Goodfellas Pizza Pasta

Decent pizza. Slightly pricey for the Bronx and the price seems to be different with each order. Margarita and buffalo chicken pizza is my favorite.

Horrible delivery service. Had a miscommunication with one of the delivery guys and he called to resolve it and we explained to him what happened with the change. He hung up, and then continued to call me 5+ times and left a voicemail. I didn’t see these calls because I was busy and then he proceeded to text my personal cell with a rude and degrading text message. After this service from the delivery man I will not support Goodfellas Pizza.
This was uncalled for and very unprofessional on his part, mind you, it was a discrepancy of $ 8.00.

Loved the pizza. Had a good taste, but was a little too salty and greasy for my taste.

I like the pizza here. It’s good for the price. My son is a super pickey eater and likes it so we order from here. They haven’t disappointed us yet so nothing awful to write about them. Today is the first day I ordered through Unilocal so let’s see what happens.

i ordered twice this week… never again!
they screwed up my order both times!

Go to Sal’s up the road. Pizza is way better there and so is the service

Wow I hate to do this but truth is the pizza is the worst I’ve ever had!!! The pizza is tasteless and the sauce taste like Ragu! I ordered a variety of pizza so take note I’m not judging my experience off one slice. I had a specialty slice. Margarita… sicilian… Reg. slice… All 3 were disgusting. And tasteless! I’m sorry and feel terrible having wrote this review but as I stated truth be told!

I’ve been a Goodfellas customer for years and while it used to be my go-​to pizza, these days I find it tasteless, oily, and leaves my stomach in a lurch.
The crew that works there are a nice bunch but the quality of food has really fizzled. #sadface

My first experience wasn’t a success! I always order from my fav Salvatore’s pizza but I decided to give this place a try but now you lost a customer for life! I’m not ever sure how the food service and the people that answer the phone to take your order are EXTREMELY rude and un-​professional! I’m sorry but I’m calling to place an order and the girl says «give me a few minutes and I’ll take you order when I can». Who does that … And leaves me on hold for over 5min. So I hung up and called my go to… Salvatore’s!

Goodfellas Pizza is one notch up from any other corner pizzeria, but demand Manhattan prices.
They made 3 mistakes with 3 different orders and when you call up and bring it to their attention you get attitude from them, they are very stingy with their Cheese & Peperoni Pizza, be prepared for a lot of crust. I only live 1 block away and still had to wait an hour for delivery at 3pm when placing the order.

Really good penne alla vodka. 1 meal can serve for 2. Good timely service. Riverdale is a safe neighborhood. Not too hard to find parking 1 to 2 blocks over. Great place for take-​out not to really enjoy a sit down dinner. They deliver so that may be a better choice.

Great Neighborhood Pizza. The staff and owner are very friendly. Slices and sandwiches are consistently good.
Sit in, Take out, and on time HOT delivery make this a great asset to Riverdale!

On the days that I forget I’m not eating dairy, I cheat with Goodfella’s Pizza!!! I love the cheese pie. The sauce has the right amount of sweet/​salty/​acidity balance. The crust is thin and crispy! Really good NY pizza !! Delivery is super fast too!

I really like the pizza here. Great variety! I just wish they would bring their Groupon deals back so I could return!

I’ve eaten pizza in 3 countries. But I’m new to the NY slice scene. All I’m going to say right now is that this one is awesome. Maybe it’s the cheese or the amount of sauce, but something is elevating this slice to another level.

It has been said that there is no such thing as bad pizza. After all, at its worst, the pairing of cheese and tomato sauce on dough is, at the very least, edible.
So, it is fair to say that on that late and lonely night, I went in with low expectations. I was hungry, it was late, and I was in no mood to forage for food.
I ordered something basic, and expected little.
A short while later, I was greeted by a massive, HOT box and enveloped in a beautiful aroma. Every pizza I have ordered from here has been a pleasant experience. Even branching out into other territory was a decent surprise, with wings that are well sized (not the teeny weeny foolishness that some places sell).
The menu is pretty expansive, and they even sell hot chicken noodle soup that made my day when I was sick.
I highly recommend Goodfellas. Their magnet is the only one that graces my fridge.

It’s decent, I typically only get cheese slices, and there’s really doesn’t stand out. I wouldn’t tell anyone to avoid the place, but I wouldn’t recommend going out of your way to eat there either.

Nothing special about the pizza. Its just… pizza. No unique taste, nothing worth saying «wow, this was good pizza». Its just ‘OK’. I’m still wondering Why I got charged tax… on pizza? That’s a first for me! I don’t even get charged tax for pizza in the city. –_​– its not worth it.
Will I be back again? ehh idk.

Love the pizza; Even more so, I love the zeppoles !
I’ll have to write a more detailed review sometime because it’s been almost four years since I’ve been here.
I remember the service being slow, but that was because I always came here late on a Friday or Saturday so that is understandable. Limited seating in here so plan to take it to go or for delivery. It gets really cramped in here with all the Manhattan College students.
My favorite is the lasagna slice! As real as NY pizza gets. Don’t miss the zeppoles for dessert. They taste very authentic.

A-​OK works for this place. It doesn’t stand out. A plain slice is kind of bland, and the sauce isn’t the greatest. Its got kind of a weird taste to the sauce that I wasn’t crazy about, but the cheese was good. I heard the buffalo chicken slice was awesome, but I wasn’t blown away. It was kind of dry, and I’ve had better. The Chicken Roll is actually superb, so if you’re around I’d say get that for sure. There is a funky smell where the soda cooler is (kind of close to the kitchen) that made me think twice about eating here. It’s also really small. So if you plan on staying you might have to wait for people to clear out or share a booth.
Speaking of which, I had to do just that last time I was there, and this guy I was sitting with felt the need to discuss politics and his world view when I asked if I could use the other half of the booth he had to himself. It went something like this:
Something something… Arabs… something something… Obama… blah blah… Libya. blah blah… Iraq… this that… chick over there… this that… perfect ass.
I get it! I made a mistake asking if I could share a booth you had to yourself, even though we were both there when the people sitting in the booth before left, and I got my food way before you did. It is no reason to subject me to torture. Whatever, I’ll live.
The pizza is pretty much suburban style… that’s right I said it! Everyone I know in Riverdale complains about the pizza. I know most people in Riverdale don’t like to say they live in the Bronx, but come on. your pizza places shouldn’t imitate Westchester. I mean that in a good and honest way. Excellent calzones up in Westchester… really top notch, but soso pizza. Other than that the place is fine. The people who work there are okay, and the service is pretty quick. If you live in Riverdale and don’t feel like walking or driving the minute and a half into Kingsbridge I guess this works for you. A comfortable 3 stars.