Fuhgidabowdit Pizzeria 2

This place is fantastic! I just moved to Brighton so I am really glad I found this place. I ordered a lasagna pinweel, a large pepperoni pizza, some stuffed shells, and some cannolis for my fiancée and I. They delivered the food within about 45 minutes and the delivery driver was great. Everything that we ordered was great. I will definitely be ordering from this place again!

The worst pizza experience ever! Like really! I want to «forget about it» but $ 41 on a pile of junk is a pretty hard hit to forget! Not to forget the sickness and the costs associated after consuming contaminated raw dough and sauce and toppings.

Great family restaurant! The best ingredients in traditional pizza. The Italian sausage and meatball appetizers begin a wonderful Italian meal. We like to order ahead for the appetizers, the pizza is made from scratch and takes some time. Worth it!

I can honestly say I’ve never had a worse lunch than the garbage that I just received from this place. After waiting an hour and a half for a delivery to my house — literally down the street — what showed up was a soggy calzone that looked like a flaccid, cold, floppy, pile of bad decisions. The ricotta was chewy, the mushrooms were undoubtedly from a can, the dough was tasteless and far too thin, and the tomato sauce on the side was watery and wouldn’t even stack up to a store bought marinara.
The parmesan garlic wings were literally floating in buttery grease and were far less appetizing than offbrand canned cat food.
I will certainly never waste another dime at this establishment, and I wish I could understand how anybody would allow food that disgraceful to leave their kitchen.
I give this restaurant 2 thumbs down, and wish there was an option for zero stars. What a joke.
Edit: my stomach is now in knots. Not only was the food horrendous, but it has made me sick.

I grew up in the NJ and NY area. I have been out here for over 30 years. It certainly was culture shock as far as food is concerned. For a long time my wife and I have searched for pizza remotely close to what we consider excellent. About 6 months ago a friend turned me onto this place. We reluctantly placed an order for a large pizza half sausage. I couldn’t believe that out here in Brighton this place was turning out the best pizza I have had the pleasure to enjoy with a gigantic smile on my face. Since that first time, we have not missed a week with a to go pizza from this place. One word of advice. If you like the pizzeria you go to now, don’t try this place. The reason being, is you will never go back to that place again! Enjoy, this pizza is the real deal.

Tasty pizza with nice veggie toppings, nice crispy crust. Guy at the counter «feels the veggie struggle» and hooked me up with a lot of extra veggies for less than the full price (literally got every single non-​meat topping except for pineapple, still ended up very reasonable with the lunch special). Slice needed extra garlic powder, oregano, and parmesean sprinkles, but very tasty once added. Good service, although was very empty. Very pleased and would eat there again.

Average pizza. Nothing special. Cheap price for lunch special.

My GPS suggested this as a stop driving through Denver.
Staff was pleasant and friendly, stopping by to chat and eagerly gave the history of the place when asked.
But the pizza is why we stopped in…
Absolute perfection! Perfect crust crispness, just the right amount of toppings.
A ‘small’ 16 incher could easily feed 4.
And if it’s your first stop, ask for a sample of their meatballs.
Mama Mia!

i love this place, ate there all the time when i lived in Brighton, best pizza in CO in my opinion… please come to Pocatello…

Went there for the first time yesterday awesome calzones definitely be back soon! Heard the wings are top notch too.

So after reading a few positive reviews my fiancée and I decided to try this place out for dinner. We came around 5pm on a monday and it was empty. The staff was courteous and attentive (keep in mind we were the only people there) The atmosphere was very casual and friendly, and I especially liked the few arcade games near the entrance which included what looks like an original Galaga machine. We ordered garlic bread as an appetizer and a couple of drinks. The drinks were brought to us immediately but the garlic bread was a different story. Service was very good but the food took quite a long time to come out –easily forgivable in the case of the freshly made pizza, not so much for the garlic bread which was listed as an APPETIZER on the menu and was only brought out AFTER the rest of our food (after a lengthy wait)
It turns out the first one that was made for us was mistakenly sent out on a delivery and when it did arrive it was COMPED by our very nice waitress.
The food: the signature stuffed pizza was amazingly good. I’m not a pizza connoisseur but this was definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had and it was very reasonably priced to boot. The garlic bread was simple — just garlic bread with melted cheese and a side of marinara but it was delicious as well. Unfortunately my better half didn’t leave any of the cheese ravioli for me to try but that in itself is a good sign and I have it on very good authority that it was well prepared and delicious. The cheesecake was good as well.
The verdict: If you are in the area I would HIGHLY recommend checking this place out. I will definitely be returning.

Awesome pizza & great service! You will love this place! They often have great deals too! Check them out! New York Pizza in Colorado — yum!

When i think of New York i think of fuhgidabowdit! Our pizza was awesome! But there beer selection was sad! Wouldn’t hurt to get some local micro brews and support local brewery’s. But over all i would recommend this pizzeria.

After working 15 years in a certain pizza company, this place was a nice change. Service was great from the moment we walked in. They have a few games in there to entertain the kids. Pizza was great! Nice and juicy with fresh ingredients. I know I’ll be craving a pizza from there in the near future! PS add some green chilies to your pizza, delicious!

The staff is very friendly and the ingredients are fresh. They make or get most of there products from New York so they strive to be a step above the rest. There prices are decent for what you get and there slices of pizza are huge!
I just wish they had some wheat pasta on there menu.

Very yummy New York style pizza!
We have tried a couple other places in the Brighton area since moving here in June and this one is for sure going to be our go to from now on. We called in and ordered the house salad (which was incredible) and a create your own 18″ (pepperoni, sausage, olives and mushrooms). Both spectacular. The gentleman taking our order was very friendly, and the whole process was very easy. We had it delivered and that was timely, and the pizza was at our door still hot enough to burn your mouth, which was even more fantasic! SOO glad I disregarded the 1 and 2 star ratings (you must have unreachable standards for pizza people). We will be ordering from them again and next time we intend on picking up or dining in. Can’t wait to try other things…

As a new resident to the Brighton area, I have yet to find a place that was amazing… That is until we found Fuhgidabowdit Pizza. I really don’t understand the 1 – 2 star reviews. This place is amazing and is the real deal when it comes to New York style pizza. The wait was a little long due to the fact that their ingredients are all fresh… But it was well worth it.
As of now, the closest thing we’ve found that matches real New York style pizza is Anthony’s. Not anymore. Hidden little gem in Brighton that will leave you pleased.

Man, just once I wish I could write a review about a place in Brighton that TOTALLY KNOCKED MY SOCKS OFF with food and service!
But this ain’t it.
«Fuhgidabowdit». Were they being intentionally ironic with this name?
Without getting into a long rant about my whole experience here, suffice to say the two times I tried it, the food was lackluster, and the service typical Brighton lackadaisical.
The second time I was here, I was in a hurry, and just wanted a couple of slices.
After waiting quite a while, was informed that they were out of slice pie, had only one slice available, and would I mind waiting while they baked a new pie?
I said, «Sorry, in a hurry, just give me my money back.»
The counter guy apologized, and gave me the one slice for free, so there’s that.
That was a couple of years ago, and apparently, they have lived up to their name.

Just ordered pizza and had it delivered. Recommended by the staff at our hotel. The delivery man was courteous but other than that. Wasn’t too great. Too expensive for what it tastes like. And it does not compare to any New York style pizza.
Will prob not order from there again.

I’m surprised about the low reviews here. I’ve been here about 3 times and it’s always been consistently good. I’ve had their pizza and calzones — both came with a generous amount of toppings and were reasonably sized for the price. I’ve had their wings as well and those were tender and flavorful.
Fuhgidabowdit also let us host a big meeting here and no one ever complained, made us feel rushed, or even winced at splitting the check for the 15+ group that was there.