Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

SLOW service. It shouldn’t take over twenty minutes to get one slice of cheese pizza. I have been in lunch, middle of the afternoon, and for dinner and it’s always extremely SLOW. One random night they quoted me 40 mins for two slices of pizza. That is absolutely ridiculous. Nice people but they need to speed things up. I no longer go here because the service is just awful.

Update: Typical response from this same responder (Peter) on here… So sorry etc etc. Asked for my phone number and I responded I will talk to the owners when they get in touch and NOT somebody replying on Unilocal… That was 5÷11÷2016 and still waiting… Just goes to show how the owners couldn’t care less nor did they refund my money… I would not go here again just for the fact that the owners could not even take the time to respond nor do they even have the courtesy of an email. Pitiful service and average food.

This pizza was righteous! I have 0 complaints. Pizza lovers unite!

I love this pizza. Truly delicious New York style pizza (I grew up in NYC). The only thing I’m not crazy about is that they put toppings under the cheese, that’s not really my thing. The staff seems young but they are kind and provide good service.

Have ordered from the restaurant four times over 2 years and the service is always slow. Waited almost an hour for a large pizza on a Monday night with the place less than half full. It’s an average tasting pizza, so I’m not going back anymore.

Terrible service, my wife and I came in on a Sunday ordered a pizza and a chicken parm sandwich. We paid, and sat down. The girl came out and told us they were out of chicken and offered us a meatball sub and we agreed. Came out a second time and told us they didn’t have any meatballs but they had chicken wings, so we just agreed to get it at this point. When the food came out, the pizza was wrong. We got nothing we paid for. As we left, the waitress asked us how everything was. We explained to her our pizza was then wrong. She took our number and offered us a free any size pizza the next time we call. Today we called trying to order a pizza and they didn’t have my name or number in their system. The lady at the counter explained to me since they didn’t have my name or number they couldn’t do anything about it. I would never give my business to Anthony’s ever again. The service is aweful and the last time we were there the employees were drinking beer in the back. Horrible.

I’m a long-​time resident of Golden and have had Anthony’s pizza many, many times. Great crust and sauce, and I’ve always had good service. Delivery can be a bit of a wait but that is because they are really busy. Recently I’ve ordered calzones and the first was very tasty with the consistently good crust and sauce, and it had ricotta cheese and a decent amount of toppings. My last two can only be described, as Patton Oswalt would say, cheese bombs. So much mozzarella that it bordered on disgusting. No trace of ricotta — maybe it was absorbed by the cheese goo — with a really scrooge-​like amount of toppings. I’ll continue to be a customer, but will stick to the pizza.

Good pizza, terrible service. We ordered mozz sticks, two slices, and garlic bread at the counter and paid. Mozz sticks took 25 minutes, slices and garlic bread took 35 minutes. This is definitely the longest I have ever waited for pizza at a counter restaurant. They were not at all apologetic and were actually quite rude. They also screwed up the order of the people next to us, took their pizza back, and it appears they just took off the toppings they didn’t want and brought it back…
I won’t eat here again — even though the food is quite good — not worth it.

Perfect crust seekers, go no further! I thought I would never get as close to my favorite pizza joint in Manhattan and… here it is! Anthony’s is great, red or white, and has an array of fresh topping choices!

We had called and placed an order. The delivery time was an hour and a half so we decided to pick it up, the girl on the phone said it would still be 45 minutes. When we walked in 45 minutes later there were multiple employees standing around just hanging out. When I told her my name she said it to the back and they grabbed our ticket and just then started making it. Great pizza but was disappointed that they were to busy flirting and goofing off to make our pizza.

Nice little pizza joint to watch a game or grab a quick slice. They have good, thin New York style pizza and they sell by the slice which is great. Really fairly priced specials and friendly staff. I would come back.

Amazing pizza, spaghetti and garlic bread. The crust is cooked perfectly and the pizzas are huge (one pie could easily feed 6 – 8 people).

How can it be acceptable to take more than 1 hour to serve a pizza? Just completely unacceptable. No apologies, no comp, nothing. And everyone in the restaurant waiting just as long as well. I would never recommend eating here.

I can’t believe I’ve lived in Golden for 5 years and haven’t reviewed this place! This is a pizza known for good New York style pizzas. It’s $ 2.50 a slice and you add on by however many toppings you want. While they don’t have anything super crazy, they have a ton of options. I’m not big on bread, so I looove the thin slice pizzas. The slices are HUGE. They also have a thick slice option… one slice is a meal. Just trust me.
They also do catering and deliver (including next door at barrels and bottles!).

Absolute worst service ever! They were disrespectful, rude, took forever and made us feel like their laziness was our fault. They even said F’U! I felt so sorry for the actual owner that he/​she would have hired such terrible employees. I would NEVER go there again. The sad thing is we are GOLDEN locals. My recommendation is to go to Woodys Pizza, they r great!
No Anthonys because the r too worried about their friends and hanging out. I feel so bad for the owners!!!

We arrived and ordered our pizza and garlic bread and quoted 30 minutes for our wait time. It was an hour and our pizza and bread came out. The guy that came out threw the bread plate on the table and the bread fell off. I told the guy that he need to make more bread and he stood up and flipped me off, and walked away. I go the manager and he said he would write him up and would refund my pizza. Prior to all of this there were about 10 people that were refunded their money due to attitude and their food not being ready. The front personnel were extremely rude and told us to move out of the way when we were talking to the manager. I would not go to this location. After this, we went to the Arvada location and it was excellent service and food!

We waited 35 minutes for a slice of pizza. Everyone in the restaurant already had pizza so no one else was ahead of us. When my friend asked her if our slice was coming up she said five more minutes and was rude. Ten minutes later, no pizza and I now ask where it is and they said «we are working on it.» Then the people who arrived literally 30 minutes after us get their FOUR slices of pizza out. Now they are saying they are coming out orders… I will be sure to check my bank statement. Two minutes later our pizza is out. I loved this place when I lived here a few years ago. Now I’m not so sure.

So, after a mess-​up, Anthony’s Pizza came through three food for me and the people I was providing good to. A super awesome shout out to the Golden Colorado location and John Le Bel the president of the company. Thank you very much for making things right and taking care of the situation in the manner you did.

As a former new yorker, I was happy that this local chain popped up. Great place to get ny style pizza. It is always best to order a whole pie if you have enough people but they have some deals on a slice with a salad and drink. When the weather is good eat here and head up the street to listen to live music at the Buffalo rose outside in the afternoon and evening.

Your typical cheap pizza. They do deliver next-​door to Barrels & Bottles, which does not have a full kitchen, so if you need a little pizza to go with your beer, I definitely recommend this place for convenience. The nice thing is that it’s a thin crust, so it won’t compete for space in your belly when you’re drinking beer.
They’re also good for a quick, cheap lunch.