love this place. It used to be in the retail part of the village of Cutchogue but now it’s in the old fashioned garage right near Braun’s seafood. The owner is lovely and has been willing to stay open a few minutes late when we’ve driven up after closing time. What a charming little ice cream place.
Tony D.
Rating des Ortes: 2 Mattituck, NY
Place is closed up for sometime now. Do your self a favor head to magic fountain wayyy better homemade ice cream any flavor you could imagine!!! Way better than scoops every was
Frank T.
Rating des Ortes: 1 East Meadow, NY
Business is closed. Just found out that they are moving next door to Braun’s seafood in Cutchogue. Not sure when the opening date is.
Vanessa M.
Rating des Ortes: 4 New York, NY
It is a little pricey but they do make some good ice cream for a hot summer day. We waiting about 15mins to get served and we think it was worth the wait!
Randy B.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Bargersville, IN
Awesome bar. I attended the last night of the season before closing. Live band + Negra Medello on tap= great night!