Frostie Freeze

We stop here on a regular basis. The pink ladies are wonderfully polite and delightful! Its a win win situation, good ice cream, great prices, and bringing the family together for a sweet treat!

Stopped here on our way through Fort Atkins and ordered ice cream for 7 people and my total was under $ 10! They don’t make ice cream stands like this anymore. The menu offerings are huge and their are plenty of picnic tables situated around the property for everyone to have a place to sit. The only negatives are that their is no bathroom and they do not take credit cards. However, their is a Jimmy Johns rights across the road, we got lunch there, used the wash rooms and then headed over to the Frostie Freeze for dessert. If your passing through town make sure to stop for a treat.

The pink ladies serve wonderful frozen treats, from malts to sundaes, it’s always a nice stop along rt 12. Always a line in the evening, but it moves very quickly, highly recommend for a pleasant stop in dairy country.

Yes, do go to Frostie Freeze! The cookie dough candy freeze is the best, or any or the candy freezes for that matter.

Great variety and reasonably priced. A must stop if you are in Fort Atkinson.

If you are from Fort, this review is not necessary. If you are not from Fort, enjoy some small town charm and the best soft serve around.

Frostie Freeze is a staple of any child’s summertime diet from Fort Atkinson and rightfully so! They only have soft-​serve ice cream in three flavors, vanilla, chocolate, and the weekly special. You also have the option to «swirl» or combine flavors, just look at their machines behind the counter.
I typically go for a cookie dough candy freeze (I tell the ladies to load up as much cookie dough as the machine can handle because the owner will seriously get in your face if you ask for extra cookie dough, i.e., «May I have that with extra cookie dough?» «What, do you ask for extras at other restaurants too??»)
The twinkle cones, banana splits and a special drink my friends came up with are the best (fresh strawberry lemonade freeze, it tastes part shake and part freeze (slushy)).
I can’t believe this place doesn’t have more reviews, but it might be because everyone is there (in the summer lines can get looooong).

Love this place. So cute and quaint. The whole town comes out-​esp in the summer. Their flavors change every couple of days. Make sure to try a cone w/​twinkle cote! Oh-​and it’s cheap :)