Cafe Sicilia

Very good pizza. Like a lot of local independent Italian restaurants Café Sicilia uses Lisanti Foods as their pizza ingredient distributor. If you are familiar with Lisanti, then you will already kind of know what to expect from their pizza but they do it really well. I got a cheese and a pepperoni/​black olive combo for carryout. Both were excellent and I plan to go back.

My husband and I always get the seafood lasagna, it’s great! The dinner rolls are great too and I love their house salad dressing so much, I always order some to take home. The only thing I don’t like is the location. Its right by a laundromat.

It was okay. I got a calzone. Can’t screw that up. Kids got chicken parm… I guess it was okay. Hubs got the fettuccine with shrimp. He said the shrimp was the saving grace. It lacked flavor.
Our server wasn’t bad till a large party came then we were forgotten. Salad never came, and garlic rolls never put it. He said the bread that was given was free. And? We ASKED for GARLIC ROLLS not bread. End of the meal got the check and sat there and waited for him to take the payment. Never happened. As a customer why do I need to get up and pay? That drives me nuts! It’s a sit down restaurant…
I’m pretty sure it’ll be the first and last trip. To each is own.

Ate lunch here today for the first time. Food was really good. The pesto and marinara were very tasty. The service was great and the whole staff were very nice to us. I will differently eat here again and so should you.

One of my favorite local owned Italian aside from Savianos and Lissanos. Simple and generous size portions. I always get the clam linguine but their seafood fetuccine does not disappoint. Plenty of cream and bits of seafood. Very rich dishes. I also like their free rolls. The time to get the food is a bit long but I ordered to go this time. They often have groupons but dine in only. Bummer

This place is fabulous. The portions are very good sized and very fresh tasting. It is BYOB.

I appreciate the customer service from the owner for what was a disappointing Christmas meal experience. He called me personally and listened to my side and then explained his side, civilly. Apparently, misunderstandings about the literacy of the menu and the assumed expectations of the customer laid too far apart for mutual gratification. However, compensation was offered and accepted; and those that enjoy the food will enjoy the owner’s considerations too. My parents enjoy eating there and will continue I’m sure.

found this cute little place last night and I have got to say it was amazing!!! food and service was an A+++++ our server was sweet and overall very helpful with giving us wonderful service. I will definitely be coming back to this place it was definitely worth it!!!

Great food even GREATER customer service! The food was wonderful! I ordered seafood fettuccine and I could taste meat in every bite. Not only was the food excellent and a short wait, the waiter blew us away with his attentive service. Definitely a must-​go to place!!!

I have been here a few times because of their groupon specials. I always order the same thing, and it’s been consistent. The first thing they serve you is fresh warm bread. The soft fluffy center is complimented with the crispy crust. Even though I prefer my bread with EVOO and freshly cracked black pepper, but the soft butter packets ok. We ordered a country salad for one with house country dressing. The salad was fresh, and the portion size is big enough for 2. We also ordered the large veggie pizza. The crust is thin and crispy (probably my favorite part of the pizza), the veggies are nicely spread out, and topped with generous portion of mozzarella cheese. Delicious! Overall, great food and awesome customer service. Will definitely keep coming back!

This place is fantastic. Lunch is dirt cheap, $ 6 – 7.50 for salad, entre, and drink before 3pm!
My favorite is the Pasta Treat, which is three different kinds of cheese filled pasta, drowning in their «Pink Sauce» which I believe is marinara mixed with Alfredo.
If your food is covered in this «crack sauce» as I like to call it, it will for sure be a hit! The first time I went, I had chicken Marsala, which I’m not really a fan of anyways, but my husband wanted to split it, so I agreed. It was definitely not my favorite thing, but every single other thing I’ve ever eaten here, I have enjoyed. The Caesar dressing is a little sweet for my taste, but it’s still pretty good!
The service is AWESOME here, and very very personal. They make you feel like family.

recently came here for take out, since I was really craving some Italian food. I am relatively new to the area, and saw that Café Sicilia had consistently good reviews.
the staff is very sweet, and the interior is great. I ordered a 14 inch medium white pizza with sausage, pepperoni, and hamburger; tortellini Michelangelo; and a cannoli and their Nutella cheesecake.
my little brother and I loved the pizza, and the white sauce. the tortellini was okay, albeit the sauce seemed a little watery. the cheese stuffed inside the tortellini was kind of tasteless. I added chicken to my order for an additional cost; pretty small chunks as opposed to the larger strips of grilled chicken I was imagining, but it was there. not bad though, the flavor itself was great! just could’ve been a little better. the garlic bread it came with was a bit hard.
I’ll probably be back for the pizza (unless someone insists on a particularly great entrée), but not go out of my way again. worth a try!

I’m not sure if it’s just me, or it was just a bad day to go. I live in the apartment community across the street and figured why not? I got a Groupon for it as well.
I went, and just to keep it simple it all tasted like they went to the Walmart down the street to pick up the ingredients. Unthawed them, and served them on a plate. Not the best food. My salad had great lettuce but the house Caesar dressing tasted like water.
I got the chicken parmigiana. If that’s what you want to call it. The noodles were watery, and the chicken tastes like chuck wagon. The SAUCE was very very good!
The atmosphere though! Amazing! It looks great in there. In sure the wine is fools.

Kicking myself for not visiting Café Sicilia sooner, as I live only about a mile away. Finally saw a Groupon and decided I had to try it. What a neighborhood gem it turned out to be. Bring your own bottle of Chianti for a delicious and affordable Italian dinner!
At the start of your meal, they bring you a basket with enormous freshly-​baked rolls. While I didn’t need the extra carbs, I couldn’t resist polishing off one of these warm, savory beauties, which are excellent with a pat of butter. To start we ordered the country salad for two, which was really big enough for three or four. The house-​made Italian dressing gave life to the artichoke hearts, lettuce and other assorted fresh vegetables.
For dinner I asked our server to recommend one of the chicken dishes, and she pointed to the chicken rollatini, a customer favorite. Excellent choice, although you’ll need to spend some extra time on the treadmill after dinner. The centerpiece of the dish is a chicken fillet stuffed with gooey mozzarella, served over a generous portion of fettucine. I wasn’t sure I liked the sound of «famous pink sauce», as it sounded vaguely artificial, but it turned out to be really rich and delicious — I would guess it’s made from tomato sauce and cream. I’m really picky about pasta, but mine was perfectly al dente. The service was warm and attentive — after our failed attempt to finish our meal, our server boxed and bagged our leftovers for us. Overall, a very nice meal!

Located in a small strip mall in a small apartment community but don’t be fooled by the location. The restaurant offers beautiful Italian music and hand painted murals of the old country. The small dinning room provides for a beautiful dinning experience with the grapevines growing along the top of the roof.
It is owned and operated by a beautiful family who have ties back to the old country and true to the families in the old country they treat you as family.
They encourage you to bring the wine of your choice and will help pare your wine with a particular dish. If you don’t have a wine or want a particular wine for your dish, I encourage you to stop in at Silver Dollar Winery located just East a couple blocks. They have a nice selection of wines to choose from.
The menu offers a variety a salads to choose from as well as an extensive selection of pasta (s) and sauces. All of which are homemade and taste fabulous. You can choose from dishes with veal, chicken, seafood, and vegetarian.
The have several options for those who like to finish the evening with a nice dessert. I personally didn’t order any desserts but I encourage you to try one that speaks to you.
Excellent service, fabulous food and awesome prices.

My husband and I just recently moved to the Bedford area and were looking for a nice italian place to go to that was not super expensive. Café Sicilia has great reviews so we thought we would try it out. One of my favorite things is that it’s BYOB. I give it 3 stars for location and atmosphere. It feels like you are eating in little Italy in NY. Very cute place. The food is OK, nothing to get excited about. My husband had the lasagna and I had the Rigatoni Vodka. The lasagna was good and tasted homemade but I felt mine was way to greasy and didn’t taste great.
All in all it was a nice evening, the wait staff is very kind and continued to check up on us. We will be back and I will try something new this time!

Best Italian food around
Big portions quiet and comfortable atmosphere
Try the Spumoni if you like sweets
Rigatoni with sausage was so good, marinara was perfectly spiced with a hint of sugar.
Pre meal bread was so tasty It made me want to try the pizza next time
I will be back soon.

Took the kiddos there for pizza. Loved and was super surprised at the size and deliciousness of the garlic rolls-​whole family loved them. Had the mozzarella stick appetizer and were served hot and gooey fresh with good, authentic marinara. Got a small cheese pizza for the boys and it was a generous size-​had leftovers and even for a cheese pizza, it was good and seasoned. Adults had pepperoni, jalapeño and bacon medium sized. Was quite good and we really thought their bacon had a smoker, richer flavor than most.
Paid $ 50 for 5 people including tip, an appetizer, and brought home lots of leftover pizza
Overall we really feel like we found a gem. Are looking forward to returning and trying the pasta dishes. Seating was full and busy, clear that the locals have known about this secret yumminess for a while!

Chicken parm, calzone & 2 sodas for lunch. Aprox $ 20.
Food was so-​so. Chicken was not fresh and didn’t taste like breast meat. Not much meat in the calzone. Food was luke warm. Salad dressing was weird, like pizza sauce. Rolls were the best part of the meal.
If in the area I would try again but wouldn’t go out of my way.

WOW… Where to begin. Service was amazing. From the beginning, we had no reservation and the place was packed. They were able to clear everything quickly after one family left and got us sitting in minutes of waiting. We had 4 adults, 2 teens and 2 toddlers. Unlike other places that make you wait a half hour or longer. The key to a great waiter is never letting the customer sit there and wait for their drinks to be refilled, they did exactly that. The servers checked on us in a timely manner being respectful, and they even had 3 – 4 people helping us at one time just to take our orders and serve us. Excellent.
The food… let’s just say I found my new Italian restaurant. We ordered the Artichoke, Stuffed Mushrooms and the Calamari. All were exceptional. The calamari appetizer isn’t your ordinary calamari. It disappeared before I could get a picture. Very well cooked, and perfect texture. The rolls? Deadly! Honestly, you can’t just eat one! The main courses that we all had? We couldn’t stop saying «Mmmmm.» We ordered the Seafood Fetticuine. the best I’ve ever had. Chunks of seafood!!! The Stuffed chicken «Rittaloni”(not sure the name, sorry we left already) but the one who ate it said it was simply the best Italian dish he’s ever tried! The small pizza (wasn’t that small) was awesome! The calzone was just as good as everything else! For Deseret we ordered a dozen mini Canoli’s… Although I saw them serve a cheesecake that looked amazing as well. However The Canoli’s? Icing on the cake. They were delicious.
If you like Italian, this place will suit your needs! I can’t say enough. By the looks of the pictures I took, it speaks volume already. I will definitely be back and also recommend this place to all my friends!
Thank you Café Sicilia! Bellissimo… (Don’t know what that means, but it just sounds right!)