Jimmy Stix

Visiting my sister for a few days from Texas and while looking for lunch found this little Gem. By and far, the breadsticks (or breadstix as they call them) are where it’s at. 2 for $ 2 and 4 for $ 3 are not a bad deal.
I got the two toping slice and a drink lunch combo and then 4 stix for $ 3 to go with it.
The pizza: was ok. Thinish crust that was crunchy and the pizza had good flavor. They were lunch slices and was about a ¼ of a medium pizza. Toppings (I got mushrooms and sausage) were fresh and sausage had great taste. Wasn’t the rabbit poop looking kind from the big chains but legit ground sausage. Sauce was a little lacking in flavor, and I’m sure when made 100% fresh the pizza is great. Will have to order a full pie some day and see. Since it was the lunch combo, and time is a factor I was ok with it being a pre made slice that had toppings added and went in for a quick warm up in the oven.
The breadstix: I got two jimmy stix and two wacky stix. This was enough for two people and came with two dipping sauces as well. I liked the wacky stix more because of the better flavor from the added toppings but the jimmy stix were the original breadstick flavor I was looking for. Would come back just for the breadstix.
The staff: this is where they made up for the lunch pizza. The guy working the counter, early 20’s maybe and has glasses, was top notch. Friendly and knowledgeable. Great server too, was attentive at the table even though it was a counter service joint. He deserves a kudos.
Overall: if your familiar with Campus Polleyeyes in Bowling Green, Ohio, and liked them, you’re really going to like the stix here. Now they are stuffed, but they are hot, fresh, delicious, and best of all cheap. 4 stix with a slice of pizza and a drink, was $ 8.71. And I have a snack for later since I only ate half the stixs.
Would def come back!

Jimmy Stix is one of the few places in Carmel that delivers it seems, and boy I’m glad they do!
I absolutely love their Chef salad. It’s a big salad (Elaine from Seinfeld would be happy with it ;)). The ingredients are always fresh and they don’t skimp on them.
Their breadsticks are indeed amazing. Try the Wacky Stix… very unique and seasoned well!
The pizza is pretty darn good. It’s not the best pizza ever, but it hits the spot. They use good quality ingredients and put a good amount of toppings on. I like their pan style pizzas.
Overall, Jimmy Stix is a great pizza place on the Northside!

We had the stix those were the best tasteting breadsticks could of ate 2 orders of those. Pizza was so good cheese was stringy and yummy. Staff was friendly restaurant was clean Great Place

My boyfriend and I live in Fishers but we’ve exhausted all the usual spots so we came to Jimmy Stix.
I really loved the relaxed and friendly vibe from the employees. Even though it’s counter service, a server checked in on us while she cleaned the dining room.
We did the medium 2-​topping combo where you got breadsticks. They were huge! I barely used dipping sauce because they had garlic and parmesean on them. Pizza was great too; generous toppings and cheese.
The only complaint was from my boyfriend, who thought it was strange they only had basic cable and played music instead, but I liked not being distracted by the TV. We’ll be coming back!

When ordering a pizza that contains bazil…“fresh ingredients” don’t include dried basil pieces sprinkled on a pizza. The crust was also very bland.

Good variety of food choices. Servers are friendly. Prices are a little high. Place us small, but quaint.

I’ve only lived here for a few months, but this is definitely the best local pizza I’ve had since moving here. I was beginning to lose hope in finding decent pizza in my area, but I found Jimmy Stix today and was very happy with it. My only drawback was my pizza didn’t contain one of the toppings I ordered, but I definitely don’t want to mark down for that because the pizza was still tasty and could have just been that they misheard me via phone. The Stix were great! Would recommend.

friendly staff and great lunch specials– stix with the garlic butter was amazing.
Lunch special was a slice (really it’s two regular sized slices), 2 breadsticks with dipping sauce for $ 5. Hard to find prices like this in Carmel for this amount of food.

Ordered a white pizza and took home. Within a few minutes, the entire pizza was devoured. The location is a bit off the beaten path from the rest of Carmel’s eateries, but it’s definitely worth tracking it down.

Phone line was busy for nearly 20 minutes. Food was ready in 30 minutes and was very tasty. We ordered fountain drinks but since they were out of cups were left with the option to get 2 liters. Good food, a little work to do on operations.

Quick and easy for lunch break. Lunch special 2 slices 2 toppings and a drink $ 4.99 + tax, great deal! Flavor was not bad, fresh veggies and crispy crust, can’t really ask for much more. Didn’t try the bread sticks, but I definitely will the next time.

Yum! If you are in Carmel, this is a must. The breadstix, how can I make you understand? Light crispy outside coated with butter and sprinkled with cheese, the inside, light and fluffy like a cloud. The pizza had the perfect ratio of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings. Not one overwhelmed the other. The staff was very friendly and attentive. Again, a must try if you are in Carmel.

Back again. This is new favorite place to come during the week day. Stop by and say Hello to Josh. He will be at the counter in the afternoon. Friendly and knowledgeable.

Strangely enough, the pizza tastes better reheated in the microwave! I’ve never had that happen with pizza before, but whatevs — I’ll take it.
The pizza is just fine. It’s not the best that I’ve eaten in the area, but it’s not the worst, either. The breadsticks are pretty good, though. Maybe that’s why this place is called Jimmy Stix and not Jimmy Pizza.

Today my husband and I visited Jimmy Stix pizza for the first time and my goodness were we impressed! We visited at 5pm on a Monday evening with a 2 year old in tow! The dining room was empty, with the exception of a few carry out customers, which made it great for a toddler.
The service was awesome, the staff extremely friendly and very responsive to requests. The waiter was really friendly with our two year old as well.
Then the food came, oh my goodness are we IMPRESSED!!! I’m a self proclaimed pizzaholic, having pizza at least three times a week, and this pizza impressed me!
We had a two topping pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese, the sauce had great flavoring with a little tanginess to it. The cheese was gooey and tasted fresh. The crust was what made it, the perfect amount of crispiness and softness with its own flavoring that made the crust enjoyable on its own.
The «Stix» were probably the best seasoned breadsticks I have ever had, and the dipping sauces ALMOST distracted from the seasoning.
My husband and I will be back, because the prices are great and the food amazing!

I can’t believe I haven’t reviewed this place yet! I live very close so on lazy nights I love to order take out from this place. They seemingly don’t do much business so I’m happy to leave a good word for them!
I love their deep dish pizza, crust is amazing and toppings are always fresh. They also have their «Jimmy Rolls» which are like a stromboli, very good. Stop in and give them a try sometime!

This experience was a bit all over the place. We strolled in just after 5pm, happy to take a break from traffic on our trek north. Why I ever thought to leave for errands in Westfield/​Carmel at rush hour is beyond me. Momentary loss of all sanity, maybe? Who knows. Either way, it landed us here.
We were the only souls in the place and heeded the sign that read, «Please Order at the Counter». No problem! As we were reviewing the menu (at the counter), we were asked to sit at a table and they’d take our order there. Huh? So, we sat and decided to try a bit of a smörgåsbord. We were hungry-​ish now, but would be hungry later after all the schtuff we had to do was finished. What’s better leftover than pizza? We ordered a side house salad and greek salad with Jimmy Stix to start.
The Jimmy Stix were delicious. At least for me. Be forewarned — they’re sweet. Combined with the garlic butter dipping sauce, divine. Unless you don’t have much of a sweet tooth, which Husband does not. Sweet aside, however, even he admitted they were perfectly fluffy and the sauce delectable. My house salad was very fresh and appealing! Taste wasn’t spectacular, but definitely not bad. Struck me as a great work week lunch option — cheap, fresh, and greeny. The Greek salad, well, not so much. It was — weird? We’ll admit, we missed the menu note about the potato salad on the item. We should have paid closer attention. Still… it did not work for us. Basically the dish is built like this: basic mustard potato salad is plopped onto the bottom of the bowl. Very fresh yummy greens then cover the potato salad along with fairly staple Greek salad toppings. The salad dressing is just a mix of oil and balsamic vinegar. Not a lot (or any) seasoning to accompany. Now that your potato salad is cleverly hidden under the greens, dressing is poured over the top. As the balsamic seeps into the mustard potato salad, you eat your way to the bottom. Now imagine your surprise? Horror? We’ll go with dismay at the first taste of mustard potato salad soaked in balsamic vinegar. Yeah. That just doesn’t work.
The whole salad experience kinda ruined the appetite. Husband’s definitely. Mine a bit from just watching. We boxed up the pizza and bailed. I’m not sure if it would have been better fresh, but re-​heated it was mediocre. Kinda tasted like school pizza. I’ll settle on a 3 for this place. I’d go back for a quick salad and a breadstick or two. As long as it’s not the Greek salad I’d say that’s safe. Can’t say I’m all that interested in trying the pizza again but maybe one day I’ll give it another shot on a whim. You know, wild and crazy me with my whims.

The service is always super friendly. The pizza is always hot and delicious. Salads are refreshing. Of course the Jimmy Stix are great (and so are the sauces you dip them in!). So much better than any pizza chain. If you are craving pizza, this will do the trick! It is our go-​to pizza place in Carmel.
Atmosphere is never too loud. It’s great for just my husband and me, going out with friends, or for families with kids.

Jimmy Stix is a stereotypical pizza joint with standard cafeteria style booths and seating. There is a counter in one wall with a disinterested teenager answering phones and slinging dough. Nothing special inside.
The pizza was nothing special either. It all tasted like an average pizza joint that you can find in any midwestern city. That’s not to say that I didn’t enjoy it but it was nothing memorable whatsoever. The titular Jimmy Stix were also no different than your run of the mill garlic sticks from any other place.
There are so many local pizza options in Carmel and Jimmy Stix just doesn’t do anything to elevate themselves over the other places.

Very good pizza. Had the Sicilian deep dish with pep and sausage. Lots of cheese and dicious sauce. Crust was crunchy and delicious. Was similar to Old Chicago’s or Jet’s deep dish (if you are familiar). Eating area was nice as well.
I like to dip my pizza in Ranch. Unlike Jets and OC, they use premade ranch (not homemade). It was ok. Average at best.