Buttermilk Bakeshop

Monkey Buns was excellent. I suggest you go there in the mood for dessert. Descent prices.

My husband and I chose Buttermilk Bakeshop for our wedding cake and they did a wonderful job. We selected a design that we liked from Pinterest and they were able to recreate it for us. The price was very reasonable and we received many compliments from our guests about how delicious the cake was. I highly recommend them for any of your special occasion cake needs.

Dessert heaven! I will admit to only going to this sinfully sweet shop once every few months no matter how many times I’m in Park Slope because I spend waaay too much money buying macaroons, cookies, cakes and cupcakes for myself, friends and family.
Personally I’m partial to the cakes. The Nutella Pecan is inspired by God! I really have never tasted a better pecan pie and that’s one of my favorite types of pie. I guess nutella makes everything better.
My mom and sister are crazy about the macaroons which are just PERFECT and come in so many flavors.
If you’re in Park Slope this place is NOT to be missed.

Buttermilk is an amazing bakery. It has delicious food, a wonderful staff and reasonable prices. I can’t recommend Buttermilk enough.

My favorite bakery in Brooklyn. If they have the nutella pecan pie when you go, this is a must try. Im a sucker for good pecan pie and this did not dissapoint. They have ice cream cookie sandwiches to that I want to try too. They make the cookies (obviously) and the ice cream (not so obviously). Definitely a gem in park slope.

This place is awesome! They have a nice variety of items from cookies to cakes. The place is very unique and unusual. They produce great products and I can’t say enough how delicious their selections are.

The Most Boring Man In The World (aka, me): «I don’t often order vegan cupcakes, but when I do, I order them from Buttermilk Bakeshop».
That is the truth. I could not tell the difference between the regular stuff and the vegan stuff. Someone went «Wow! Did you make these??», and I was like «Hell yes, cuz I’m a master baker who just chooses to toil away in mediocrity, choosing only to bust out my mad vegan baking skillz when my lactose intolerant friends are in danger of starving at a party.» I’m just that kinda guy.
But seriously, this is a great little shop. We ordered a little vegan chocolate cake, and 24 cupcakes (some of those vegan as well). Lots of options, lots of flavors, but with some helpful advice, we were able to lock in our order within a few minutes and had a smooth pickup a week later. It’s a little more expensive than your average bake shop, but when your friends end up thinking you’re a master baker, it’s worth it.

Buttermilk Bakeshop is a welcome addition to 5^th Avenue in Brooklyn. It takes real willpower not to stop in for a treat every time we walk by. The staff is friendly, the baked goods are delicious, and the loyalty program is a nice perk.

Brownies worth the walk in –13′ windchill weather. Combined with a few bites of a snicker doodle & I’m set :)

You will never find a better cookie in your life.

Bought two macarons and it was ok, then I decided to buy slice of apple caramel pie and it was frozen WTF.

Amazing experience inside the bakery! Super friendly and patient. If I could, I would give them 200 stars. I ordered a three layer half sheet and 144 cupcakes for my baby shower. DELICIOUS! Everyone kept asking about where we ordered. 200 pleased guests and a very happy pregnant person!

The salted nutella cookie $ 2.50 was pretty darn graet, distracting from the water dripping right onto the entrance from their counterproductive Rube Goldberg tube.

This review is only for my brief moment inside ordering iced coffee. The coffee was bad, and I tasted all of the badness since I drink it straight black. Tasted burnt and had the bottom of the pot grinds. Also had no air conditioning on a really hot NYC day

Oh my goodness, this shop has the best baked sweets in all of Brooklyn! I recently made a catering order for a baby shower event with Katie at the shop for 5 dozen assorted cupcakes, 30 cake pops, and 30 bags filled with chocolate trip cookies and macaroons, and these treats were the BEST party of the whole event! Everyone was asking where I got the baked treats from because they were so good! My personal favorite are the triple chocolate chunk cookies but everything else is just as delicious.
What I really liked about this shop is that they gave me a nice discount because I was ordering so much stuff and when I counted everything at pick-​up they had actually given me a few extra cupcakes and pops and bags of cookies! How nice!
Also, the treats are just SO PRETTY to look at that they made the perfect decorative pieces for the shower.

Great place with great baked goods.
Will definitely be back again. Macaron was delicious and at a great price.

Much like their first location in the slope on 7^th Ave, this new Buttermilk outpost brings the goods. They took over the space formerly held by Trois Pommes (sniff, sniff) and as much as I loved that place, you can’t ask for a much better replacement. Everything here is bonkers.
I find solace in the fact that I can now get a chocolate nutella sea salt cookie on either 5^th or 7^th Avenues. I suppose some hard decisions will need to be made if/​when I get the craving on 6^th Ave, but I’m sure I’ll figure it out!

Ordered a cake from here for our bridal shower. The price was right and the cake was delicious.
The people who worked there were easy to work with and very helpful. I only knew that I wanted a ‘beach theme’ cake and they made a beautiful looking cake that tasted just as great. Highly recommend!

I’ve been wanting to try this bakery since they have came to Park Slope, but honestly I’m way too lazy to walk up the seventh avenue, so when they came to fifth I made sure to get my lazy behind up, and walk over there with the kiddies. I absolutely loved the raspberry cookie, I had one there and had to order four more to go! Most defiantly enjoyed it the next day also with some coffee. I also tried the Nutella cookie, only was able to take a bite because my husband stole them from me… lol yea they were that good! The kids had cupcakes, I believe the vanilla and strawberry, and also the chocolate one. I didn’t taste them, but they loved it, my son even asked for a second. So happy that I’m able to take a quick walk over there without having to walk up the hill to seventh avenue! Welcome to fifth!

Park Slope is teeming with new businesses, including this new bakery on Fifth Ave.
We had three cookies (all of them were super rich):
— Salted Nutella: warning: this cookie literally melts in your hand so it’s messy but so so worth it. It had the consistency of a super moist brownie with a deep pocket of Nutella in the center
— Triple Chocolate: my least favorite of the three, though by no means unsatisfying.
— Vegan Gingersnap: I hesitate with vegan products given some horrible past experiences, but this cookie shattered stereotypes. By no means healthy, the cookie is still moist (possibly from maple syrup) and the ginger comes through really nicely.
Space-​wise, it’s very small unfortunately with only one table and a window bench seat. I would say that it’s more of a stop and go type shop.