Seatide Gourmet Fish Market

To be extremely honest, this is a beautiful fish market and the people who work here are nice. BUT, the fish is not fresh whatsoever. I have been here probably four times over the years and every time I get something, I am reminded of why I do not return for a year or so but this time, I will never buy something from here again. I have bought grey sole (really fishy), shrimp (the frozen kind tastes more fresh) and frozen crab legs (I had to throw out because of how dry and nasty they were.) Just a week ago, I returned and bought some fried shrimp already cooked (because I do not learn my lesson) and as soon as I got home and went to put them in the oven to warm up, the stinky smell of fish came out of the container. I tried one after I warmed them up and spit it out. Okay, obviously the ppl who gave this place good reviews know NOTHING about fish. Fish shouldn’t have a smell if it is fresh! Owners, get some fresh fish. Yours is very old and smelly!!!

There are two fantastic fish markets in this area, Seatide is one. This store ALWAYS smells like the ocean, which to me indicates that everything is fresh… and they have everything, fresh. They are extremely courteous (imagine), the knowledgeable staff is glad to help you and often goes the extra mile with their warm customer service. It’s a neighborhood place for me and for that I am glad.

Amazing fish market! I’ll give it 4 stars because the prices are a bit steep but the product is always fresh. I usually get fish on a bun with French fries (which is always delicious) but I decided to get live lobsters a few days ago. Best lobster I’ve tasted in a LONG time. The staff was super friendly and he even let me hold one (talk about awkward bonding). However! I’m not to big on the cold bar. Most of the food is flavorless to me but to each is it’s own. Seatide is definitely my «go to» spot when I feel like splurging.

First time customer here! Called and ordered 2 fish entrees and 2 containers of lobster bisque the other day. When I asked I was graciously told that it would take 30 – 45 minutes to prepare. I went to pick my order up early and waited a bit — having never been there before I wanted to see what all the hype was about.
Boy, the hype is righteous!!! The store is very bright and clean, the people are very friendly and accommodating and the fish and prepared delights look scrumptiously delicious. From the sushi chef in the front to the counter girls in the back and everyone else in between my experience was rather nice. And ALL that fish!!!
The bisque was delicious with chunks of lobster in it and the salmon was melt in your mouth good, however, I would’ve liked more oreganata sauce. Next time I go I will ask for some extra sauce, and there will be a next time. 4 thumbs up!

okay so came here for the first time and i have to say i’m impressed for a fish market, friendly staff very clean, a bit expensive but it was worth it ! they also have a buffet section which had fresh seafood such as fried oysters, fried shrimp salads an more … deff a place to get some good seafood

Food always is sold fresh and look yummy. I always go here and they always have a large variety. The employees are sweet and the manager is nice as well. Always helpful. If I had any complaints is that the food is a little on the expensive side. Seven dishes cost about $ 80 to $ 100 depending upon the weights. My fav is their salmon dishes whether salmon sausage or pretty much any, they charge about $ 16 LB. Still I buy it because it is so good!!! My fam loves this place and I go about once a week.

This has got to be the cleanest fish market that I have ever come across and the service is pretty good.
I discovered this fish market through a groupon offered by this company and was extremely pleased. The fish is fresh but fairly priced. There is even a buffet in the back. So glad i came across this place… highly recommended!

Been shopping here for three years and drive over from Midwood because its well worth it. Buy fish every week and the quality and selection are outstanding. Purchased a big platter for the holidays and it was terrific. So happy I found this market. Only fish store I shop at in Brooklyn!!!
PS Landi’s meat market is across the street so its one stop shopping!

My mom has been buying fish here for a long time so when I saw a groupon for them, I bought it for her. The store is clean with a nice selection. Would I call it Gourmet… no. I asked the sushi guy to make a roll that they had with no spicy mayo, he said no. I bought two other rolls that were just ok. Frankly I think they should have been kept colder and they should be less expensive. My local Japanese restaurant, Chikurin has rolls that are half the price and twice the size. The calamari salad I bought was not good; something was definitely off in the dish. I bought several cooked shrimp for a shrimp cocktail, a salmon burger, 2 pieces of fish and some cherry stone clams. I likes that they shucked the clams when asked but absolutely thought it was terrible business practice to try and charge charge 30 cents for cocktail sauce for those clams! They give a small container of it for the shrimp so why not for the clams? The guy in the front told me most people use only lemon for raw clams and if I wanted cocktail sauce, to buy a bottle. SERIOUSLY? I just spent 40 bucks and you are quibbling about 30 cents?! The food and service is not good enough that I would return.

Bright, clean and good service with a smile. They have food to order which I have yet to try but I know for a fact I can get fresh fish from here. The people are so accommodating, going out of their way to let you know when deliveries are coming in and even going the extra mile explaining what each fish taste like and how to prepare it. And now that I have perfected the art of cooking fish, I will be at Seatide more often than not.
Sometimes I really do love my neighborhood, I swear I do.

Besides being a very clean and fresh fish market, the service is excellent. For the past three years, I’ve placed my Christmas eve fish dinners here, since they offer a Holidaycooked menu too Everything I ordered was delicious! I was NOT disappointed and neither was my family or any of my guest. While I was waiting for my order, there was one woman questioning her order and price. The person in charge did not hestitate to make certain this customer walked out of his business satisfied. Great Costumer service! The people working here take their time to answer any questions you may have. There is a large variety, it’s always fresh, clean and stocked.

Me and my dad just had the baked ziti with roasted skate, and it’s very safe to say that we both agreed that the skate is arguably the worst tasting fish that we’ve ever had, first of all it has a lot of bones at the bottom of it that gives the illusion that it’s thick and meaty, the texture is a little watery fake chicken like and did i mention tasteless as well, I am sorry people but salt and pepper is not adequate seasoning you have to learn to mingle with some herbs as well :) the ziti was not the greatest by any means but it was doable, their menu seemed wide and varied even one of the cooks was bragging about being the only one person who can make the best burgers (especially salmon) although I must say he did not appeared to have traveled anywhere else besides from Brooklyn to maybe Manhattan so I have no idea how he was able to come up with such a grand assessment :) I have some business in the area so may I decide to give them a try again.
ps: it’s also surprisingly very clean, the cashier is a very nice and young either Georgian or Russian who is fair to look upon and genuinely very friendly as well :)

I love this store. While I waited, for no extra cost, I had 6 pounds of shrimp shelled and cleaned in only 10 minutes. I put a tip in the jar for the thorough and cheerful service. The store was so clean and beautiful and all the food was gorgeous, so I took some pictures, all except the lobster tank, which was awesome, but my friend snapped that one… Hey Jen, post the lobsters!

This isn’t your father’s old fish market. This is a truly impressive, modern, bright, well designed work of art that just happend to sell fresh fish. Gone are the days of dingy, dirty, mystery fish that you have to wonder if it had been sitting there more than it should.
From the exquisit signage to the floor to celiling windows & doors to the state of the art stainless steel fish counter, this is a very well thoughtout functional layout. The fish is displayed so ornately and meticulously that you don’t want to even place your order afraid that it might somehow disrupt the design. All the fishes are super fresh and preserved by ice at all times as it should.
The only reason, I have to take away a star is because, in their prepared food section, I had order the fried calamari. It was so full fo MSG that, it numbed my taste buds for two days. I hope this was the cook’s off day.
Now they even have a sushi chef that will make to your hearts desire. Selling sushi inside of a fish market, what a great idea!