Lobel’s of New York

With the plethora of unhealthy eats and temptations of flowing beer, this is possibly the best and probably fulfilling sandwich in the park. The meat is finger pull tender that sits inside a pillow of a roll then dipped in its own natural juice. Great sandwich all around and especially at the stadium. The only complaint I had was mine was on the well side, wish it was more rare. Make sure to get the horseradish sauce on the side just to give it a little extra kick. Might be above average price but worth it!

4 stars. The steak sandwich is great, but the 2^nd best steak sandwich in the stadium in my opinion. The bun is what brings the sandwich together. It soaks up the sauce and is so fresh. The steak is cooked to perfection and is not even the star of the sandwich in my opinion. The sauce can be put on anything because it is so yummy and is the star. It’s a must eat for carnivores.

Their steak and fries is one of the best deals you can find at Yankee Stadium. The The box of fries are topped with layers and layers of steak strips that are cooked to perfection. And at $ 15.00, you won’t even get this value eating at a restaurant, let alone a sports stadium. Each strip had a medium rare center and was tender. It might look like a lot but it was finished in just 2 innings.

Maybe it was the day and maybe not, but my experience here wasn’t as I expected. I was really looking forward to trying out Lobel’s and super excited too after reading all the great reviews on here, but sadly the excitement turned into disappointment. I hate giving bad reviews to restaurants, because I realize the hard work that’s being put behind everything to please consumers like us, but I just was not impressed with this place. Like I said, maybe it was just that day! I felt that the sandwich was overpriced for the quality I received. The meat was served to me cold and covered in a ton of gravy too. Due to my experience, I probably won’t be returning back.

This is one of the steak sandwich that you MUST have while watching Yankee Game. Not only taste good, but fill you up. It is not a small sandwich. Don’t wait and add to your bucket list.

Best steak sandwich of my life! Worth the wait and enjoyed every bite!

Ahhhh Lobel’s…
I’ve been to Yankee Stadium a ton but came here for the first time this past opening day. To start, it’s a cool little place because you can see the guys slicing the meat behind the window. But, let’s be clear — the sandwich is way overpriced at $ 16 a pop. Yes, I understand it’s Yankee Stadium and NYC but still overpriced.
Worst part about the experience was how long it took. They only had one person actually putting the sandwiches together and it was not done efficiently. I think everyone was rusty on opening day, including the Lobel’s sandwich makers.
On to the sandwich… they do give you a fair amount of meat which is nice and the roll is decent. I do think they could use some better bread. Then, they douse it with some gravy/​sauce. The meat was pretty tender and it is definitely a very good sandwich — don’t get me wrong. This is also a «lotsa» napkins type of sandwich. It’s messy but good.
I’d get a sandwich here again but only if the line wasn’t incredibly long. All they sell is sandwiches and drinks — that’s it. Be warned. I’m sure I’ll be back.

Love in a bun!
The price has gone up a dollar in the last year or two. But at $ 16 the sandwich is well worth it. The meat is succulence cooked to perfection! The bun absorbs all the juices perfectly that it all melts in your mouth. The meat is so tender, it’s divine. No veggies or sides needed!
You MUST try it for yourself!
I admit I only went to the stadium to take a bite out of heaven. :)

MEAT MEAT MEAT. It was worth the walk to get it!!! Excellent sandwich!

My friends told me I had to eat here when I visit Yankee stadium. At $ 16 a sandwich it might seem expensive but considering its a baseball stadium and the meat quality is excellent, I felt it was a fair value. The meat is incredibly tender and had a nice sauce. Definitely recommend if coming to Yankee stadium.

Solid steak sandwiches, especially for ball park food…

I made a trek all the way from the 4^th level of Yankee’s Stadium down to ground level just to get my hand on one of these sandwiches, only to make the trek all the way back up and find they recently opened one of the 4^th level for the convenience of the guests. alskjalklkj.
pro tip: they have two locations now, not just one. :(
OH my. This sandwich is like heaven with every bite. They load up the buttery brioche buns with juicy au jus covered slices of prime rib. The juices and the sauce are quickly absorbed by the soft tender buns which attribute to a flavor so amazing. you simply can not find this anywhere else. It is definitely not cheap at $ 16 per sandwich, but considering the generous amounts of quality cut, melt-​in-​your-​mouth meat you receive, this might actually be considered a steal. I mean, if a lemonade costs $ 6. you are essentially paying the cost for less than three lemonades in exchange for something extraordinary. I’d make a trip to see the Yankees play just so that I can have another one of these sandwiches!

For the price the sandwich is excellent. You have to expect a pricey night at the stadium anyway

5 stars is reserved for great service and this a lune up and wait counter. Thats what you should plan on because this is not only the best food taste and value at Yankee Stadium, its one of the best tasting sandwiches in the world. No joke.

It’s all about the steak sandwiches. Or perhaps more accurate to say, they ONLY serve steak sandwiches.
But really, why is there even bread? Each bun is simply a tepid accessory that can afford to be tossed aside, as Lobel’s serves up some hugely tender and savoury cuts of USDA steak lathered in gravy that just ramps the juiciness factor to another level.
It really was a great steak (I will refrain from calling it a sandwich because I never did find a need to eat the bread), and I’m glad I tried it, but the way the lines can get, I don’t think I would line up for it again and I’m happy that I managed to get a taste on a rainy Wednesday afternoon at Yankee Stadium.