Pascarella Brothers Delicatessen

Holy Moly! This place has sandwiches down to a science. SO delicious. My kids crave their subs. The gluten free bread was amazing! The guys are all so nice, too!

These guys do a great job, and you get that Jersey-​family– feeling in this Deli, and that is hard to find these days. And there is little standing around, you won’t wait in line here for 25 mins to get a sandwich at Noon. A good experience and what you should expect at a good Deli.

The best local deli!!! I have been going to this place weekly for over a year now and it is always spot-​on. They are very accommodating to any customer needs and are always so friendly.

I am going to start by saying Gino and Anthony are super nice guys. I can definitely taste the love in their food. Excellent sandwiches, wraps, and salads. (I especially LOVE their sloppy joes!) I always have a hard time deciding what I’d like to order because everything I have had has been delicious. Pascarella Brothers Deli is definitely one of my favorite places to order from.

I read all these great review that I had to try it. Unfortunately I was not as impressed. The sandwiches were made with good deli meats but had really average bread. It’s just one step above a Subway sandwich.

Most amazing sloppy joes in New Jersey!
Such friendly owners and staff. All round great deli.

Amazing very fresh sandwiches. My bf always gets the pascarella brothers special with hot peppers. I have tried multiple different ones, although usually go with the turkey, gouda, and avocado wrap.
The best part of the deli I’d that I have 2 gf family members and they have a dedicated gf section. Makes our family get together easy. .just pick up sandwiches without any worries about cross contamination.
The staff here is excellent. We usually call in our orders to prevent the wait that can occur during busier times. Anthony and Gino’s do a great job…

I was virtually certain I had reviewed this place .I’ve been here 3 times and I like it for take out hoagies. I’d go crazy trying to eat in the place because its a cacophony of competing noises. I think you do best getting here early or calling your order in. I like the Pascarella Hoagie or Italian and the Turkey with fresh mozzarella. The ingredients are good and they are reasonably quick. The parking lot is a little tricky and if your crossing the road to go to Summit or Bottle King, be careful.

I had to throw out a 3^rd of my order as a wrap was so mushy it couldn’t be eaten. The Cuban panini was ridiculously small for the price. When I ordered a sloppy joe I was given a pre made one from the case. I don’t like or eat pre made sandwiches and it would have been nice if they had asked if I wanted a fresh one. I will probably be throwing that sandwich out as well.
Today was my 1^st and last visit. Too bad as I live nearby and like to support local businesses

Don’t order in advance they make u wait in same line as walk ins. So by the time the person who ordered ahead gets to front ur food is cold. Very very disappointed .
Food was ok might have been better if it was hot. Won’t be returning. Too many other better choices. Hickory tree or Fairmount country store.

Review #300
I think this place is amazing. I had a gluten free italian sub that almost made me cry because it felt like having a little bit of my soul restored after being denied italian subs for so long. It’s crowded. There will be a line. The sandwiches are great — gluten free or not, they make a great sandwich. There are also italian specialties available and they have an entire freezer section devoted to gluten free stuff. You better believe that this place will be in heavy rotation on weekends when we need a place to grab a sandwich when we are out an about. Thank you for providing the best gluten free sandwich I have ever had.

Pascarella’s is a great deli. The staff is so welcoming and friendly. The food is delicious. After going there once a week for lunch for about a year, I still have yet to have a bad meal. The Taylor ham egg & cheese is better than anywhere else I’ve had in NJ. Their Sloppy Joe’s are amazing, but my favorite is the eggplant pannini with a little balsamic. This weekend is their 5^th anniversary. Congratulations Pascarella’s!

Love this place.
I started coming here about a year ago when I found out I couldn’t consume gluten anymore. Being in love with italian sandwiches, I thought it would be hard to find a place that would make me a gluten free sandwich as good as I was used to.
Pascarella bros does this without a doubt, everytime. My boyfriend eats their regular sandwiches too and loves them.
Super friendly owners, very polite and respectful. They will do anything for their customers.
A little pricey, but worth it.

Let me say that this place is a find!
First of all, the bacon egg and cheese sandwich is the best in the area. I can’t say that with enough emphasis
As for lunch sandwiches. I like the pascarellas special however everything is great here! They cut the meat nice and thin and the guys behind the counter are friendly fast and great
Best deli around.

I cannot believe I’ve driven past this place so many times without stopping in, truly an awesome local deli!
To start, the place is very clean and presentable as soon as you walk in. They have a beautiful display of pastas, sides, meats, and even a ton of frozen sauces and dishes to go. Seriously. Who has whole cases of homemade frozen rollatini and other creations? Just awesome.
The food is really spectacular. well presented, super tasty, and a huge selection to choose from.
Finally, the staff is very friendly, quick, and courteous. Honestly this is the best deli I’ve been to in the area. Good for breakfast, lunch, and dinner!

So I went again, gave it another try and it’s been my third time since ordering the tuna. It’s delish! I know I said the eggplant here sucks but I mean their other sandwiches are amazing. And not to mention the service here is always friendly and nice. Plus they use my favorite pens haha. Definitely a great spot! Be sure to try the tuna on multigrain and the original potato chips. Perfect combo!
Also my coworker got the chicken parm, and said it was decent, which is saying something since he’s Italian haha. So yeah id give that a try too.

We had sandwiches here while visiting friends in the area. BEST sandwich I’ve had in a long time! Really enjoyed the personalities of the staff; fun, approachable, and seemingly care about the customer experience. The menu feels endless and there’s no problem with creating your own if you don’t see something that’s exactly what you want. There’s not much in the way of seating and the small deck out front works in a pinch, but the view and ambiance are nothing to write home about. Still, if I lived here I’d be placing a to-​go order a few times a week!

There are few times in life when you eat something and can’t stop thinking about how ridiculously good it was. That’s what happened at Pascarellas Deli one day last summer when I ordered a Sloppy Joe. It was absolutely perfect — amazing turkey, slaw, dressing, bread. Every weekend, I considered making trips from NYC to NJ just for one of these.

Stopped in with my wife for lunch on a groupon purchase. I had heard great things about this place and I am always looking to find another speciality store close to home for all my Italian delights. The place is cozy, well lit and clean. Staff friendly and customer focused. My first try here when they first opened I had a roast beef joe and was disappointed. The rye bread was too soft and the worst part of it was the bread was so soaked in Russian dressing that the taste of not rare enough roast beef was undetectable. Perhaps it was just a bad day or growing pains.
So I gave it another chance given that my wife now has a gluten allergy, they specialize in gluten free items. I have to say this place really changed my perspective. My wife and I each had an Italian, hers on a GF sub roll, mine regular. The sandwich was perfect in every way. Fresh crispy bread, flavorful meats and cheeses, finely shaved lettuce and delicious red vinegar made for a carefully built sub that was yummy down for the last bite. I even had a few bites of the GF sub and you won’t miss a thing here with a GF version of their sandwiches. You should have heard my wife «oooo and ahh» after every bite of her sandwich. Then she thanked the entire staff at which point they introduced her to the entire frozen section dedicated to gluten free Italian specialities!, Pizza crust, meatballs, fully made pizza, pastas, stuffed shells and soups all for a gluten free diet. She is set now. Can’t wait to go back and try their other menu items.

Best gluten-​free sandwich I’ve ever had.
Even if not gluten-​free — they place looks like at least a 4 star.
Super friendly with great meats and cheeses AND great bread = win!
Absolutely going to go back when in the area. Go!