Perfectly Scrumptious

I first met Amanda in 2014 when I was looking for somebody to do the cake for my wedding. Before we even signed up for a taste testing we took some cupcakes home and we were SOLD. We did the mini cupcakes in all different flavors (my fav is the salted caramel, it’s to die for) and they were a huge hit at our wedding. It’s been almost a year and were looking forward to opening our Bride and Groom cake pops from Amanda that we froze for our first anniversary. Aside from an amazing product and the cutest little shop, Amanda is an amazingly sweet person with a fantastic personality. Such a pleasure to work with we will never forget how much greater she helped to make our big day

Had the delicious cupcakes for a dinner party last night! Really nice dessert selection, pretty and very fresh, we bought a dozen and had no leftovers. The girl at the store (my only complaint was they needed signage outside) was delightful ! It shares a space with an adorable ice cream shop. Thank you and we will be back for more!

I was disappointed in the selection available. There was only about 5 choices. I got the salted caramel and another chocolate cupcake with white icing and colored sprinkles. Both of the cupcakes were on the dry side. Since both of them were dry I can’t be sure if that’s the way they always are or I just got a couple of old ones. The icing on the salted caramel one was fabulous! The other one was nothing special. I’d visit again because there were many flavors on their brochure I’d love to try.

Amanda is AWESOME!
Lori and I absolutely loved working with her. The ONLY thing we were disappointed about was that she came and set everything up the day of our wedding well before the reception and we didn’t get a chance to thank her again in person :(
But EVERYTHING was amazing — from the taste test to the beautiful display she set up.
The one main thing that people should know is that Amanda was very comfortable with mixing both regular and gluten-​free cupcakes for our wedding. She even put different liners on the gluten-​free ones so Lori and several of our friends would know exactly which ones they could have. This was just perfect!
And oh the cupcakes themselves tasted amazing… you might even say they were perfectly scrumptious ;)
Thanks again amanda!
Ryan & Lori

I gotten my wedding cupcakes, a friend’s baby shower cupcakes, and cupcakes for a St. Patrick’s Day party from Perfectly Scrumptious. I also stop by whenever I am in the area. I have had her cupcakes (regular, giant, and mini size), and cake pops, and chocolate covered Oreos. Everything is amazing. Amanda worked with me for every occasion to make sure the cupcakes were absolutely perfect and matched my colors and themes exactly. The cupcakes are incredibly dense and rich — the best cupcakes I’ve ever eaten. I also love the variety of flavors — my favorites are Irish Car Bomb, Chocolate Coconut, Key Lime, Carrot Cake, and Hot Fudge Brownie! She is a business owner who actually cares about her customers, and goes way above and beyond.

My family and I just gorged on cupcakes. The salted caramel are to die for!!! Also had the red velvet, which I am normally not a fan, soooo delish! We loved it so much we ordered more for tomorrow! The owner is sooo friendly and accommodating, we will make this a regular stop whenever we are in town!

I found Perfectly Scrumtious by chance while looking for a local bakeries in Bonita Springs. I was attending a company meeting and needed a sweet treat to provide during a breakfast meeting. I’m so glad I found Amanda! I was looking for a breakfast themed treat and her Pancakes and Bacon and Almond French Toast cupcakes fit the bill! I contacted Amanda via e-​mail outlining what I was looking for and she immediately replied. When we spoke the next day, she walked me through her cupcake flavors, provided some suggestions and in 10 minutes I had ordered 4 dozen cupcakes! The cupcakes were out of this world! One co-​worker quoted the the Pancakes and Bacon cupcake as «the best cupcake I have ever eaten.» The Almond French Toast tasted exactly like a piece of French toast. I don’t know how she does it but it was amazing. I was not able to taste the other flavors-​chocolate covered banana and cinnamon apple streusel but they looked delicious. The presentation was beautiful– Amanda wrapped each cupcake individually with her signature colors. She even delivered them to me at the hotel! I couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

I have never felt compelled to write a review in the past, but joined Unilocal today to post this review. This is the best and most friendly cupcake shop we have ever been to. My daughter had the vanilla and chocolate peanut butter cupcakes. The cupcakes were moist and decorated beautifully. The owner, Amanda, was one of the kindest and most genuine people I have ever met. Since she was featured on Cupcake Wars, my kids wanted a picture with her, and she was sweet enough to oblige. This is a place not to miss when you are in the area. Thanks for the great cupcakes and a perfect experience!

Go here and get cake pops! Best ever –moist, rich and super cute bouquet presentation. Will be the hit of your next party.