Sundaes Ice Cream Parlour

The BEST homemade ice cream in Ft Myers. My husband and I can’t get enough of the White Chocolate Ice Cream with White Chocolate Chips and Raspberry Truffle Cups!

Time to treat MrsO to an ice cream cone. Place is a bit tricky to get into when there is a lot of traffic on MacGregor, but we got in. Huge cones in a 50’s like atmosphere. Lots of flavors available. For sale sign made me wonder if they were still open. Not sure of their future. Will keep tabs on it.

GIANT portions, teeny prices, super friendly service in a kitschy retro atmosphere. Reminded me of the best dairy bars of New England. Glad I could stop in and get a cone. Their soft-​serve was really good.

Although not located in the most scenic area, this store is filled with good vibes, friendly staff, and great ice cream. I recommend the pistachio!

Great ice cream! Great hot fudge! Feels like an old ice cream store and has a wide selection of different flavors for a reasonable price. I recommend the cookies and cream for those Oreo fans, and the hot fudge is amazing as I mentioned before. Great place to go for some great ice cream!

During my time in Fort Myers, I would drive back and forth on MacGregor because if I wasn’t burning gas, I was watching Harry Potter for the billionth time. Sundaes was this pink building on a major intersection but always looked closed. Why? Why are you closed? It’s fucking hot outside, this is what you’re here for!
My father and I were convinced that it was a front to something. I mean, it was never open.
On our last day, driving back from Starbucks, I saw the «Open» sign up and threw my car into first gear and slammed on my brakes to get into the parking lot. Okay, over-​exaggerated, but you get my point.
I walked in and immediately went to the counter where I asked for a sample of the cookies and cream. I don’t know your ice cream, it could be Breyers or something. The owner then berated me for asking for said sample. «No one ever asks up north (East Coast)! That’s sacrelig, you get in, you order, you get out!»
Okay, well, uh… you own a goddamn ice cream business. Have you stepped foot in a Baskin Robbins? It’s standard practice. I swear I thought he was fucking with me. Oh no, he wasn’t. He was serious. The rest of the visit was just as surreal. Apparently they get their ice cream from the goddamn Amish. What the fuck?
I got my sample, by the way. The ice cream was amazing, hence the four stars. Don’t order it with marshmallow, it’s not what you think.
Oh and I encourage everyone who reads my review to go in and ask to try every flavor they offer.

Great ice cream and a wonderful assortment of flavors!!! Always a hit in our house and we «cross the bridge» to come AND pay the toll to get back home! Well worth it.
And NOW, they take credit/​debit!

Yum! Love the delish flavors of ice cream! Toasted coconut is my favorite, but I love other flavors as well. The décor is cute and the atmosphere is friendly. Great for those warm Florida nights!!!

Ordered the pistachio in a waffle cone. Was three giant scoops, enough for two.
The only real comparison here locally is Love boat ice cream. At least for this flavor, they nailed it. My girlfriend won’t order it there but we both LOVED it here. Creamy and chocked full of nuts. So glad I swung by to check this new place out!
Interesting to hear the ice cream is made the old fashioned way by the Amish.