Nunzio’s Pizzeria

The pizza is pretty average… the prices are OK and the delivery times are on point. I would normally give this quality of pizza a 2 or 3 stars, but I gave Nunzios a 4 because they are open extra late.

Okay… Sooo… As far as Unilocal was concerned… You can sit down here to eat… Ummm… You absolutely can’t. The parking is on the street and next to impossible to find. The food… We got a medium pepperoni pizza… The sauce was actually good… the crust was burnt. I also ordered a meatball sub. Great bread… Decent meatballs… Not enough sauce. Not my favorite to-​go pizza place, but… I would actually go back (if I were in the area)… Not bad. Certainly not 5-​star.

Only go here if it is your last resort. My order took more than 1hr and 30 minutes to arrive and after delivery, was 3 minutes away from being cold. The pizza was plain and made with minimal amounts of ingredients. I almost thought I order plain cheese pizza. Will not be ordering from here again. Yuck!

Their pizza pie is definitely delicious. Truly not my go to because of the location but when I’m coming back home with friends in a cab from some downtown fun, we make sure to make a pit stop here to get some grub. By the time we order it and fetch a cab, the order is usually ready by the time we get there. They are open super late on the weekends which makes it easy to make a decision on where to go for our late night bites.
I’ve never eaten anything but their pizza which is quite delicious when you’re hung over. I honestly don’t think this pizza tastes that good as a leftover but some people may think otherwise. They were a bit stingy on the toppings but their pizza sauce was pretty good.
Would definitely recommend this place to anyone wanting a pizza super late at night.

I have been eating this pizza for years and its always great the calzones are good too the price is fair and they are open late great for when you are drunk and need something cheesy the subs are ok but i havent really given them a chance wings are great so yea i will always pick this place when ppl ask if i know s good pizza place

This is a follow up to my review of Nov 6. It had taken 2 hours to get my pizza and my side order was forgotten. When I called, I was told that I would get a credit for the part that was not delivered (but charged to my card, of course). Here it is 8 days later and still no credit. Sorry service, even worse pizza and they rip you off. Not worth the time to call them

Nunzios used to be my go-​to pizza joint, not just because they are a hop and a skip from my house or because they’re open super late, but because they had some of the best pizzas in town. Keyword, had.
I don’t know exactly what happened, but I can only assume they started using cheaper ingredients. That’s certainly what it tastes like anyways.
I’ll still continue to order from them though, because every once in awhile you need a pizza delivered to your house at 2am when you have the drunk munchies. That’s really all they’re good for.

The restaurant is very dirty so I definitely would never eat in there. I’ve gotten carry out and delivery a few times though. The pizza is very greasy and tastes like the cardboard box it’s served in. Also, the people working there are pretty dirty as well as sketchy looking. I haven’t been here in awhile because the pizza is garbage.

Vegetarian pizza is really good. I’ve ordered from here several times and the delivery is pretty quick only had one issue and it was because i was charged twice for an order and it took two weeks to get my money refunded. Other than that pretty decent pizza.

This is a solid 3-​star pizza joint. If I was having a really bad pizza craving and they were they only place open I might even toss in another star. It won’t blow your hair back but it’s certainly orders of magnitude better than anything you’ll get in the Giant Eagle freezer section. This was our first experience with Nunzio’s and it was delivery. Here are the highlights:
Customer Service: Average on the phone. I’m not saying I need to have a excitement, it’s just that the guy on the other end was all business, flat affect and straight to the point. I could hear in his voice that he wasn’t happy to be there. On the positive side, he did get our order right.
Delivery: The guy on the phone told us «within the hour». Nice CYA line. The reality? About 20 minutes between hang-​up and door knock. Pretty damn fast if you ask me. They are 0.5 miles from our house, though.
Pizza (medium 8-​slice, pepperoni, mushroom, banana pepper): This is your typical pizza joint pizza. The crust was fair to middling, not too thin not too thick. Crispy and tasty as far as crusts go. The sauce, and probably all of the other ingredients on our pie, was canned and tasted slightly metallic. Not bad, just noticeable. It was also on the sweet side (read HFCS) but all-​in-​all not horrible. I thought they were a bit stingy on both the sauce and cheese amounts. If I can see sauce through the cheese, it’s not enough.
Garlic Bread with Cheese: It was a white, sesame seed-​topped hogie roll slathered in garlic butter, herbs and provolone cheese. What’s not to like. Unfortunately, it was wrapped in foil which meant it was soggy when it arrive. Still sucked it all down.
House Salad: No surprises with this one. Your typical pizzeria salad — iceberg lettuce, shredded provolone, diced tomatoes. The tomato was anemically pale and horribly out of season, not their fault, and the rest did as much as it could. The house Italian dressing is very sweet.
Our total order (excluding tip) was $ 20 even. Not bad for two people I suppose. I won’t lose any sleep dreaming about a follow-​up visit with Nunzios but I certainly won’t be having any nightmares either. They’re a bit of a neutral experience as far as I’m concerned.

Yes they deliver and the timing is reasonable. Quality is OK. As for leftovers… Don’t even go there. OK fresh, and it doesn’t get better than that. Their hours are phenomenal though. If you have a late night craving for pizza they’re open! Just don’t expect it to taste the same the next day when you reheat it — oven or microwave. Decent if fresh. Fresh is best. Period.

This nunzio’s location used to be my go-​to for pizza. their hours are awesome, they are a block away from me, and best of all they had the most bomb pizza in the area — second only to Angelo’s in lakewood, in my opinion. Service was only good if you were a female in my experience, which worked for me. unfortunately, within the past year, they’ve changed their recipe and lowered the quality. I tried it at least 5 times after this change to confirm something was off, and sad to say but a pizza place I would have given 5 stars at one point is now isn’t even a last resort. I’d take little Cesar’s or any other crappy chain pizza over the «new» Nunzios any day.

Very good pizza, open late and has a very wide delivery area. The pasta and cheesy garlic bread is pretty good too.

We get pizza delivered from Nunzio’s a few times a year. We get the «Margherita» which is a cheese pizza with a garlicky tomato sauce. This is not a health food item — more of a special treat. The pizza has always been consistent. And our one cat loves their pizza boxes.

If you like pizza that tastes like BRUT cologne then this is the place for you. THIS PLACE IS NASSSTY. NO THANKS.

GREAT PIZZA & WINGS!!! I’ve been getting their pizza for years. They are open late. Awesome!!!

There is something intriguing about any pizza place in Cleveland that DOESN’T deliver. It makes me believe that the pizza must be THAT GOOD; sooo good that they couldn’t possibly deliver a hot pizza with all the orders they would get.
Nunzios was nothing like the exclusive «takeout only» winners like Pizzaz, Guidos, and Corleones. I think the only reason they dont deliver is because they dont make boxes to hold in that much grease.
The pizza was very commercial, the cheese didn’t stretch into gooey strings like real cheese; it slides off as one chunk at the first bite.
Pizza is something that I get when I’m too lazy to leave the house. If you are going for takeout; there are a ton of really great restaurants in the area that are far better.
I compare Nunzios to that Gyro stand outside the bars at 230– it’s open, it’s nearby, and you will regret eating it the next day.

Among the many independent pizza restaurants in the Old Brooklyn corner of Cleveland, Nunzio’s is very much a place that caters to the drunk crowd. Having ordered and picked up pizza several times now, they don’t seem to start cooking the pizza until you arrive to pick it up. If you call and they say it will be ready in 20 minutes, it will REALLY be ready 20 minutes after you walk in the door. Seems like they are used to dealing with a large quantity of no shows.
As for the pizza itself, the quality is comparable to Little Caesars or any other mass produced chain. The pizza is delightfully greasy; the bottom of the box becomes transparent if you save pizza for the next day’s breakfast or lunch.
Basically Nunzio’s exists to fill one need: those too drunk to drive to Taco Bell for after bar munchies.

Without question, this place serves up great tasting pizzas at reasonable prices and remains open well past the closing times of most pizza shops. Hands down, one of the best on Clevelands West Side. I have eaten here only 5 times or so, but every time was just as special as the one before.