The Everything Bagel of Commack

Made a mistake on my last two visits, totally crushing my perfect bagel dreams. I won’t give up just yet, though. Stay tuned.

Excellent BLT on a sunflower flagel with delicious chick pea salad!
Staff are very friendly!
Will def go back again!

The bagels are huge, hot, and always fresh. The cream cheese is always creamy and the staff is always sweet and kind. Who could ask for anything more?!

Yummy, I love egg everything bagels and this one did not disappoint.

To start off the bagel store itself is the cleanest bagel store I’ve been to on Long Island. They offer a lot of varieties in meal choices for breakfast and lunch. There bagels are a good size and very fluffy and overall a good tasting bagel no matter what you choose to put on it like a flavored cream cheese, eggs, or something such as peanut and jelly. For a lunch choice I would highly recommend getting a panini. I had a chicken bacon ranch panini and it was by far the best panini I’ve had on the island. Overall I would highly recommend going to the Everything Bagel of Commack for breakfast or lunch.

It’s gotten even better since my first review. They now have salads at half the price of the nearby bagel place that everyone seems to flock to. Salads are just as excellent which is nice because I REALLY need to cut back on the carbs.

I love this place. They always throw me a discount when I place and order to be delivered to my school. The bagels are often hot. And the women who works behind the counter with the short «reddish» hair is a doll! She remembers everyone’s name.

Their eggs were cooked a bit of average at best; since the eggs had too much white and not enough yolk (for my liking), but they know how to place their cheese correctly onto the eggs (on top and in the middle), which are usually melted in really nicely. They know how to cook their bacon, nice and crispy and if you prefer it not on the sandwich they’re willing to put it on the side in a separate container for you. There prices for the 2 eggs $ 2.50 and just adding an extra egg $ 0.50 is a big higher than most places, (especially if the eggs don’t come out exactly how I like them cooked) as well as adding bacon $ 1.25 (when most just include it with the egg sandwich no additional cost and the cheese). Unfortunately, their coffee doesn’t come included with their egg sandwiches anymore (so I wasn’t willing to pay extra just to try it after spending $ 5.25+tax for one sandwich. When I could have of saved half of my money if I just got a sandwich at 7-​Eleven for $ 2.99). However, if you just want 3 eggs and cheese on a roll that’s just $ 3.50.

best bagels on Long Island!!!