Best Western Plus Bayshore Inn

Best Western usually know what’s up, but this one in particular was one of the most charming places I’ve stayed in the past couple years, at least.
How about those free cookies upon check in? Along with a friendly face, efficient service, and the coziest little foyer this side of the Humboldt redwoods. We would have stayed for breakfast, but we wanted to check out the Samoa Cookhouse.
I just loved the look and feel of this place! Close to the ocean, but not quite an ocean view. More of a Marsh view. Don’t let that deter you, though. For me, that was part of the charm. This hotel really stood out in a sea of copycats. The rooms are decorated like a Seventeen spread of college dorm room styles, but the bright matching colors made me happy.
Beds are cozy, pillows are soft and plentiful, rooms come with amenities aplenty and are squeaky clean. There’s a sweet pool that’s half indoors and half outside. You would have to see it to get it.
Unique and cozy. Next time I’m up in the area I’ll jump at the chance to come here. My friends and I got a good deal on the room too.

Check in was a breeze. Staff at front desk was super nice and courteous. Got us to our room in no time.
The bed was nice and firm. Pillows were perfect.
This is the last stop for my trip down to San Francisco and the sleep was amazing. I didn’t wake up as much as I usually do during vacation and I woke up like a brand new person. (Kind of)
I would recommend this Best Western. It’s the best deal in Eureka you can find.
There is also a nice garden with massive koi fish. They’re beautiful! Can’t really see them at night but it’s worth it to wake up a bit earlier to spend some time with them.
I definitely recommend this Best Western.
THANKS FOR AN AWESOME STAY!

We the family stayed here on 2÷5÷16 and got to be one of the best hotels in Humboldt county. Classy looking place with the nicest employees and best free breakfast you will ever have. Just don’t eat at Marie calendars they got the worst food, prices high and bad service. Will be back to stay in coupe weeks. (:

This was a beautiful hotel. It was exceptionally clean and comfortable. The shower/​bathtub sparkled it was so clean. The water pressure was great! I was seriously impressed with how nice and clean it was. The staff were very helpful, directing us to restaurants and informing us about the hotel. The breakfast was great the next morning. There were so many choices and it was all fresh. I would stay here again.

Not a bad place to stay. Great area, really good customer service, comfortable beds, plenty to do around the area, excellent free breakfast and the rooms are decent. Also adding, if you are hungry drive out to the island and go try, the samoa smokehouse.” Just make sure you check the hours, great place to get a full stomach. The hotel also offers a coupon for it.

We stayed here one night with our family of 6 Dec
30, 2015. The staff was courteous and helpful the rooms were comfortable and clean, the parking is tight, the breakfast was fine, it did seem a little overpriced.

Stayed over New Year’s and couldn’t have been happier. Clean, spacious, nicely decorated room. Friendly staff and full-​blown free breakfast. Free in-​room Wi-​fi was fast and reliable.

Great stay! Comfortable room and wonderful amenities. This is a great stop in Eureka!

The room was average but the extras made the difference. The girl that checked us in was awesome. She made sure we knew where everything was & everything that was available to us (I’m soooo sorry, I didn’t get her name) The Koi pond in the garden area where we stayed was super neat. The complete breakfast was an experience we’ve never had. (It was included in the price of the room) Not a typical continental breakfast here! Bacon, eggs, biscuits & gravy, fruit, etc. They also had a traditional continental breakfast right by our room for a quick pick me up before the big breakfast. It was a rushed trip, unfortunately,
but if we are ever in the area again… no question where we’ll stay!

I stopped at this hotel because I couldn’t see thru the fog anymore. It was not cheap ($ 149) but it was very clean, well furnished and comfortable. Parking was a challenge and the homeless people around the property made me worry all night, that and the price are my only complaints. The breakfast area is small and was very crowded but the food was good. All things considered I would probably stay there again.

Awesome place! Great service, very clean rooms. The beds were comfortable. Overall very nice & good rates. Great hot breakfast too!

This is a great hotel when in Eureka. There are lots of hotels in Eureka, but really not any nice ones. This Best Western is about as good as your going to find. The rooms are clean and spacious and the hotel is very quiet. I have stayed here several times and been happy with it. Not the best area, so don’t leave any valuables in your car. But overall its fine.
The only thing that keeps it from a 5 star rating is the «Hot breakfast.» The food is of very low quality, Id say lower than McDonalds quality. Powdered eggs, Microwaved bacon, etc. There are some ok choices such as cereal and fruit. But Id stay away from the hot items.
The free in room wifi works great. One of the best free wifi Ive used in a hotel.

This is a huge old motel, with very large poorly lit and poorly decorated rooms. We stayed three nights, but almost left immediately because of the bed. It was extremely soft, hot and confining, and felt like it sagged in the middle. I decided to sleep on the floor and in the process of getting a blanket laid out discovered a thick soft pad on top of our already too-​soft mattress. After throwing the horrible thing in the Jacuzzi the bed was still too soft, but tolerable.
The staff was efficient and polite, breakfast par for the course — green bananas and overcooked scrambled eggs, but good sausage and a nice selection, about what you would expect from any good motel. If you are excited about having a Jacuzzi and the idea of an electric fireplace that produces no heat, this might be a good choice for you. Personally, I don’t think the motel is a good value and plan to try someplace else next time.
I see now that they lowered their rates the day after we left. We paid $ 190. At $ 96 a night it’s fairly priced.

Pro: Nice rooms, comfy bed, great breakfast, good size fridge and freezer, and a microwave.
Cons: Tight parking spots, unresponsive TV remote… and at 3:05am someone thought it would be funny to pull the fire alarm in the hotel.
This hotel would have gotten 4 stars, but on the second night of a 2 night stay, my wife and I were woken up at 3:05am by a fire alarm. There was no fire. The very best way to ruin a good trip is to mess with a person’s sleep, especially when they have a 5.5 hour drive later that morning.

This place was a big surprise! The courtyard garden was gorgeous but the room was incredible. I really enjoyed the spa. A jem in eureka California.

I didn’t have high hopes staying at a Best Western, but it was an enjoyable stay for the short time we were there. There’s an indoor/​outdoor heated pool that we didn’t have a chance to check out. There’s also a koi pond, which was nice and provided a relaxing feeling. Our room was standard. The wall between the bedroom and bathroom was thin though, because you could hear when someone was doing their business in there. Rooms had a mini fridge and microwave. Free Wi-​Fi! Free breakfast in the morning too, but it’s basic. What I liked most about the hotel were the freshly baked cookies. My friend and I ate several of them. We were disappointed there weren’t any when we checked out.

The hotel seems fairly new I guess compared to a few others I have seen in the area. The rooms aren’t bad. The breakfast is pretty good for what it is. They have fifteen pet friendly rooms. If you dont like animals there is a separate pet free courtyard with a private garden. There are security cameras supposedly in the parking lot. That is the good.
The one stars are for not honoring their word. I was going to book through Expedia for a low rate but the front desk clerk talked me into paying more for greater flexibility. According to her; I could get a refund if I left early and I could extend at the same rate if I needed to stay longer. That, according to the assistant manager — Missie — was not true. Now that I need a place for a few more days; they only have rooms available for much more. Now I have to try and find another hotel if possible.

To be frank, when I think of Best Western, I think of motels where the amenities doesn’t matter because you are only staying for a night. This hotels completely erased that prejudice.
Room– [[two words: INDOOR FIREPLACE!!!]] The room was spacious, clean and everything looked really new. The bed and pillows were comfortable.
Layout — The overall hotel was actually cute, they had an enclosed garden with a koi pond with gigantic kois. They also had an indoor hot tub with high ceilings and outdoor hot tub. The pool was also pretty neat with 50% indoor and 50% outdoor. Facilities were clean.
Staff — When my friends and I checked-​in, we asked for extra towels and they said they will bring it up to us within 10 minutes, which they did.
I would definitely recommend staying here.

Everything was excellent. the rooms were clean and nicely decorated. The rooms were large, had plenty of space. They had a flat screen TV, microwave, refrigerator had a grass run on both sides of the hotel for the dog. All the staff were very helpful and polite. The complementary breakfast had lots of choices and was very good. they also offer a 10% discount at both of the restaurants in front and behind the hotel. You can walk to the little bay behind the hotel and enjoy the water. We didn’t use the pool but the kids were having a great time in it. I have nothing negative to say about the hotel. I will stay there again in a heartbeat.

Can I give this place a million stars?
Any place that can take a bunch of teenagers at the last minute and totally accommodate deserves a million stars. The staff was very helpful and ensured our students had a cookie and some water upon arrival. They provided us with the breakfast area to feed them lunch and dinner and continued to check in. At the end we had to make some adjustments with the rooms and again… totally accommodating.
The rooms themselves were clean and had all of the usual amenities.
HIGHLY RECOMMEND as a pit stop while going up North. The rates are super reasonable.