Pet Supplies Plus

As far as pet supply stores go, this one really earns their Plus. They’re always well-​staffed by friendly, happy workers. Their shelves are stocked, and they oftentimes have sales and discounts if you join their free membership program.

We buy products for both ends of our cats here.
Give them the food and out it comes into the litter we buy here.
All locations in the area have what our cats like to poop on, and at a great price also.
As long as we have critters in the house we will shop here. Unless it is a squirrel. Then we will go to Farm and Fleet for a live trap.

We have been to every pet supply store in the Milwaukee vicinity and this is the best one by far. They carry everything, kibble to raw food and the store is neat and clean and orderly, all the time. The employees are just super in every way, which is a good way to judge management. This must be a good place to work. We have been to many stores… this is the best.

Piper (our dog) loves shopping at Pet Supplies Plus! When we pull into the parking lot she gets so excited and can’t jump out of the car quick enough :) The staff is always approachable and helpful, knowledgeable about products, and treats your pets like their own.
They have a large variety of brands and carry the higher quality dog foods that you can’t find at the larger chain pet stores. We use Nutri Source and they participate in the frequent buyer program…11^th bag free! They also email you frequent coupons and specials.
The store is large enough with a nice variety of food, treats, crates, clothes, toys, leashes, pet hygiene products, they really have it all. There’s a large private parking lot, and open almost every day making this a super convenient location.
Pet Supplies Plus locations around SE Wisco allow Greyhound Pets of America-​Wisconsin rescue in their doors on most Saturday’s. Check them out!

This is my place to go for my pet supply needs. I prefer to use local products such as Fromm pet food, and they happen to be the very few that carry them. And their aisles are always clean and I’ve yet to see any incorrectly placed items or incorrect price labeling on any of the items that I end up buying there. The employees are very polite and always circulating around and always available to help. Check outs are always quick, efficient, and with an abundance of politeness. Personally, I do think the prices run on par with other pet stores around unless it’s being compared to online prices. But then again, my expenses are often tailored to a singular, nonchalant cat that prefers to lounge around and groom herself instead of chasing a laser dot.

Funny story — the one time my dog ran away, I found her at this store. So per her request, I give it 5 stars. They gave her treats, and were very kind to me when I came in after looking all over for her.
The staff is always so nice and helpful, and they have Fromm food. Many toys, and many made in USA options.

This store has almost anything you would need for your pet but the service is isn’t great. If you don’t know where it is on you own, you probably won’t be buying it.

I have been going here for three years. This place is a little pricier than other pet stores, but I also feed my dogs a particular type of food that they sell here. It seems they have supplies for dogs, cats, fish, rodents, birds, and more.
The people are usually incredibly nice, I have no complaints. They also have a newsletter you can sign up for that will give you coupons for the store as well as sale prices for food.
I’m not one of those «pet food hippies» or «brand communists,» I just know what is healthy for my dogs and they sell it at Pet Supplies Plus. They have specialty food as well as Purina Dog Chow, Puppy chow, Beneficial or whatever.
If you shop wisely, then it shouldn’t be that much more expensive. Buy food here, buy other things at cheaper places. Example: I buy baggies to pick up my dog’s poop at Marshall’s or TJ Maxx. They have really nice thick, quality dog poop bags on the cheap (120 @ 4.99!).

Everything «pet» that you need. Wish they carried more «wild» bird stuff.

My dog eats a brand of food not carried by discount stores so I shop here often. They always have exactly what I need, but I feel a lot of items (especially toys and treats) are overpriced relative to Wal-Mart/Target/Farm&Fleet (or Fleet Farm). However, I generally don’t have time to shop around for pet supplies so this is a decent one-​stop shop. It kind of feels like they can justify the mark up due to the convenience and lack of competition in the area. Personally, I’d rather just spend the extra couple $ on an item than waste time and money on gas driving up to Brown Deer or Menomonee Falls…
The associates are always friendly and helpful, +1 star for excellent customer service. I often go here when I’m crunched for time and just need to pick up dog food, and I have always had a fast and efficient experience at the check-​out.
I do miss the fish and little critters they use to have in the back of the store. I always find enjoyment taking a few moments to stare at the fish before heading back out into the crazy world.

I usually just go here to get the extra large Tubs-​O-​Litter for my two cats who just lounge around and poop all day (get a job you hippies!)
Each time I go here I’m reminded of two things: 1) Seems like many of their products are overpriced compared to other pet supply stores, and 2) They can get away with it because many of the patrons here are pants-​on-​head crazy.
Seriously, they’re everywhere. If you need to go in just don’t make eye contact until you get up to the register. Otherwise you’ll be greeted with, «My doggy/​fishy/​kitty-​cat is the best and he only eats this special food hurrrrrrrr!»
Maybe its just when I go there, which is usually Saturday afternoon.
The store’s lighting is a bit drab and they love to move merchandise around a lot. The employees are friendly though and they will help you out with your questions — and believe me, you will hear some doozies while waiting in line to check out. As stated before, there are other pet stores that have better prices, but around this area this is the only one you’ll find.

I shop at a different location but the staff is just as knowledgable and very helpful. They preorder my cases of food, I have one allergic cat who can’t have grain or chicken or any kind of fowl, so being able to order what she needs is great. Since we can’t have food wars, all the cats eat the same food, so it’s nice to be able to order enough to cover a month of feeding. Supermarket pet foods are usually loaded with grain and fillers, and dogs and cats are true carnivores and need MEAT, not vegetables. When have you seen a cat go pull up a carrot???

What a delight to find this shop near our Trader Joe’s bi-​weekly wine stop! Our allergy-​riddled dog has been eating Nature’s Variety Instinct dog food, which mostly we can only find at Petco, until we found this store.
The store was clean and the staff was very helpful, and the food was on special the day we were in just for signing up for their shoppers card. If you are a member, they will send you a coupon for a free toy for your pet’s birthday.
We will be back!

My impression was from the outside how could this place have a decent selection of pet foods, but once inside they have more than petsmart or petco. Friendly service, decent prices. They’re selection is enormous.

Awesome customer service. You will not find employee’s like this at Petsmart. The employees that work here *really* have knowledge on pet food. Our dog was so itchy and we couldn’t figure out why and the vet suggested switching foods. If you have an animal, you know how frustrating it is to read all the labels and make sure it is 1.) something that your pet should be eating 2.) something you pet will like. The more you switch foods, the harder it is on their digestive systems. Even if you do it slow, it is still a pain in the neck to go through all the hassle of reading tons of labels.
Anyway, the girl that helped me really knew her stuff and educated me on food (I am embarrassed to say I was feeding my dog Science Diet before I got educated on food… no judgment if that is what you are feeding your animal but mine was having problems). It was suggested she go on a grain-​free, chicken free based diet… I was already thinking cha-​ching cha-ching…but the girl that helped was really good at finding something in my price range with a frequent buyer program!
I also have my cats on Fromm now, which is a local company located in Mequon. They are doing really well on that food now too!
I am so happy I live so close to this store!

Thank goodness for this store! It’s so nice to have alternatives to the cat food offered at grocery stores. My guys do extremely well with «Chicken Soup for the Cat Lover’s Soul» food (what a name, right?), and this is the only store I’ve been able to find it at. They also have any type of pet accessory you could want. The staff there are usually friendly and helpful.

I have decided that I like this store. Great selection of pet supplies and friendly and attentive staff. They even have the frozen blood worms needed to feed my stingray!
1 star deduction because of the crappy parking lot and the fact that the frozen bloodworms share a fridge with frozen mice and other nasties.
**Bought a dog toy that my pup ripped to shreds within a half hour… PSP said they would refund the money or put it towards the cost of something else for me… nice!