The best Gaetanos is in Willingboro, Pennypacker. This place is ok
K Y.
Rating des Ortes: 1 Riverton, NJ
Picked up food, only to find it cold and incorrect. As a frequent customer of Whistler’s and Nicks, we decided to give this Gaetano’s a try, as we loved the Gaetano’s at Sherwin Williams plaza forever ago. The wings were cold and greasy, the fries ice cold and glued together, and burger was cold and dry, and the chicken cheesesteak was on garlic bread when specifically asked twice to put on a regular hoagie roll. When we called and told them about our order, there was no manager or anyone to speak to about it, and we were told there was no protocol for this. Sad to say, we will not order again.
Chris m.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Riverside, NJ
Part of a chain that shape shifts over the years, some outlets having pizza, some not(I really miss the original Gaetano’s of Cinnaminson with their superb pizza and very scary-looking, but friendly workers.), but still making THEBEST hoagies and steaks anywhere. It’s the generous fillings, the provolone, but, of course, the capper that puts them over the top are the delicious sesame seeded rolls. These are hoagies and steaks that will make you weep with joy. There’s none better.