Very good pizza. If you’re a freshman college student you know about this place before you’ve gotten your fall syllabus.
David D.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Fairborn, OH
This place was FANTASTIC. Pizza was great their Sunday night special is the best, cheesy bread was fantastic, service was great, it’s nice to get a great pizza at a reasonable price where you don’t have to pay for the chain store prices is handmade. We will be back again.
Craig M.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Cedarville, OH
I realize that this is a hometown review, but Colonial Pizza has an earned reputation for great pizza, enzonis(a calzone at some other places), and sub sandwiches. A personal favorite is a mushroom and green olive pizza for my veggie option, and adding bacon to many of their pizzas is a great option. People who used to live here long for a pizza from Colonial, and when they visit they always want to go there!
Carrie H.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Russiaville, IN
Family Loved it!!! Great stix and pizza. Too bad we are from out of state. Would love to visit more often.
Caleb M.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Cedarville, OH
Good pizza. Great option in town when you get tired of cafeteria pizza. They close early and I am pretty certain that they do not deliver. Fun for groups and parties and pick-a-dates.
Tony C.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Xenia, OH
By far the best pizza around! period!!! Always polite. Order does not take long even when walking in for a take out. Large pizza with everything on it is our favorite! My daughter and Grandkids will be here soon and they’ll get to enjoy it.
Andrew F.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Cedarville, OH
If we’re talking best pizza in town, Colonial’s the place. It’s also the only place. They have solid pizza and sub’s. The menu has a lot of good choices and they have good hours. If you’re looking for a good place to eat for dinner, colonial is a solid choice. It’s not the delicous thin crust east coast pizza I’ve become accustomed to, but for an Ohio pizza joint it’s not bad. They also have Pepsi, which we all know is the inferior cola. Overall a solid choice for food in the ‘ville!
Hannah D.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Reston, VA
Great crust! Loved the buffalo chicken pizza. Service is a little slow, but the pie is worth the wait.
Ashley D.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Wilberforce, OH
Really good Enzoni, cheesy bread and subs! Haven’t tried the pizza yet, but I’ve heard it’s good too. Cozy atmosphere, reminds me of an old cottage. Staff were all nice and helpful. Went there for a birthday party. We will be back for sure!
Nathan M.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Grand Junction, CO
The lobby of this restaurant was hotter than outside and it was a very hot and humid day when I visited. I nearly left without ordering. This appears to be the most popular restaurant in town, and for good reason. The pizza and salad that I had were both excellent and the dining area was cooler than the lobby.
Taylor M.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Cedarville, OH
Best Pizza in Ohio! People drive from all around for this small town treasure.
Robert M.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Mason, OH
The Deluxe pizza(I prefer regular vs deep dish crust) and Colonial sub(multi-grain bun, please) are fantastic. I’m working about 5 miles away(60 miles from home) and stop by at least once a week.
Kristyna Z.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Cedarville, OH
The cheesy bread sticks are to-die-for!
KariDe L.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Springfield, OH
Great food! Could use a friendlier staff.
Daniel W.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Cincinnati, OH
Colonial Pizza is a solid place to stop for dinner of lunch. They have recently expanded and haver a lot more seating. The food is pretty good, but not exceptional. The also have a pretty big menu, so you should be able to find something for everyone. The only real knock is that service can be a little slow, so call ahead. The service is usually pretty friendly, though I went once when they seemed annoyed that I asked for a box for the leftovers. They deliver(even to the dorms), which is a huge bonus if you don’t have a car or you live on campus. The prices are middle of the road, not a great deal, not a rip off. Good for large groups to dine.
Brandon R.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Xenia, OH
Nice looking place. However the person who took my order had no understanding of the menu. The dough was soggy and probably needed par baked. They get points for making their own dough and having a creative menu; but I wouldn’t eat it again
Julie T.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Cleveland, OH
Loved this place. I had driven by last weekend, but not at meal times. This weekend my mom and I are exploring this part of the state and we happened to be by around dinner time. We got a small pizza(they have several sizes to choose from and thin or thick crust), which was the perfect size since we are traveling about and can’t take any leftovers with us. The pizza was hot and very tasty. We also got some breadsticks that were really good. The place is cute inside and the prices are fantastic. Our whole meal for two with drinks was under $ 15. I would definitely come back to the Colonial.
Brandon W.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Cedarville, OH
Love the pizza, especially the ham and pineapple. Pizza is only as greasy as the meat you put on it. Nice dining area with recent renovations to the resturant.
Greg F.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Reading, PA
Pizza is fine, can be a bit on the greasy side… Breadsticks and cheesesticks are a hit. Salads are also very good. Service can be a bit on the slow side, but it’s understandable because there are usually only two or three people running the whole show.
Nathan R.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Cedarville, OH
Pizzas and subs are always really great. Chicken nuggets are good, but serving sizes leave much to be desired.