Angelo’s

Absolutely one of my favorites! The bread is to fit for, salad very fresh, spinach ravioli is heaven and so is the eggplant. We were over charged for the kids pizza as it says they get 2 pieces and they are great pieces but they charged us twice. This is an amazing local fav where you will go time and time again.

Decent choice for lunch, however, the menu could be larger. Basically your options are pizza slices, calzones, or two types of pasta. I will say the pepperoni and sausage calzone was pretty tasty. Would consider returning to try something different, but don’t think its a must-​try kind of place when in Evansville.

We had Angelos cater a family gathering, it was amazing. Everything was fresh and flavorful and they delivered it right on time!

I went for dinner with a coworker recently and had an decent experience. Its ambience is nice but the food is alright. The house dressing is great and so is the homemade marina. I had the eggplant dish for about thirteen dollars and a fried provolone appetizer. The fried provolone was simply cheese sticks with dipping sauce. Don’t expect super flavorful food but it is filling. A bit expensive for my taste.

Absolutely love this place. My wife and eat here each Valentines. Took my daughter here for birthday and have reccomended it to our kids for prom. Our favorite is crab cakes over angel hair and Chicken Ala Crema. Portion sizes are excellent. Salad and rolls are great, too. Love the atmosphere and location Main St.

First impression was that the hostess was short and rude. They had 7 open booths, but they would not let us sit in any of them since we did not have reservations even though they were not reserved and had none coming for quite some time. Our party of four large people sat at a small table with poor lighting. I personally will eat elsewhere.

Located in downtown Evansville, IN, on Main St., close to the Ohio river. Food is rich and delicious. I had the spinach ravioli, which was heavenly. My husband had the lasagna, large portion. Complimentary garlic rolls and Italian salad. The rolls are to die for. It is definitely worth a stop, if you are headed downtown Evansville. Would recommend, service good, locally owned.

This place is delicious! The calzones are seriously to die for! Good prices, quick service and a chill atmosphere! Love it!

If you don’t like mushrooms be prepared to have limited options! It seemed they were in anything I wanted and I hate them. The garlic knots are delicious and the server was great but I left there feeling like I had experienced all that there was to experience given the mushrooms and without feeling the need to go back.

The customer service was outstanding here. Trent was my server and he was fast and friendly. I had the Chicken Ala Angelo’s and it was delicious. They need to go lighter on the salad dressing and the garlic butter on the rolls. Also, it would be nice if they would carry some local, craft beer. (Carson’s, etc.) I don’t like chains and I would go back here.

Absolutely amazing. Been a couple of times and it’s been great. My favorite is the chicken cordon bleu. The salad and rolls are a bit oily but I enjoyed them despite this fact. The service was great and they even have a great priced lunch menu.

Angelo’s, in my opinion, is the best Italian in Evansville. The portions are always generous, and the service is generally pretty good. For wifey’s Birthday, we were back in Evansville, and made a reservations for (9) of us on the day after Thanksgiving. Fortunately, Angelo’s accommodated us, even though we called the day of.
Our table ordered the following: Chicken Parmesan, Fettuccine Alfredo, Lasagna, and three of us ordered the Chicken Cordon Bleu, which is amazing. In fact, Angelo’s has the best Chicken Cordon Bleu of any Italian restaurant I have dined at.
Two servers handled our large party, and wifey even got a Birthday Cheesecake (which was amazing) on the house.
Top notch! I will return again when in Eville!

Not impressed. The food was all extremely oily, cream sauce was broken. Customer service was lacking. Our waiter was not friendly or concerned with our experience at all. Very disappointed. Would not visit Angelo’s again.

I had a very mixed experience while at Angelo’s. The staff was phenomenal. They were so kind and accommodating to my son’s food allergy, and just friendly and attentive overall. If I could rate them solely on service, they would get a 5, but it’s hard to overlook the food and décor. Angelo’s poses as a «fine dining» dining restaurant, but they simply are not. The food is extremely bland and almost every dish is swimming in cheese. The décor is lacking. The salad is overloaded with onions and they use Good Seasons salad dressing… not my idea of fine dining.
Honestly, I feel bad giving them a low rating because they are so nice, but the food is pretty awful.

Outstanding food and outstanding service. The rolls were incredible! The staff very professional! The food excellent!

Over-​priced, mediocre food. Yes, the bread is good, but that seems to be their only redeeming quality.

Service was ok. Wasn’t as dressy as my friend had told me. A bit noisy. Food was good. They could have brought more garlic rolls. I started off with a couple of appetizers: the stuffed mushrooms which were excellent, and the fried ravioli which was a little dry but tasty. ho-​hum marinara sauce. the salad was typically swimming in olive oil & vinegar — hey restaurants, can you please CUT THAT OUT — but was mixed up pretty well with red onions and a black olive or two.
I ordered the Chicken Marsala and the Chicken Parmesan. In both cases the chicken was a little tougher than I’d like but it was about as good as you’d expect from a Denny’s. The appearance of mushrooms was pleasant but they should have been cooked longer. By the time I reached the pasta it was cold so I just took it home to reheat for lunch.
They were out of Amstel Light so I settled for a couple of Newcastle’s.
Holy crap. $ 60 before the tip? Thank god I brought a $ 30 Groupon.
If this is the best Evansville has to offer, it’s a pretty sorry town.

I first went to Angelo’s in a large group of about 15 – 20 girls for a birthday party. The staff was incredible. Our waiter was outstanding. He was friendly and just on top of his game.
The food is amazing. It’s authentic Italian in southern Indiana. I’ve had the Chicken Marsala, Chicken Cordon Bleu, and the Lasagna. Everything was AWESOME. The marsala sauce… perfect. The cordon bleu sauce… perfect. I’m not even a lasagna fan and that was amazing.
Free, HUGE tossed salad with an oil based dressing and rolls with a spicy, pesto butter. I LOVE free treats before my meal.
I went to college in Evansville and I would always take visitors here for a nice dinner. Authentic Italian food at reasonable prices. Angelo’s is a must try and in my opinion, a must LOVE.

I have frequented Angelo’s for 13 years now and can honestly say that I will never tire of this wonderful little place.
From the very friendly service, to the warm colors of the restaurant, Angelo’s is definitely my favorite place to eat Italian food. Everything I have ever eaten there is delicious! The lasagna and Penne Carbonara are my two favorites. They offer a nice menu, with plenty to choose from for meat lovers as well as vegetarians. Their salad is always fresh and tasty and their garlic rolls are to die for! Far better than breadsticks you might get at any other Italian chains. They also have a nice wine selection and wonderful desserts such as fresh cannolis and home made Tiramisu. Very nice atmosphere as well.
Oh and lunch is great too and very affordable. At lunch, they have more of a cafeteria style thing going on, where you order from a selection of food they have at the counter, from pizza to pasta, complete with salad and rolls. You can buy a whole lunch with a soda for around $ 6.00 and everything on their lunch menu is incredible too.
Buy local. You won’t be sorry!

Absolutely wonderful experience. The food was positively outstanding. Tonight we started with the Crab Cakes which were made fresh and served over a small bed of angel hair, everything covered in a creamy pesto. I ordered the Lasagna after deciding I wanted something traditional. It came out baked in a dish, absolutely delicious in a slightly sweet marinara sauce covered in mozzarella. Mmm. He ordered Tortillini Alla Pesto. A cheese tortillini with peas and sundried tomatoes served in a creamy pesto sauce (which seemed to be a combination of pesto and alfredo, making it very creamy and delicious).
The food was outstanding, and we even got free dessert: red velvet cake. Mmm. My only real complaint is the crying baby at a near by table – this seems to be much more of an adult restaurant, lots of ambiance. Also, having to wait a good while be for being waited on. After that though, it was a very pleasant meal.