Popularity Pops

Honestly I’m surprised this place has such high reviews, though the pops are fun to look at and the shop is an original concept, the treats are underwhelming and overpriced. If I’m going to indulge, I’d rather have a regular old ice cream cone or cup of fro-​yo. I ordered the mint chip pop and thought it tasted a little like toothpaste and I normally love mint chocolate chip ice cream. My boyfriend ordered the pistachio pop and his was a little better. Either way, I don’t think I’ll be back here.

On an island where everyone sells the same Ice cream brand pops stands out. Very fresh very clean! The maple bacon pop was great. All our kids love it here!

My favorite! The best way to end a day or a barbecue! The other ice cream joint just cannot compete. Closed now for winter how sad!

Really cute and trendy Popsicle shop in Beach Haven. Stopped by on a hot summer day to cool off after playing mini golf at Mr. Tee’s across the street.
Pros:
–Multiple flavors to choose from
–Made from homemade gelato
–Have a couple of diary free options
Cons:
–Very limited seating
–Kind of expensive for the small size of the pop ($ 4)
Overall, worth a visit if in the area!

Oh wow. This was startlingly good. I love –love-​love ice cream. I had a mint chocolate chip ice cream pop and the taste made my tastebuds tingle. it was exactly right. minty. chocolaty goodness. my friend and brother also had a couple of pops and agreed. great choice.

Great creamy pops but most impressed by the help. She mistakenly overcharged me and came across the street to where I was sitting to give me back money. Have never experienced that in my life!

The «POPS» are definitely 5 star! Unfortunately cannot say the same for sales help! Have been there several times and the young blond girl has a snippy attitude and demeanor ! Sure does not make for a pleasant experience.

Stopped on a Sunday night for our first time. Small little place, no inside seating, a few chairs outside. Very friendly girl at the counter was very helpful and shared her thoughts on her favorite flavors. We got a chocolate habenero and mint chocolate chip. Eaten fast because they were both delicious and melting. $ 4 a pop. Not bad for my husband and I, but won’t be a place to take 5 kids on a regular basis. A unique place.

Really cool looking pops and REALLY GOOD! I think I just found my new tradition on the island. I had a Nutella pop, it was sprinkled with pretzels. Very yummy.

This place was cute and fun. No place to sit and it is $ 4.00 for a pop. Colorful and cool place to stop and check out.

I’m a convert to gelato Popsicles! This store has an incredible variety of pops. You can get anything from birthday cake to chocolate to pistachio. The flavor is spot on. I had the habanero chocolate dipped in dark chocolate and it was dynamite. It started off with deep chocolate flavor and then the burn snuck up on me. We’re coming back!

This place ROCKS! Gelato pops with amazing flavors and toppings. Great size as not too big, not too small. $ 4 any flavor. Cute décor inside. Will be a favorite for us this summer! The salt on the salts Carmel Pop makes it. Delish. The marshmallows in the s’mores one is an awesome add too.

LOVE — LOVE — LOVE
We have been here practically every weekend. The flavors and toppings are endless. They are the right price, right size and so delicious. The staff is just so incredible and fun. The t-​shirts and sunnies are great too. Try them. you will be back!!!

Great little place, wish it wasn’t so far down the island, since we are in Manahawkin. But if your out that way, eating at at Chegg perhaps, go another 2 blocks down & grab a Gelato pop. The owner helped us & was VERY nice, however they close today (⁸⁄₃₁) for the season. They have lots of fun flavors like Nutella dipped in pretzel and s’mores. They also have a fun polkadot selfie wall and encourage you to # them. So hopefully they’re back next season, because I discovered them a little too late.

This is the only place on the island that makes their own products, and they’re god damn great at it. Try their fruit and gelato pops, which are really good.
We’ve been looking for years and finally found a business gutsy enough to make their own stuff.
As much as my friends and I enjoy the mom-​and-​pop ice cream parlors on LBI, its never home-​made and they end up being either Turkey Hill or Breyer’s. What’s the enjoyment in generic crap that you can get at the CVS back in the the city a block from my apartment?
They’re great people and service and I hope they stay in business for the years to come so I can go back every summer.

Neat new place on LBI that serves gluten free popsicles that are just the right size. The flavors are great and there’s a wide selection. Plus who’d have thought you can add toppings to popsciles?! Very cool place with friendly staff and affordable prices.

My fiancé and I grabbed pops from here a couple weekends ago. They have a ton of great flavors to choose from. It was pretty hot out, so I probably should have gotten a fruit flavored one, but I love gelato, so I wound up ordering the Salted Caramel, while my fiancé ordered the Chocolate Peanut Butter.
They were very tasty popsicles. They definitely had the richness effect you expect from gelato, and I thought the flavos were very nicely done. They held up pretty well in the heat too which is always a plus.
The location isn’t really conducive to a lot of traffic, so I think they may have a tough time of it. Also, 4 dollars for a Popsicle is pretty steep. Its worth a stop in at least to try it, but I cant say Ill be back frequently with so many great ice cream shops to choose from on LBI.

Great spot!
Fun place and great choices
Amaretto is a real winner
Fair prices all things considered

This place is fantastic! I got the coconut pop which came with shredded coconut on it. The other people I was with got the special which was chocolate– peanut butter and the salted caramel. The pops were $ 4/​each which is reasonable. I was slightly overwhelmed by all of the options, which just means that I’ll have to return because I’m very curious about the s’mores, cookies and cream, coffee, and amaretto.

Had a mango pop. It was oh so delish. Chocolate was very rich and creamy. Mixed berry really refreshing and not too sweet. Absolutely will return to have another pop. All flavors looked interesting.