place in Bayport. The pizza is excellent. The crust is firm and chewy, not too crispy and not too soft. The sauce is perfect and the pies I’ve had have always been good. I’ve come here many times, ordered the old antipasto salad, which is always good and fresh, and I’ve also gotten heroes. The meatball parm is excellent as is sausage and peppers. My daughter and I both love the garlic knots.
Bonus points– this place delivers to my apartment on the Blue Point-​Patchogue line. Delivery seems to be a rarity in this area so that got me trying them, but the food is good so I keep coming back.
There was one glitch, several weeks ago– I called on a rainy night for delivery and apparently so did everyone else. The delivery took well over an hour and my pizza was cold when it arrived. Not a huge deal– I warmed it in my oven, but disappointing nonetheless.
Overall, I’ve ordered delivery, picked up, and eaten in countless times, and the quality is excellent.

Being someone who has tried many authentic NY pizzas from Manhattan to Montauk, That’s Amore is the best on the south shore in the area. Their Sicilian pizza is the right amount of doughy and crispness and their sauce is delish– not greasy, not too garlicky– just perfect. Definitely recommend them over any of the other pizza restaurants in the area!

This is one of four pizza joints in Bayport. In regards to their slice it is the best of the four. Tony uses all fresh ingredients in his sauce and it’s 100% homemade, unlike others that use canned sauces and sugar.
Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed

Solid Pizza /​Italian
Small place on Montauk Highway that is hard to see due to the location in the shopping center it sits in, the food turned out to be a pleasant surprise here.
Owner /​operator is present and cooks in the back while decent help works the counter– there were four of us and we all ordered entrée’s and everything came out freshly prepared and nice large portion sizes.
Prices are average and food is fresh and good– give it a shot!
Parking in shopping center lot.

Gave this spot a few chances but it is at best very underwhelming. The pizza isn’t terrible, but not very good either. The eggplant parm was terrible. It tasted as if it was pre packaged and frozen for months. I’ve had better frozen eggplant from Costco. It was more like soggy cakes of breading rather than any real eggplant. I want to give this place a shot but just go to Satellite. It’s much better and basically the same price.

As one of the only pizza places in the area that delivers– the pizza is fresh and delicious. My family and I are large supporters of Satellite and Furccis however without delivery, That’s Amore will keep getting the call!

Great service, very clean place with great menus. TV big screen inside and on the patio.

Really enjoyed the food an service here. They have an extensive menu. The employees are friendly and fast.