Cibelli’s Pizza

I’m sad to say quality has taken a real nosedive here. The last few times I’ve been here the pie has been a big fat greasy mess. I literally had to take the pizza and roll it up since the grease had sogged the crust to an unbelievable mess. And that’s after I have them add extra oven time. Sad as hell folks.

This place has the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust is amazing :) It does not get a full score however, as they did not have a changing station for babies, so we had to change our daughters diapers in the car.

This place is by far the best pizza joint in Corvallis! It’s a little more expensive than most of the other pizza places in town, but well worth the extra couple of bucks. I love the thin crust, and I think they get it just right with the salt. Pretty much every other place in town makes their pizza with way too much salt for my taste. The other thing I love about this place is that you can buy pizza by the slice. This is my favorite pizza place in Corvallis, and I’ll continue to be a regular customer of theirs.

For my kid’s 7^th birthday party, we bought two giant pizza: one cheese pie and one pepperoni. Just after pool party, more than twenty children were so hungry that pizza were almost gone soon.
We chose Cibelli’s pizza for two reasons.
The most important one was that pizza had to be surely IN TIME for the party. We had read a lot of reviews, and I thought we could trust this pizza place. I think that we made very good choice! Two pizzas were baked several minutes before the time we specified as pick up time. Not too late, and also not too early (children could eat fresh pizza!). Perfect!
The second reason was that giant pizza could feed a lot of children by reasonable costs. Also on this points, we were right.
In addition, pizzas were delicious!
Thanks Cibelli’s pizza for contribution to let my kid’s birthday party success!

My mom loves, loves, loves, loves this place. Since I decided to show her this place in May, we’ve come once a week or bi-​weekly. Anytime we want to eat out, she suggests coming here and she barely likes eating pizza! We really like getting the personal Combo to share amongst the two of us. Sometimes we will eat get a slice if we aren’t too hungry. The pizza doesn’t have a lot of oil and the flavors are never too over powering. I like that the dough is made fresh and they use some of the best pizza ingredients in the world like their tomato sauce (my sister is a pizza junkie and informed me of this last time we went). I would say this is the best pizza place in Corvallis hands down!

Fast service and great pizza. Greeted by both employees in a cheerful happy mood. Good music playing and even better pizza! Ordered a specific custom pizza and they knocked it out very quickly.

Absolutely the best Greek salad I have ever had!!! My niece and nephews loved the stuffed crust pizza, said it was the best they have ever had.

Cibelli’s is one of the best pizza joints in Corvallis. The price is about average, nothing special, but you don’t get pizza anywhere else that’s quite like theirs. The inside of the restaurant has a great atmosphere, and I really enjoy looking at all the historical pictures and stuff on the walls.

Visiting in Corvallis and was looking for a good pizza, so checked out Unilocal.After reading the reviews and looking at the pictures online I had to check it out. So glad I did! Pizza was incredible worth the trip if your close! Had Canadian bacon, extra cheese, pineapple, bacon (real pieces of bacon strips) and jalapenos. Crust is perfect. Had them cook it a little longer to get crispy!

Darn good New York style pizza!
I was craving some good, fold-​it-​in-​half, New York style pepperoni pizza and Cibelli’s satisfied my fix. Friendly service, reasonable prices (got 6 slices of pizza for just over $ 21 — not bad for the size of the slice!), and quality pie.
Only bummer about Cibelli’s is their location — worked fine for me, but in Corvallis, it’s all about relative location to the OSU campus, and in that sense, Cibelli’s is pretty far away. Hope they can overcome that challenge and stay open, ’cause I’ll certainly be coming back!

Best pizza in Corvallis by far. The slices are huge and delicious. We had the pepperoni and supreme pizzas.

This pizza place was good. I usually don’t like stuffed crust, but I liked their version. I had a pepperoni stuffed crust pizza and the garden salad… only thing I didn’t like was the lettuce was chopped so small it was hard to get onto my fork… but that’s hardly a complaint :) The za was delicious!

Great pizza! Super cool and friendly staff bad the meat lovers and every bite was great. A crust you can eat and super hot ovens that make a great but not burned bottom.

Second best pizza in Corvallis! Their service is definitely the best for pizzas places in Corvallis. Their colossal pizza is to die for and perfect for large groups! I always order it for small parties/​get togethers. They have great student deals. Their actual atmosphere isn’t the coolest, but it’s definitely doable! Not the best beverage selection, but delicious, quick pizza!

Very good New York style pizza. Prices a tad high but is worth it for great pizza. This will be my favorite pizza parlor when I’m in the area next time.

So I’ve ordered here a couple times now. At first I ordered for my husband he loves their stuffed crust cheese pizza and he loves their cheese sticks/​bread. Everytime we do decide to order out pizza he always wants to go here first.
Now one time I decided to order a pizza for myself, something i wanted. I ordered a pizza with artichoke hearts, bell pepper, onion, cheese, mushroom, and pesto sauce. It was really good I enjoyed it a lot and I didn’t get sick afterwards so that was great also!
I would definitely recommend this as the top pizza place to try in Corvallis if you’re looking for a good pie to chow down on.

When we get pizza, it’s Cibelli’s. It is the only pizza place around that my husband and I agree on. Great pizza and salads… great service. Nice décor. Music isn’t too loud. Best bathrooms for a restaurant (have been clean and smelling nice, all but one visit). Reasonable prices. What’s not to love?
Hubs loves white pie with stuffed crust — says it is just like East Coast.
If only they delivered. Then again, it tastes so much better when you eat it on site.

This pizza is ridiculous… ridiculously good!!! Crushed a meat lovers pizza! Probably the best pizza in the Albany/​Corvallis area.
Pros:
Good beer on tap.
Such good pizza (loved the grease).
Lots of places to sit.
Single slice all the way to giant 24′ pizza.
Crust was bomb, super soft.
Get to watch the dude toss pizza dough in the air.
Cons:
A little on the spendy side.
Kinda chincy with the toppings (still good though).

Here’s the scoop: delicious, greasy, thin-​floppy crust (I mean this as a compliment) think Rock N Roll high school when they get the pizza delivered — the first bite is perfection. I love the pepperoni and black olive. My girl has had the margarita and swears it’s the best in Corvallis.
The reason I only gave the rating a ⁴⁄₅ is because the location isn’t too great, but mostly the music is too loud when we’ve gone in. And sometimes it’s country BLARING and honestly, if I’m eating pizza country music is the last thing I want to hear. Also – why don’t you deliver??? Please! But my belly says that’s probably a good thing. So does my doctor.
I love the big huge slices for a great price. Order by the slice or get a giant pizza because the small or medium doesn’t taste as good — the crust is different.

The BEST pizza in Corvallis.
I ordered a takeout order of large ‘White Pie’ with stuffed crust.
This flavor was similar as Apizza Schrolls in Portland and I loved it.
It’s dough was perfect, topping was awesome, and stuffed crust was my favorite. The size was really huge, too.
I tried few pizza places in Corvallis and I would highly encourage everyone in Corvallis to try this pizza.
I don’t think I can order pizza from Domino’s anymore. Cibelli’s pizza wins over every category except delivery option.