Mr G’s Pizzeria & Wings

This place was a great find. It feels very local, and our waitress was very nice. We ordered their original pizza which sits on a medium crust. The crust itself was cooked evenly on the bottom and the edges. The ingredients were fresh, and the sausage was spicy and delicious. The price was fair for a 16″ pie, the two of us were stuffed after 2 slices!

The pizza was a bit greasy for me.

Pretty good food. 4 stars.
Decent price for what you get. 3 stars.
Like the BYOB. 5 stars.
Rude service. I called in an order, and almost canceled. The girl taking the order was rude, and very annoyed. I thought about canceling 3 times between trying to order and receiving food. Terrible service. 0 stars, negative stars.
Luckily, the food delivery was quick. 4 stars.
It’ll be a long while before I go back.

Wings were good but the pizza was not so much arrived 1 hr and 45mins and was cold. So much sauce on the pizza and the cheese was just a thin layer all of it fell off. Crust was burnt and hard like cardboard. Never again.

After reading mostly positive reviews, I decided to place a delivery order. I generally don’t expect much from pizza joints outside of NY, but I had a long day of meetings and just wanted something quick and delivered. Figured I’d go simple, cheese pizza and chicken parm. Simple enough, right? The pizza was what I would expect in Ohio, however… the chicken was not cooked… AT ALL. I’m not taking somewhat undercooked, this was RAW CHICKEN.
I generally don’t post reviews, but this warranted one. Upon calling and speaking to manager, I was asked if I would like a new order delivered… um, no. Gave me a credit for my next order, which will never be used.
Needless to say, the next time I am in the area for business, Mr. G’s will not be on the menu!

Food is amazing but inconsistently so. Normally I would love to give 5 Stars for real NYC pies so far from the Big Apple. However if this place was in NYC it would be shut down by the health inspecors. Two clear reasons 1) the amount of dust dirt on all the walls and curtains and dusty cobwebs over where food is prepared. Dust is very thick more than a monthly build up. 2) The servers carry out food by the rim of the dish and glass not on a tray. It’s disconcerting to have have a salad given to you with the lettuce sticking to their thumb as they set it down.
I want to give them a five but some routine cleaning up needs to happen first

Delivery Disaster … again and again.,
On Monday I ordered delivery to a neraby hotel. After an hour and twenty minutes, I called and was told the order had not gone out yet, but would soon. And it did. And the food was very good (veal parm).
On Wednesday at 4:30 PM … I figured that I’d order again, and early. The nice lady said the food would be here in 45 minutes.
At 6:00 PM … no food. So I called, and was told that that they had called me twice and got no answer (this is a lie) and that they forgot to write my room number down. Okay, I was then careful to provide my telephone number again, and my room number, and was promised a call back when she found the status of my order.
At 6:30 PM … no call and still no food after 2 hours! Called back and Ron said there was a lot of confusion with another order, but that the driver should be here an minute with the order. And he did arrive … 5 minutes later. Cold!
Are you kidding me? This is the most ridiculous example of repeated incompetence that I’ve ever witnessed!

Hands down the BEST pizza in Summit County! When we want to sit down and enjoy New York thin crust style pizza this is where we go! HUGE pizzas, delicious flavors, great salads, pasta, and a fantastic wait staff! This is a good place for couples, families, or single patrons in a relaxed setting. Look in your entertainment book or Verizon Smart Rewards for coupons!

We recently moved to the area and tonight was our first time ordering pizza here. We wanted to try a local pizza place instead of a chain. Called another local place first that had a minimum order of 50 bucks for delivery. WTF? No thank you! Next call was to Mr Gs. Competent people on the phone. Pizza delivered at expected time. AWESOMELY friendly delivery guy. Tasty pizza with good quality cheese and not overly greasy. «Medium» pizzas were the size of a large at most other places. I felt bad this was initially our second choice… It’ll definitely be our first from now on!

Lots of people have suggested I should try Mr. G’s, so the other night as I was driving past I realized a had a coupon for half off a large, two item pizza. Now I knew going in that their large was 18 inches, much more than I could eat, but pizza is one of those foods that is always good the next day, so what the heck!
I ordered, choosing pepperoni and onions as the toppings, waited 20 minutes, and drove home. My cost, using the half off coupon, was $ 8.75. This ended up being my deal of the month! The pizza measured in at 17 to 18 inches in diameter and was covered with a very generous and quite tasty layer of cheese. The crust was a minimum of ½ inch in depth, about average for regular pizza, and I counted 50 slices of pepperoni on top. The edge crust, about which I am about to rave, was from ½ to ¾ inches wide.
As I already mentioned, the cheese was delicious and plentiful. I would have preferred the pie to have been baked a little bit longer until the pepperoni began to crisp up. But I am not sure that would be possible without overcooking, and ruining, the edge crust. You see, as I was finishing off the first massive slice (two slices filled me) and I got to the edge I fully expected to bite down on that typically dry, hard-​as-​a-​rock, tasting-​like-​cardboard piece of crust that usually gets tossed after the first slice or two. Well Mr. G’s has perfected the edge crust. It is fantastic. It has a nice crunch on the outside and a soft-​as-​a-​pillow inside. So, baking even a few minutes longer could prove to be detrimental.
The pizza is great. I am a fan. I will return. The edge crust almost prompted me to move it up to five stars (a rating I reserve for the pizza that equals one I used to eat at a family-​owned joint long ago in the Mahoning Valley that has long since closed). As it is, Mr. G’s goes to the top of MY (current) list. Well done Mr. G’s!

The service is wonderful. Great menu. The calzones are huge! My one son loves them fried and my other son loves them baked, management is always willing to accommodate any special order. My husband and I love the wings and always get a salad… SO GOOD! Definitely worth checking out!

It’s really hard to find a good gluten free pizza. Mr G’s gluten free pizza is beyond fabulous and my husband loves the (not gluten free) sub sandwiches! This is will definitely be on our dinner delivery rotation.

I’ve always believed that even bad pizza is still pizza. This place has negated that saying for me. This was by far the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Unilocal is full of people saying that such and such food is «the worst I’ve ever had» but this truly is.
We ordered two large traditional pizzas: one with pepperoni and one with sausage and mushrooms.
So why did this pizza suck?
1. The dough was spongy and tasteless. It was like a blob of negative flavor in your mouth.
2. There was barely enough cheese to cover the pizza (ironically we ordered a salad and there was an abundance of cheese)
3. The sauce was WAY too sweet. Even after putting crushed red pepper and Parmesan cheese on it.
4. For $ 2.50/topping I would expect more than a few crumbles of sausage scattered around the pizza.
Basically every component of the pizza tasted bad or was done poorly. We ended up throwing away most of it and I HATE wasting food. Hopefully by writing this you choose somewhere else so that YOU don’t end up wasting money and food too.

We ordered 2 large pizzas to split between 6 people and it was definitely enough! Pizza was great! We got extra cheese and pepperoni/​bacon. Sauce is flavorful and has a bit of a bite, loved it! All I can comment on was the service, as it could be a little bit better. Our waitress didn’t seem to listen/​care very much to what we said and got our drink order completely wrong. Service wasn’t great, but not bad enough to keep us from going back.

My Favorite Pizza by far! Their wedding soup is the best around! The Homemade pasta dishes are to die for and The owner’s (Mark & Debbie, along with their whole family) make you feel like family!!! Love the place, I eat there at least once a week!!! :)

Pizza was very good. and really a lot of food! Salads are tasty. Disappointed there was no wine or beer, but you can bring your own in :)

Great place to sit down and a family and get some fantastic pizza! New York style pizza was great and the service was friendly and top notch. Will definitely eat here again!

My family and I LOVE this place! It is the best pizza I’ve ever had… can’t say enough great things about the customer service, food and prices. This food is from scratch and it’s BYOB — doesn’t get much better than this!

Just had a craving for pizza and this was the next place on my list to try. I called and placed a pick up order, and was given a time of 20 min.
I decided to try the New York style pizza. When I arrived i was a few min early, so I paid and sat to wait. I was offered and drink, and ask specific questions about my pizzas, whether I would like to have it crispy or different. The staff was friendly even though seemed busy. I even heard them take a large order close to closing time.
I couldn’t wait to eat my pizza on the way home, but I made it, and was not disappointed. The pizza was nice and crispy, and the dough tasted home-​made. It had a nice sweet taste to it, soft and crispy on the bottom. The sauce could have been more flavorful for my liking, but it was still great. The cheese was just starting to be crispy, and the pepperoni was nice and crispy on top as well.
Overall, a great experience from beginning to end. I don’t think there was anything that made it extraordinary, which is the only thing that kept it at 4 stars. But as I try more of the menu hopefully that will change! Bottom line is great pizza, great experience at a fair price.

I AM IN LOVE WITH MR. G’S!
This place is absolutely amazing old world Italian. My son got the New York pizza, I got the chicken parmesan and my husband had the all you can eat fish. Everything was so delicious and they give you large portions. The prices are very reasonable and they even make homemade Italian donuts and cannoli’s. If you like authentic fresh Italian food, you have to try this place. I promise you will never want to go back to Olive Garden or Luigi’s. And make sure you try the appetizer garlic rolls.