SmackDaddy Pizza

They are very good for the prices on pizzas and ribs. The crust on the pizza is excellent and they are very generous on the toppings. Lotsa Mozzerrela!!! The staff is excellent the owner stops by your table to see if you are getting good service — which we most certainly did! I will be back again!!!

Best of the best. My boyfriend and are regulars here. Individual pizza are DELICIOUS. Fresh ingredients and excellent customer service make this place stand out. I normally don’t like to eat pizza crust, but when I eat here I look forward to the crust and everything else! Oh and this place is super affordable! Great for the family!

1. Support this local business!
2. Don’t be a stuck up snob like I was and dismiss
this spot based on appearance.
3. Overall, great prices, service, taste.
4. Everything is custom made to order, so don’t expect your food to appear instantly after ordering.
The Philly cheesesteak is legit.
The pizza is also great, this coming from a I don’t really like pizza person.

I don’t live particularly close to SmackDaddy, but I made my first visit today and intend to be a regular. It’s located on the east side of South Federal, just north of Oxford in a small and unpretentious building that as far as I can remember has always housed fast food outlets. Honestly, there wasn’t a single thing I didn’t like about SmackDaddy.
I liked the people — the owner and the staff — all very pleasant. I liked the dining room — quirky, like me — a blond mannequin behind the counter that I kept wanting to talk to, sorta/​kinda 50’s diner motif, bright and clean. I liked the pizza — remember — I don’t debate about the «authenticity» of pizza — if it’s shaped like a tiddly wink, is covered in cheese, tomato sauce and pepperoni, and tastes good, then it’s good pizza. And please, don’t ask, «what’s a tiddly wink»? The crust is buttery, seasoned and crispy, and the pizza is wonderfully cheesy. My family tells me the BBQ pulled pork sandwich is also very good, the wings are good but not great, and they’ve heard consistently good reports about the Philly cheesesteak. On my next visit my plan is to try the Meatball sub.
Most of all, I LOVED the price and value. Lunch specials — 8 inch pizza and soft drink for $ 4.00. Yes, you heard me correctly — $ 4.00. Meatball sub and soft drink for $ 4.50. Philly cheesesteak, fries and soft drink for $ 7.40. Menu includes hot and cold subs, burgers, wings, calzones and pizza. 18 inch pizza with one topping for $ 14.95. Anytime carry out special of two 16 inch pizzas with two toppings for $ 19.95.
Chances are SmackDaddy will never earn any Michelin stars, but it’s really good at what it is — locally owned, nice people, unhealthy but really tasty food and great value. I liked SmackDaddy so much that I’m still trying to figure out why I didn’t give it 5 stars.

I love love love this place. The gentleman that runs it is the biggest sweetheart. The fries both sweet and white potato are amazing. And the BLT… OMG the BLT, now that is bacon.

Wow, great tasting pizza. The crust is crispy and the Cheese and others toppings are great too. Always made fresh to order. They had really good Philly Cheese Steaks but lately the meat hasn’t been that great. Overall, costumer service, price, and taste makes this place a hidden gem in the city of Sheridan.

Good points
1. Excellent quality pizza.
2. Got two larges for about $ 20.
3. Best pizza restaurant with delivery in the area
4. Locally owned and owner operated
Bad
1. First time calling, dude taking order couldn’t get my credit card number right. I eventually cancelled order. Card was charged anyway accidentally. The owner did own up to it. Service on phone very iffy.

SmackDaddy is awesome! My guy and I came here yesterday for dinner. We got a 16 inch, half of the Aloha and the other half was basically a sausage supreme. Soooo much pizza, at a great price. The guy who served us was extremely friendly, as was the woman who made our pizza. We had to wait for a little bit after ordering but it was so worth it! The crust is perfectly crispy, they use a generous amount of toppings, and the flavors blend together perfectly. Definitely ordering delivery or coming back in the next time we have a pizza craving. This is by far the best pizza place in the area (trust me, we’ve tried them all)

Probably one of the best pizza around Sheridan. They made a custom Philly cheesesteak pizza for my craving I had. Crust was amazing definitely reminded me the days I lived in New York. Simple menu is always a plus. If your looking for a pizza craving and want something authentic give smack daddy a try. These Guys are friendly and the delivery time seemed quick enough. Thanks guys will order again soon.

Horrible. Called and placed an order. Estimated delivery time was 50 minutes. Hour 15, no food. We call multiple times and get no answer. At hour 45 they finally call. They had an incomplete address written down and never called when in the neighborhood. They offer $ 20 off on the $ 50 order, but at this time the food was cold. Greatly disappointed in lack of customer service and hospitality. When they wouldn’t comp the food, we opted to pass on 1.5 hour cold. Extremely disappointing.

I just inhaled a BBQ chicken calzone, I think… I blacked out and things are still fuzzy. This might have been one of the best calzones I’ve ever had and will be sure to return. Plus these guys are ridiculously friendly and seemed to genuinely care about how my day was going.

If I could give this place no stars I would. I ordered two pizzas, waited 1.5 hours and nothing. I called their store only to get the answering machine. Finally they called us back stating they got lost because we didn’t give them the apartment number, which actually isn’t true. But even if we didn’t, why didn’t they call us? We had given them our cellphone number. When they called us they said our pizza was cold and it would take another 15 minutes (so this would make it approximately 2 hrs late). We tried to negotiate some kind of discount for their mistake but they wouldn’t really work with us, so we cancelled the order and got a papa John’s pizza 30 minutes later. I’ll never order from here again.

SmackDaddy is great. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful. I went for a lunch and got a personal pepperoni pizza and drink for $ 4. With lots of cheese and a crisp crust, it was a delicious pizza. Whether you are dining in, taking out, or ordering delivery, I would recommend SmackDaddy.

I love this place! I have only had them through delivery, and every time was delicious. The lemon pepper wings are to die for and the pizza is always perfectly cooked. Best wings and pizza I have found in the Denver area!

$ 4 for an eight inch one topping pizza is pretty hard to beat. The pizza was cheesy, with a crispy crust. I was a fan and would happily order the special again. Specials are also offered for wings, burgers and various sandwiches. All looked good and were quite inexpensive.
The staff was super friendly and helpful. I highly recommend a lunch at SmackDaddy Pizza.

Every time I’ve visited I’ve received excellent service and delicious food, and the price is always great for what you’re getting! Don’t be fooled into thinking they’re just a pizza joint. The pizza, burgers, wings, meatball, pulled pork, pastrami, and cheesesteak are all very good! The only thing that could make it better is if they served beer to wash it down, but I’m usually stopping there on my way to work so it’s probably better for me that they don’t!

This is our go to pizza place. The crust is made from the owners grandma’s garlic bread recipe. Thin crust but then a nice twisted crust at the end. I haven’t had a bad pizza from this place. Curb appeal is lacking and its not a beautiful area on South Federal but its worth going to! Haven’t eaten there always done carry out or delivery. A must try!

Great food, great prices, and great service! Really clean and comfortable! I literally crave their food all the time! Mark the owner is an awesome guy. So friendly and appreciates the business. Everything on the menu is good. I love it and everyone I have brought loves it!

I stopped by this place a little after lunch today and there were two guys working. Both very friendly and available right away to take my order and get my food served. I had the 8″ pizza special which I’d have to say is way under priced and way better then getting a slice of pizza at a NY style pizza joints which are typically all soggy and greasy. It took a little longer however but the quality is way better at SmackDaddy’s. I also was headed out the door when they had these large cookies they just started to put out and I had to stop and buy one of those as well which was super good. To my surprise I was the only one in there eating. Knowing how good this place is I’ll stop passing it by.

Soooo… I feel kinda bad for giving this place a meh review. I just didn’t dig it. I wish I did because I live about four blocks away. I did only order a sandwich… I’ll try the pizza and get back to you.
I ordered a chicken parmesan sandwich with extra marinara. The lady who answered the phone asked «How can I help you?» I asked for a pickup. She promptly told me she had someone in front of her and to please hold on. I said cool. She then laid the phone down on the counter, shouted for someone else to take my order and took the other gentleman’s order.
Cool. Fine. Whatever.
So then a guy picks up the phone and maybe we had a bad connection but it was kinda awkward. I said «Thanks.» at the same time as he said «name?» and he said «Vanessa?» so I’m pretty sure it was just a bad connection…
On to the sandwich: It was warm, bordering on lukewarm. The shredded cheese (mozzarella?) was not melted at all. I tossed it under the broiler and it was fine. The chicken, I think, was some sort of processed nugget. It looked kinda spongy. The extra marinara seemed a bit thin but that may also be preference. I like chunky, thick marinara.
I wanted to love this place. I really did. I just couldn’t help thinking; «Meh. I’ve experienced better.»