Papa Saverio’s Pizzeria

Good thin crust pizza… Extra thin crust is even better. Fast Delivery time and always within the hour. Avoid the pasta. Lasagna sauce is very bitter/​acidic. Shrimp Alfredo sauce is watered down and I won’t even begin to describe the shrimp … Great breadsticks. Customer service is decent. Sign up for the email coupons. Parking is easy to find for pickup.

I would like everyone to be ware. I’ve been going to this location for 15 years. Tonight will be my last. They have posted prices and a stack of menus on the counter and they insisted on charging more stating that prices are subject to change. Then I was told the manager who knows me and has talked to me several times was too stressed to deal with it. Then they said corporate reserves the right to change prices. Well I reserve the right to not feel like I’m being taken and to have an honest business transaction. If you publish a price — that’s the price. I guess I’ll be looking for a new local pizza now. The review is really 0 but I couldn’t submit a 0.

Decided to try a stuffed pizza there last night while playing Trivia next door. I have to say, It was great. Nice thick rich sauce, tons of cheese and a great buttery crust.

Order pizza there numerous times and pizza is really good. It’s always consistent and good amount of toppings. The price is average than any other pizza joint. Will keep getting pizza from them.

Happy we tried this place out the night with my friends. Pizza was really good and the wings were really good. Delivery was prompt and had no issue — would go back to them for delivery without a doubt.

(Note) — while having the same ‘name’, this restaurant’s food seems to differ a little from the other Papa Saverio’s in Bartlett on Rte 59.
3 Stars.
Ordered a few times, the food is «okay to good». Nothing fantastic, but not terrible.
Pizza just seems «okay». I’ve had far better pizzas, though. Ordered a small pizza last night, and it was pie-​cut, which is fine. Something about the pizza though — I don’t know — it was just «okay.» It seemed no better than say a perfectly cooked Tombstone or Jack’s pizza in your frozen sections, though.
(In comparison, pizza from say Augustino’s or especially Garibaldi’s — based on what I had last night, this place couldn’t even compete with those two.)
— Cheeseburgers — «okay». Not bad. You get a lot for 4.99, but again, the burger’s «meat» cold be a little better or more flavorful. Doesn’t seem flame-​broiled.
— Fries — «curly type» or «battered type». Some people love these, I don’t. I can’t recommend the fries unless those type are your thing.
Overall — this «location» just seems OKAY.
** The Papa Saverio’s on the corner of 59 and Army Trail Rd. SEEMS to have a bit better pizza, and different (regular style) fries.

Pizza, beer and Hawks game! One of the best combination ever!
We’ve actually never had their pizza before, but just so happened that we had their advertisement so we tried them out! Boy were we glad that we did! There are quite a few pizza places around here and I’m not too big of a fan of any of them. We had a Jumbo thin crust with 4 ingredients and they weren’t cheap about it either!
If you like your pizza super cheesey then this is your place! Plus with all the coupons that they give you, it’s really an amazing deal! I seriously don’t even like thin crust pizzas that much but I couldn’t stop eating this one!

We order from this location frequently, mostly because were are in a weird pocket of the suburbs that doesn’t have a ton of options for local delivery. That being said, I’m never really excited about eating their food — it’s mediocre and unremarkable, but usually «good enough». It is also way overpriced for what you’re getting — essentially just pizza, pasta, or hot dog stand food. We’re a family of 5, and if we actually order individual items off of the menu instead of pizza, our bill is typically $ 60-​$ 70. We can eat at a dine out place with drinks for less than that. So basically, it’s our best (least worst) option only for pizza, but we’re always looking for a new place that will deliver to our address.

We tried this restaurant for the first time for a family Christmas gathering and we were more than pleased! The beef was tender and tasty, chicken moist and spiced just right, and the pasta was excellent! We ordered Caesar salad and the veggies fresh… and the homemade dressing was beyond any expectation we could have ever had! The prices were reasonable, there was plenty of food and it was delivered on time and piping hot! We WILL be ordering again and would recommend this restaurant to anyone!!!

I will NEVER order from them again. I have ordered from them several times prior with no issues. However, after today, it’s a wrap! Their delivery man buzzed my apartment when he got here. I live on the first floor. However, he went up to the second and third floors. I buzzed him in three separate times and even when to the front of the building and he was no where to be found. When he finally found my apartment, he didn’t even knock and just let himself in! I’m a single girl and here comes this strange guy walking into my apartment.
I called the restaurant to complain and asked to speak to the manager. The manager told me that this would be his first and last warning and that he wouldn’t be working there much longer. He wasn’t very apologetic but his response leads me to believe that this isn’t the first time something like this has happened. My mom happened to be over visiting and was in complete disbelief that this had happened. I was a fairly frequent customer, but I’ll stick with rosati’s pizza from now on. At least I know I’ll feel safe when their delivery men come.

I’m a long-​time customer and long time Chicagoan, so I know my Pizza! Of all the «non-​franchise» places, Saverio’s is the 2^nd best in Carol Stream — 2^nd only to Lou Malnatti’s. I highly recommend it.

It might as well be a late 1970’s Domino’s pizza with an idiot on the phones. Too inconsistent & expensive.

20″ BBQ chicken nicely fed 4 adults and a toddler for under $ 30 with a coupon! Arrived within an hour, as promised. Everyone thought it was really good. We’ll be repeat customers :)

We’ve had the thin crust pizza 4 times, & it’s always fresh tasting & very good. Nice crispy crust every time. They send out great coupons. It always looks very clean. We haven’t tried any other items, as we were looking for a great pizza place & so far, they have been very good.

I tried this place tonight and while there wasn’t anything bad about the pizza (thin crust), it wasn’t good enough to make me a repeat customer. The gondola dog was good, not to mention huge (see photos), but again, not enough to draw me back.
Sorry Saverio’s, I wanted you to be my new favorite, but you didn’t make the cut. There are plenty of pizza places in the area I plan on trying for my quest for a pie that rivals my old hometown favorite — Palermo’s (Oak Lawn, IL).

I’ve got 2 words that set off Papa Saverio’s from the rest of the world: Gondola. Dog.
This ingenious invention is a hot dog wrapped in melty mozzarella cheese and then wrapped in pizza dough. But, they dont stop there! They coat the baked bagel dog in garlic butter that pretty much made me sploodge when I had a bite. Top that all off with some marinara sauce and you have an excellent START to your dinner!
I’ve also had the combo, the classic beef, and the Chicken Sevario (fettuccine alfredo w/​broccoli, mushroom, grilled chicken breast and melted mozzz. Everything was tops.
I also had the pizza once. We got your pretty typical sausage and cheese and it was also quite good (although not as wowing as the Gondola Dog).
This is more than likely my favorite place to order from around the Carol Stream/​Wheaton area.