We needed some photogenic custom pies for a work project, and got in touch with Cutie Pies. We were able to get the pies in a tight turnaround(within a day and a half of ordering), and they turned out great & delicious! Highly recommend.
Sonny L.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Ordered a selection of pies a few months ago and I can’t express how delicious and GORGEOUS these pies look at tasted! They were such a hit, I also recently used cutie pies for a friend’s bday party last month and got a selection of mini pies which were perfect and so freaking adorable. My favs are the fruit filled pies, OHMYGOD, they’re so bright and delicious!
Jillian R.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Upper West Side, Manhattan, NY
Extremely impressed with the delicious pie that was delivered to my door this past weekend. I ordered the peach w/bourbon and cinnamon for my boyfriend’s birthday and we both were blown away. They also personalized the pie and were able to write«Happy Birthday» in cut out letters– it looked great… Incredibly delicious and you could tell it was truly homemade and fresh. The crust was the perfect texture ad the filling was flavorful without being nauseatingly sweet. Highly, highly recommend. Great customer service and delivery was reliable(and were willing to accommodate to my schedule). MUSTTRY.
Tiffany L.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Cutie Pies is Super CUTE and Super Sweet. Spotted the booth at Smorgasburg over in Williamsburg one Saturday. I’m a big fan of the Coconut Cream Pie. Visually stunning(I adore all things cute) and special treat for my tastebuds, then again, i’m impartial because I have a sweet spot in my heart for any coconut dessert. The pies are beautifully presented, I would definitely consider ordering a pie for a holiday event, or maybe even for client gifts! Yes, I think I might do just that.
Shannon D.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Brooklyn, NY
My mom loves Strawberry Rhubarb pie and chocolate, so for her birthday my dad wanted to get her a chocolate cake filled with strawberry rhubarb. I called so many bakeries all over Brooklyn and not one place would accommodate. Finally, I called cutie pies and spoke to Alice. She was super nice and said even though her main focus is pies, she would try her best to make the cake I wanted. I took the cake to my family in Rockland county and boy was it a hit! The Chocolate melted in my mouth and the strawberry rhubarb was so fresh and tasty! We can’t wait to order pies for thanksgiving!
Abra C.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Ordered the bourbon pecan pie for Thanksgiving. It was a nice twist on a classic pie — definately brought something a little different to the table. It was hard to not slice into it before Thanksgiving dinner, and everyone really enjoyed it!!!
Anne M.
Rating des Ortes: 5 New York, NY
Ordered the sampler for Thanksgiving and it was a big hit with my entire family! Our favorites were the butter tartes, bourbon pecan, and apple… So good! I often find its hard for restaurants or caterers to get the classic pies to taste truly homemade. Cutie Pies has done it! I think I prefer the crust-to-filling ratio of larger pies, so next time I’ll be ordering full size pies.
Michelle B.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Ordered a Bourbon Pecan Pie for Thanksgiving, it was a great way to finish our meal!
Brett H.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Brooklyn, NY
I am not a very frequent reviewer, but I had to make an exception for Cutie Pies. They were just that good! I got three pies for a big dinner: Bourbon Pecan, which had the perfect texture and was not too sweet, Guinness-Bailey’s Irish Cream(with whiskey-caramel drizzle), which was really unique and yummy, and an Apple pie which may just be the best apple pie I have EVER had in my life.(God forbid my mother reads this.) But seriously — apple pie is one of those desserts that is so simple yet so hard to perfect. Their version had incredibly crispy apples, flaky crust, and just the right balance of sugar and cinnamon. I can’t remember the last time I was blown away by an apple pie, but this one did it.
Yadira v.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Palisades Park, NJ
I ordered 2 pies for Thanksgiving weeks in advance using a Gilt City offer. Requested that they be delivered before 5pm. Around 6pm, I called them inquiring about my pies as I had not received them. The owner stated that they were experiencing delivery problems and would not be receiving my pies in time for Thanksgiving. I found this to be extrememly unprofessional not to mention discourteous as I now had no dessert. They didn’t even have to decency to contact me in regards to their issue.
Jaimee A.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Manhattan, NY
I hate to give a bad review to a small business with really good customer service but the proof of the pudding(or in this case, pies) is in the eating. We purchased 4 three inch pies and 4 maple tarts(another gilt purchase). The pie flavors were: Chocolate Caramel Coconut Cream Lemon Cream Bourbon Pecan All were barely edible. We ended up throwing them out after taking one bite of each. The reason why they get two starts as opposed to one is because the person I dealt with was super nice and accommodating.
Cath G.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Salt Lake City, UT
I got a CutiePies deal off Gilt City website and Alice delivered my pies yesterday. I got a sampler — four mini pies and four little tarts. I’ve only tried the mini pies so far but they are delicious. I tried bites of coconut cream, chocolate caramel, apple and maple bourbon pecan. They were all great, sweet but not over-the-top and very moorish. Can’t wait to try the butter tarts over the weekend. I’ll order again for sure.
Megan G.
Rating des Ortes: 4 San Francisco, CA
I stopped by the Cutie Pies stand for a sweet treat at Smorgasburg. I picked the chocolate peanut butter scone. I would have picked pie, seeing as that’s what Cutie Pies is known for obviously, but I was on the go and pie and«on-the-go» don’t really mix! But the scone was so good! Other scones I’ve had have been dry but this was the perfect consistency, not to sweet, etc. I will be sure to come back for another scone and definitely a slice of pie! Prices were good too for the size of the portions and in comparison to other stands in the area. Definitely worth trying!