The Pub by Wegmans

This was our first time eating here basically because we got an email coupon for $ 10 off 25 so it seemed like a good time to try it out. We made an online reservation for 5:30pm and walked right in. The seating is very open and I didn’t see any booths which I prefer. We could touch the people next to us, as the tables are very close together. Very cramped. Seating gets 1 star. Waitress — Heather was very attentive, quick and friendly. She gave us a happy hour menu which had $ 2, $ 3 and $ 4 appetizers so I decided to have a little appetizer buffet. Mac and Cheese was delicious, super creamy and basically large enough to be a meal in itself. Bavarian Pretzels with dips were also excellent. Lastly I had Chips, Veggies and Onion Dip which was ok — homemade chips were very greasy and I like my onion dip to be a bit stronger on the onion taste — wouldn’t order that again. Three good sized appetizers for $ 10 which I felt was very good. Husband had the Steak, Fries and Root Veggies. He could not stop raving about the steak which was very juicy, tender and had very little fat. Fries were good although seasoned with something we couldn’t identify — perhaps their own house seasoning. We will be back.

We’ll be back– First visit– uninspiring– Second sold us
Ate there twice. First time was at the bar in December 2015. Gyro Turkey Burger was great. Their in house beer (Tail Chaser by Sly Fox was very good– I wish they sold it). Bartender was okay. Not overly responsive and was a bit annoyed when I ask for refills of water and ketchup. Seemed annoyed and not real helpful with question on WiFi access. A bit odd as looked like kitchen manager was going around handing out gift cards to some patrons but not others. I wondered what the rationale was.
Second time– tried it last night with my wife. Lobster night– which we did not do but great price. Server Emily was AWESOME. I asked for a second spoon for my soup to share and the food runner (I wish I got her name) brought out a split serving. «High touch for a pub». We had a coupon that my wife went to show on her phone and Emily said, «don’t worry– no need to show me». Again, a very nice touch

The Pub by Wegmans is an easy spot to hit up before exploring this enormous grocery store. Portions are perfect for a filling lunch and a great way to not end up shopping hungry!
Service was speedy and the staff was friendly and helpful with the wife’s gluten sensitivity. They had a separate menu with a respectable amount of options.
The Lobster Roll was ordered gluten-​free. A somewhat unique item to find, it did not disappoint! Large chunks of sweet claw meat were a happy sight and the gluten-​free roll was better than most. The Lobster Roll and other sandwiches were served with Tuscan Fries which were hand-​cut and well seasoned!
The Gyro Turkey Burger was flavorful but overall, average.
The Thai-​Inspired Chicken Salad was excellent! The familiar Thai peanut flavor was present throughout but did not overpower at all. Portion size was perfect to share or for a lunch salad. Would recommend!
Off the «Snacks and Sharing» portion of the menu we ordered the Chicken Quesadilla. Simple dish done quite well. The lime sour cream was a great addition!

I was disappointed in this place. It’s not a good value & the atmosphere seems cramped. Portions are very small & we left feeling hungry. I would not return to this place.

Prices were fairly high for food of such mediocre quality. We ordered three appetizers. The arugula salad was basic, just arugula and dressing. Nothing else, and the dressing was overpowering. The wedge salad was rather pathetic looking. About ¹⁄₁₂ of a head. The server said it came with tomatoes and cucumber, but it didn’t. Basically iceberg and dressing. The warm pretzel was decent, but the beer cheese was thick and gloppy. I tasted no beer.
My wife did like the French dip, but it seriously needed seasoning. I had the bacon burger. It was way over cooked, despite their menu saying the meat is irradiated to they can cook to order. I was going to complain, but our server took far too long to return for a nearly empty restaurant. The meat was flavorless and the bacon was chewy and stringy. Precooked bacon from Acme is better. Even the bun was unappetizing. The pickle was good, however. The fries were flaccid and very greasy. We got a kids mac-​and-​cheese for the little one, which our server said was so good she eats it herself. Think less flavor than Kraft and those icky fries. He wanted more pickle.
Given Legman’s reputation, this was a decided let down.