Mary’s Mountain Cookies

We have been to several locations now, this one has tons of varieties that we haven’t seen before! Love the s’mores, and Orange Snickerdoodle. Try them!

Oh man. These cookies are to die for. Come hungry and don’t plan on leaving feeling good about yourself. Grab a coffee across the street and then come have a cookie and people watch at a window seat.

Super delicious cookies, great selection and friendly staff! My family from CT always makes this their first stop in town. Plus they’re in a beautiful setting in downtown Fort Collins. How can you go wrong???

After doing a little Unilocal research it became quickly apparent that I needed to stop in at Mary’s Mountain Cookies before I headed back to SLC.
I walked through the door directly when they opened at 10am on a Wednesday morning, and was hit with the over stimulation that is the amazing smell of fresh cookies, and the vision of endless giant treats neatly arranged.
I’m bad with decisions, but needed to start my travels home, so instead of picking two treats like a normal person (when you’re sharing with one other), I went with four. Getting the: Salted Caramel, S’more and Peanut Butter chocolate dipped cookie + a mint chocolate brownie.
And then. I needed to wait more than 7 hours to consume them. However, I can speak to the fact that these excellent cookies hold up while traveling cross-​country.
Once I got back into town and met up with my sister, we dove right in. And oh, man!
What spectacular, ginormous cookies. The Salted Caramel one was definitely my favorite, but that’s not to say I didn’t enjoy the other cookies. The S’more cookie was definitely inventive — there was no way I could leave without getting one to try. And though a peanut butter cookie is pretty standard, this one was great half dipped in delectable chocolate.
When first deciding on treats, I went with the Mint Brownie in lieu of the Cream Cheese Brownie — as I felt it would hold up better after hours of not sitting in the cold. The Mint brownie was good… once you got past the flavor like you were eating toothpaste. I think for any future visits, I’d stray away from the mint brownie and try different ones.
These cookies are huge, well worth their price, and compared to other cookies I’ve had, not so incredibly sugary that it hurts. This cookie shop is so easily accessible, there’s no way I would be able to make another trip to Fort Collins without trying others! And if you’re in the Fort Collins area, you really have no excuse for not being there right at this very moment.

I was participating in a sweets online gift exchange. Being the procrastinator I am I waited till the deadline date to ship my package. I was frantically searching google for sweets delivery services in Fort Collins. That’s when I stumbled across this gem! I called to ask a few questions and had a lovely conversation with a lady who’s name I can’t remember but she had amazing guest service and suggested a few items. I completed my order online and it was delivered within 3 hours.
Not bad and would recommend if Ya live in the fort Collins area.

Wish I could give a million stars because these are THE BEST COOKIES IVE HAD IN MY LIFE… no joke…
We bought 6 and got 2 free. 3 days later the cookies are just as good as the day we bought them!!!

Stopped in to get some cookies after a day of walking around and shopping in Fort Collins. These cookies are amazing! They are huge, but absolutely so delicious that you won’t want to share. I had the oatmeal chocolate chip, mmm mmm good. My mom had one that was cranberry oat walnut and white chips… oh man, that was so heavenly good. I love that they are local and are not a huge chain, but I do wish they had more store fronts around Colorado, but my waist is glad they don’t! I can’t wait to go back!

Best darn cookies I ever had from a store.

Little shop that tries to drive the local and authentic. You know, for the little person. Except that my little girls needed to use the restroom and they shrugged their shoulders. They want the small town cred and service but don’t want to be burdened with providing it. Boo!

Oh my god. Yum.
Mary’s mountain cookies are a Fort Collins staple. Get a cookie cake for a special occasion! Can’t beat them

Stopped here on a recent trip to colorado and was impressed with the selection. The cookies we tried were delicious and loved the ice cream sandwich cookies. I totally recommend this place if your in the area.

The gluten free cookies are awesome. Been in Fort Collins for 4 days and have already been here twice. Thank you for the gluten free options!

Summary:
Cheap, Delicious, Variety
Food:
The s’mores cookie is freaking delicious. Had one of their brownie’s too and it was rich, gooey, delicious. They had probably 24 options to choose from with ice cream sandwiches to top it off.
Service:
Very friendly, helpful in suggestions, and playful in jokes.
Value:
The size of their desserts is huge. I’d recommend splitting a few items with your friends so you get lots of variety. Coming from Seattle this place is half the cost, and twice the amount I’m used to so a super good deal in my book.
Location:
Going through old town on a hunt for dinner we past this place and almost skipped dinner but decided to come back afterwards. Lots of other places around, easy parking, very convenient. More of a grab and go rather than a sit and eat type place.
Comments:
I’d be fat if I lived near Mary’s Mountain Cookies

Awesome cookies, very nice staff. I recommend this place.
All the employees were attractive blonde women.
They were open till 10 pm!

Absolutely worth the $ 3. I ordered a s’mores cookie. It was recently baked (~7pm) so clearly they’re continuously baking throughout the day. The service was friendly and they had samples out. Like another recent reviewer, I, too, bake frequently and wanted to be able to scoff at this standard-​looking cookie shop… but I’m glad they proved me wrong. The cookie was a rich, goopy, mashmellowey mess, complete with Graham crackers atop and below the cookie. I’ll definitely return soon for an ice cream sandwich.

If you like cookies, this is the place for you. The staff are really friendly, and the cookies are great. I wish they had more selections that have nuts in them. Thankfully the turtle cookie is really good. Make sure to check in for a 20% discount!

Good God almighty. Let me start by saying that I am a longtime hobbyist baker. I bake ALL THE THINGS, all the time. My favorite thing to make (and eat) are cookies. This is all to say… I am very, very picky about baked goods and cookies in general.
THESE. ARE. GREAT.
My absolute favorite is the chocolate chip cookie dough sandwich (look for it in the fridge). They also make a mean Charlie Brown, which is a giant peanut butter cookie half-​dipped in milk chocolate. They usually have a great special where you buy 5 or 6 cookies and get one for free… do it! Freeze them! I am both glad and sad that they don’t have these in the Bay Area where I live, because I would be here all the time.

so so.
we were visiting from Chicago and found out about this place from Unilocal.Don’t get me wrong, the cookies were good, but not 5 star good. Not gonna lie, a little shocked with the reviews. Service was sweet and the place was cute, but the cookies were just A-​OK

Walked in here after having some great sandwiches at Backcountry Delicatessen.
We were invited to sample a few of their offerings on a plate:
Chocolate Avalanche– Put fudge filling between two chocolate chip cookies… and there you go. Pretty tasty, not too sweet, but very much so…
Snickerdoodle– Their rendition was a bit saltier and heftier than your typical sugar-​cookie-​like snickerdoodle. Not sure I’m a fan.
I ended up getting a big Blueberry Cheesecake cookie, which turned out to be pretty darned good I must say. Large blueberries still intact inside the cookie, combined with cheesecake batter and a slightly hard frosting drizzled over the top of the cookie. Really good. Just right.
A hefty cookie will set you back about 3 – 4 bucks, so be warned. :-)
If I’m ever back in the area I’m going to try their Ice cream cookie sandwiches…

Oh, what a dangerous place. There ought to be a warning posted on the door for dieters, diabetics, and those suffering from ADD because you are not going to be able to walk out of here without a sugar buzz in a little brown paper bag.
I am someone who finds myself in that first category of people more often than I’d really like to admit. I will try to rationalize the indulgence by telling myself that I will only eat half of a cookie. The fault in that logic is that the cookies are ginormous, so only eating half hardly represents a restrained portion, not to mention the fact that to date I have not had the self-​control to stop at half a cookie.
I recommend coming here to split a cookie with a friend, that is if you can agree upon what kind of cookie … so many delicious flavors, often with seasonal or holiday-​specific specialties to choose from!