Karen’s Cookies

Second time ordering from Karen’s, and both have been wonderful experiences. For my younger son’s birthday last year she was so open to my suggestions and input for a superhero themed cupcake! Ultimately, decided on Captain America shield-​just sorry I didn’t take a photo of them first. They were beautiful and tasty! And just today I happened to stop in to see if I might pick up a few extra goodies for my older son’s birthday party-​he requested brownies at the last minute. When I saw they did not have enough of what I wanted, they very kindly offered to make what I needed. Karen (the baker, I think) was clearly busy baking in the back, but said she would make a quick order right away for me. Just what one looks for in a local/​neighborhood spot! I am all for supporting our community, and being a small business, I think they’re doing the best they can, and doing right by their neighbors. Keep up the yummy work, Karen! We need more local and homey businesses to stay around town.

Karen’s Cookies is the best! What a wonderful addition to downtown Berkeley Heights! Karen is an amazingly talented cookie, cake, and cupcake decorator. She has lots of great stuff in the case in the store (incredible chocolate chip cookies, red velvet cupcakes, her grandma’s famous cheesecake minis are amazing, cake pops, and SO MUCH MORE!) and she has an amazing variety of things available for special order. PLUS Karen is a kind a gracious person — so great to have this little jewel of a bakery in town.

Yummy Yummy Yummy, Karen make the BEST COOKIES!
everytime I am in there, you can smell the cupcakes, the cookies, the sweet goodness!
They are SO nice in there. best cookie presentation. And please give me permission to rant about the COOKIE DOUGH CAKE POPS??? I COULD EAT EVERY SINGLE ONE. Speaking of which. I just had one today! lol so stop by and grab a cookie and a cupcake and you will have a great day! trust me, you will.