Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

Sucks so bad. We spent a lot of money here over the last year and it just gets worse. Over ten times we have asked for delivery and not once have they ever followed through. Their staff cannot even cut a pizza. We spend over fifty bucks every time here and it is consistenty ridiculous. Not that jj Maxwell’s pizza is any better but at least the service is. Tonight I phoned in on a nice night and the delivery time was two hours. You suck some serious ass Anthony’s and I will not ever spend another cent on your shit food. I just wish I would have taken photos of our last huge order of half burnt pies and under cooked crap. CLOSE DOWN DIP TARDS. I HOPE THE MANAGER CHANGES THINGS BECAUSE NO ONE WOULD BE PROUD OF A SHiT STORE LIKE THIS.

I came in there for their lunch special today I got two slices with two toppings and a soft drink for $ 8.50. The slices came out hot, the crust was then and crispy, and they were generous with the toppings. It’s definitely a great spot for lunch or to get a pie for carry out.

Please note: I am giving this one star rating based on the service alone. Honestly, I am sitting in the restaurant currently waiting for my food and even if the pizza was the best I’ve ever had, the attitude of the girl that took my order has ensured that I will never come back. We walked in on Sunday night at 6 to a cluster of what I assume are teenagers based on the creepy stares and childish snickers that were going on behind the counter. I regretted it immediately. The ordering process was awkward to say the least. It seems hard to find good help these days and I think it would serve this place well to get rid of the 5 terrible employees I experienced and maybe hire like, 2 grown up employees. Also, one of the guys behind the counter JUST said f**k. So, that’s offensive.

Pizza is good. Service is terrible. Ordered a pizza. 45 minute wait. Show up 50 minutes later and they had not even started to order. No apologies. Staff could careless.

Ordered online at 5pm for a 6:15 delivery. Called at 6:30 to check, pizza wasn’t out of the oven yet. Asked for an expedited delivery, then proceeded to get yelled at by some dude named Anthony (fake name I bet) for 10 minutes b/​c they were busy and I should have known better than to order online. Really? My fault? All I asked for was a call if the delivery was substantially late, apparently the didn’t care enough to do that. More yelling ensued. Pizza shows at 7:30.
I understand mountain time, everything is slower and takes longer. On random nights when they don’t have a delivery driver, I get it. But to be disrespectful and belligerent, no excuse for that. Papa Murphys, JJs and The Den will get the reward of my business. This place needs to remember who the customer is.

The place has an overall good time kinda feel. Generic looking wall of NY photos, coupled with an opposite subway tile wall. I love me so Aspen Park.
The food is better than but not equal to Fazoli’s. Reminds me of your everyday, pasta joint. I’ve had the Stuffed Shells con Marinara. I wouldn’t have known they were frozen until they were hollering it from the back to their location. The meatballs that accompanied them were a bit dry. Their white pizza is pretty good as per my SO. She says the Chicken Caesar Salad was on point, too. I love me this marinara sauce.

They carry gluten free dough for pizzas! I enjoyed this place because of the menu options that were allergy friendly. In consideration to the other places in the area I would recommend this place.

They deliver way up here!!! We just moved here from Virginia, and are so excited that we found a great pasta place that will actually deliver to our new address way up on the top of Conifer Mountain! Back in VA, we ordered out delivery just about every Friday and Saturday night. I knew when we moved up here that we wouldn’t have many restaurant options, but to find one that delivers… awesome! The food is great, the driver was great, and I am in heaven! I know it cant be easy delivering up here, that’s why I will tip extra. Hopefully they don’t change the delivery radius! I highly recommend Anthony’s in Conifer!

I would probably only give them 1 star, but they are the only place I know of that delivers in the area. The pizza is really greasy, sloppy, missing texture and flavor. If you decide to go for delivery be prepared to wait 1 – 2 HOURS. If you are doing pickup, you’ll still be waiting a while. I have tried their breads and pastas too and both were meh. My partner likes their pizza, so I imagine other people do too but if I am craving pizza and passing Aspen Park, I am going to Papa Murphys.

I was craving a chicken Parmesan sub and stopped in here for lunch. The reviews left me hesitant but wow I was pleasantly surprised! They were out of chicken Parmesan so I went with meatballs instead and my girlfriend got the ravioli. Sauce was excellent on both items, meatballs were very flavorful and tasted fresh (made in store) which I can’t confirm. The bread on the sub was excellent, very fresh and soft. We also split an Italian salad which had nice fresh shredded cheese and a solid dressing. I would stop back here in a heartbeat next time I need lunch in the area. Easily a better option then the Wendy’s right next door.

I know good pizza. And Anthony’s is pretty darn good. Especially since there is not much else up there. I loved when I lived in Conifer getting my pizza on thanks to Anthony’s. Delivery has got to be difficult up there, but still had delivery. Many times I just stopped in and picked up a slice which I loved. There is no other place up there that you can do that. I typically get extra cheese because i just love a ton of it. Their sauce is great because its not extra spicey. Its marinara as it should be.

Again pizza approved by this Jersey girl’s high pizza standard.
The only negative, which isn’t really a negative to some people, they put a little too much Cheese!

Pros: Really good calzones and baked pastas. Yummy!
Cons: Food took FOREVER (literally over 30 minutes) to arrive at our table after ordering — and we were the only patrons in restaurant at a slow off peak time in between lunch time and dinner.
Also, the food seems way overpriced and the service (we weren’t offered any service at all except a quick order taking when we first arrived and wordless delivery of our meals) definitely leaves something to be desired. If you have tons of time to sit and wait the fresh pasta and calzones might be worth it.

Awful. We have given this Anthony’s location more than enough chances to impress us. We have placed orders for deliveries to our home and they either have a two hour wait for delivery or they agree to deliver and never show up! We have even gone in to the store to pick the food up ourselves and have waited in store for more than 30 minutes. There are never any sincere apologies and despite my request to speak with the manager or to have him call us we have never heard from
him. This owner has the entire pizza market up here to himself and shows no effort to make solid name for himself. Doing just the BARE MINIMUM. Good food. Horrible service.

I have been to several Anthony’s locations throughout the greater Denver area, and this one is my favorite. These guys have NY pizza down to a science, and I am a native born NYer. About 10 or so times over the last 2 months I’ve gone in for lunch, ordering 2 – 3 slices. Every slice has been perfectly cooked and delicious. I do wish they were a little less meager with the toppings, but I could easily just eat cheese slices all day. My GF and I also ordered a pizza to our house, and it was cooked perfectly also. It did take quite a long time for it to arrive, but that’s what we get for living in the boonies I suppose: p Just be sure to place your order amply ahead of time if you need to. The staff is also very friendly. They knew my typical order after the first 1 – 2 visits, and always know I like my pizza ‘crispy’- kept in the oven for an extra minute or so. Already can’t wait for my next slice!

Pizza pretty good. However the service and staff is terrible.
They tell you 30 minutes I waited an hour
Twice my order was lost
Waited 20 minutes while the pizza sat on top of the oven because staff forgot to tell me it was done.
Go to Madwells across the street pizza is just as good and no side order of bad attitude.

We have lived in Evergreen without pizza delivery because we were too far out in the boonies on Brook Forest. So after selling our house and finding a rental on Hwy 73 in Evergreen Meadows, we called Anthony’s in Conifer to see if they delivered pizza at the new address. They do! Yeah! We were so excited to have pizza delivery especially since we had a full house of teens playing Dungeons and Dragons and needed to feed them. It is our first pizza delivery night in 13 years. Oh joy– what a special night this will be.
They said delivery would take 2 hours– yikes — I think they need more drivers on a Friday night. It took over an hour before the driver arrived. We were hungry since it was after 8pm and I opened to find a half cheese and half pineapple and mushroom pizza with a slice missing not the supreme style I ordered. Who orders mushroom and pineapple together? Gross — I did taste it and indeed it was «yuck» Oh and I chased the pizza driver down the driveway arms flailing to try to stop him. My husband was laughing hysterically and told me I probably scared him with a crazy hungry lady chasing him.
So what to do when you are unhappy with a restaurant? Hmm, I sat down last night to write a bad review on Unilocal.I hate writing bad reviews. Before I could, the phone rang and Anthony’s was calling me to tell me the driver forgot my pizza and we had the wrong one. They said they would credit us back for the pizza we ordered and asked send us our pizza. I still wanted it. Another hour later I finally had the pizza I craved.
Thanks Anthonys for making our Comedy of Errors right. They credited it us for my forgotten pizza and the teens ate the the wrong pizza in addition to the chicken, sausage, onion, pepperoni jalapeño pizza they ordered. I didn’t like that one either. However my pepperoni, sausage, black olive and green pepper pizza was delicious.
My advice to Unilocalers if you are hungry go pick up your pizza. The pizza is good if it’s hot. The delivery times are too long. However if you are a lush like me and have started into a few happy hour glasses of wine on a Friday night stay put, make an appetizer at home first and if starving with no food in the house– Anthony’s in Conifer delivers. There aren’t many options to pizza delivery in the Evergreen/​Conifer area. Guess we are lucky to have delivery even if it’s a two hour wait. Anthony’s in Conifer will deliver on Hwy 73 up to the traffic circle in Marshdale.

My wife and I were ready to write off Anthony’s. We’d had a few bad experiences in a row, culminating in a delivery that took nearly two hours to arrive and when it did, it was cold and 70% of the toppings were smashed and stuck to the lid. Ughghgh.
I called in just to tell them they had lost a customer, but was greeted by a very friendly and apologetic employee. She quickly offered to send me a free pizza the next time I called in. I hesitantly took her up on her offer. About a month later, i figured i’d use my freebie. To my pleasant surprise the delivery was on time, the pizza was hot, unmarred and delicious! I figured they tried extra hard b/​c i was on the customer freebie list and was not yet convinced. I have since ordered twice more and they have officially won us back.
Good job Anthony’s!

Reading other peoples reviews makes me wonder if we are talking about the same restaurant. We have tried Anthonys twice (both for pizza) and were pretty disappointed both times. The first time the pizza was just plain horrible, the crust was like cardboard and generally it just did not taste good. Our 12 year old son said he liked the place and talked us into trying it again a few months later and it was worse than the first time. The pasta there may be good (I have only tried pizza), but to my taste this place is a bad choice for pizza in an area that has other (far better) options for pizza.

Amazing thin crust pizza. It tastes just like back home in New Jersey/​New York. You gotta go here now!