Glass Nickel Pizza

Above average food, friendly staff. The specialty pizzas are good and their pasta dishes are well made also. The only reason I don’t give it a 5 star is because price wise it is on the higher end.

They have really gone down hill after the move. Food quality and management issues are happening. I question the cleanliness of the place and the attention to maintaining quality. I have had a lot of items taste like fish on the weekends. Someone is not changing oil after fish fry night. Basic stuff, fix it.

Had a great time there, food was very good. There beer selection is good. Service was very good, I will be going back for sure!

Our family’s favorite pizza by far! I love the sacre bleu pizza with walnuts. It is amazing. We frequently order it for friends, and many have been surprised how much they loved it! We usually order delivery, and it is comes pretty quickly.

The chicky chicky parm parm is blowing my effing mind. This will be my go to Packers pizza place anytime I’m in town for a game. There are so many more pies I want to try.

I was able to convince my in-​laws to go here while my wife and I were in town visiting them. I anticipated my mother-​in-​law having multiple negative things to say about the place because of it isn’t her cooking, it isn’t good. Believe it or not, she actually said the pizza was better than the place she normally goes (and where I talked her out of tonight). Originally this was a recommendation from a friend in the Madison area who knows the owner. My family comes up to GB twice a year and I hope to stop by at least once a year for as long as they’re still serving up delicious pizza.

Great pizza, service not so much. We arrived to find the place fairly busy on a Friday night. We asked to be seated and were told to sit anywhere. After a few minutes of being seated we were greeted by our waitress and ordered drinks. A couple at another table who had been sitting there when we arrived, waved our waitress down and asked for drinks. I don’t know what happened there, but she took their drink order. We got our drinks and ordered our food. I ordered the deluxe pizza on hand tossed crust.
My pizza arrived about 30 minutes later. It was fantastic. One of the better pizzas I’ve had in a while. I also ordered another drink. We didn’t see the waitress until I was finished with my meal. She brought the drink and apologized that they had forgotten about it.
The price was reasonable, the pizza as I said was great, however the service needs improvement.

First of all, they forgot our onion rings on our order and had to go back to get them. We got delivery and the pizza got here in normal delivery time, but it was cold when we got it.
The pizza was cold and not good at all, not enough sauce, but if they put more sauce it would just taste worse because the sauce wasn’t good. The cheese was nice and gooey, but it didn’t taste good and there wasn’t enough. The crust was normal pizza crust, not good but not bad either, kinda tasted like papa’s.
The onion rings were ok, but they forgot them at first and had to come back hahaha.
Also, we got a black friday discount, which was 10 for a large, but I still think it was overpriced, they should price at at 7 or 8 for a large and that quality.
Overall, I give it an Eek! Methinks Not. Better than Lil Caesars but worse than frozen. peace\\

We waited for over an hour for cold pizza. Definitely, not coming back. Don’t waste your time or money.

Great people, great food. Between pasta, sandwiches, and pizza, everything is done well. Do it. You won’t regret it.

Boom! The flavor was like a pleasant punch to your taste buds. We had the Pollo Diablo, and if you like spicy, you are going to love it. Don’t stop there! Enjoy any of the delicious craft beer. If you don’t know what you like, then the friendly wait staff will lead you in the right direction.

We ordered a cheese and sausage to be delivered to our hotel while staying in Green Bay. They deliver to the Hyatt, in case you’re wondering. The front desk didn’t mention this place when I asked who delivers. Apparently, Green Bay shuts down at 10:00pm, so it was kind of a last resort for us. The large pizza was under $ 20 and reasonably good. The front desk called our room when it arrived and I came down for it. Considering the options in the area after 10:00, I would say this is a pretty decent one.

Far and away this pizza blew ALL my local, Louisville, KY places out of the water! First let me just tell ya, I am extremely finicky when it comes to my pizza. No lie. The crust has to be just chewy enough to please the kids but NEVER doughy or sloppy wet from sauce or overly greasy, soggy/​runny cheese… There’s a popular Papa somebody’s pizza that originates in Louisville that exemplifies this abhorrent quality (which I despise) but all other red-​blooded Americans seem to just blindly devour. As apparent with his joints popping up on nearly every corner in Louisville and across the Southern states. However, I digress…
From the first bite to the last, the Glass Nickel’s pie hands down was one of the best (traditional hand-​tossed crust) that i have ever eaten. And that’s just their crust! The sauce was the perfect blend of seasonings and spices as well and not at all too heavy or too sparsely applied.
On to the CHEESE. Wow, just wow! Perfection. Every. Last. Bite.
For me, the cheese has GOT to be the stringy, ooey, gooey mozzarella-​y delectable goodness of the almighty pizza cheese Gods… or I’m out. No strings = no bite, no foul. Their pizza had it all. Amazing Crust + Awesome Sauce + Cheesey Perfection = Pizza Heaven! Ya’ll this pizza may well go down as one of, if not my ALL TIME favorites. Did I mention this was delivery?! We’re passing through Green Bay and at a hotel x2 days so I was VERY skeptical ’bout pizza delivery and immensely delighted and impressed with their speedy service and great food!
*My 11 and almost 7 year old also raved about this pizza, which never EVER happens! To them, pizza is a pizza is a pizza… until now.*

Great food, great service. Bartender was super friendly and knew her products. A breath of fresh air after attempting to get in to the boutique pizza places down the street and told the wait would be an hour.

That was the worst service I’ve ever received. I will never return. Took 40 minutes before our waitress even took our order and they were everything but busy!

This place was a total disaster. I was visiting from Los Angeles and this place took 45 minutes just to get my salad on the table. No one else was in the place. Ridiculous. Horrible service, mediocre food, really upsetting.

Delivery is always hot, fast and delicious! They have creative combinations for their specialty pizzas and they are all amazing! Tried their jalapeño cucumber lemonade at the farmers market and it was out of this world!

I have only ate at the resturant one time but order pizza from here all the time. The pizza is expensive I will say that. It is good though and they offer pizza toppings that no other pizza joints offer (thai pizza).
I would recommend you order from them if you want something different than your normal cheese pizza.

My husband and I are from Los Angeles California. We came across Glass Nickelby searching places.
First off it was slow and the gentleman said to take a seat wherever we’d like.
Service was fast and prompt. She didn’t introduce herself so I don’t know her name.
The cheese curds were fabulous and absolutely amazing!
Husband ordered a calzone with sausage and pepperoni
Their sausage is so awesome!
I ordered the Smothered Chicken and I asked for white onion instead a red
We got our food in a decent time frame but I was disappointed with my sandwich. I received it with red onions and it had no side. When I asked my server about the side she said it didn’t come with any. So then I asked for a side of the chips as on the picture with flavor jalapeño, she then brings a bag of chips, like from the store. She did apologize for the confusion and what the picture showed.
This is probably the only reason I give this a 4 stars.
It would’ve been excellent if the menu was more clear especially with a side of a sandwich. In addition I really dislike red onions I didn’t send it back because I was hungry and I didn’t want their kitchen to go through the hassle of making it again so I just took the onions out.
Overall, we definitely go again now making sure that we ask the questions even if it seems obvious.
Great place, great food. Next time we will order pizza!

My Husband and I had a coupon for this place and boy am I glad we went. I think it was last week Wednesday night and there was just a few other couples in the place. The guy behind the bar was nice and just told us to grab any table we wanted, so we took a booth in the bar area. There was just one girl working the tables and then the bartender, they both seemed nice, they were joking around with each other and with the people they knew. The place was clean and she came right over to get our drink order, we were able to get an appetizer, two beers and a specialty pizza with our coupon, so for the appetizer we got the fried Mac and cheese, I don’t recommend this to anyone all it was was Kraft Mac and cheese, I know that flavor anywhere, on the up side it was fried to perfection and it came out quick, we weren’t even done with those and our pizza came out, we ordered the Ranch it had chicken, tomatoes and bacon on it. It was probably one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time.
Our waitress was really nice and the guy behind the bar seemed like he was nice, I would definitely recommend this place for pizza the tables are cool too, each has a different design with nickels.
We will definitely be going back to get more pizza, I’ve already got another coupon for the same deal, but this time we are not getting the same appetizer…
P

It isn’t often I give a low rating, but this has to be one of the well-​earned ones.
We went for pizza, heard it was so good. But were we ever disappointed.
Wasn’t overly busy for a Friday night, yet, pizza was a bit slow to arrive.
Though, I must say, our server was very nice!
The pizza had no flavor, nothing that made you go WOW.
The crust was soggy, so much so that I actually thought they added mashed potatoes to our bacon cheeseburger pizza.
The sauce was bland to say the least.
Unfortunately, I don’t think we will be back again.

This rating is based on the sacre bleu pizza! It is my favorite pizza ever. We try to find a reason to order one of these once a week or so. Walnuts, Canadian bacon, diced tomatoes, and bleu cheese… It is fantastic! We have ordered it for lots of friends and they were surprised how much they liked it.

Driving through Wisconsin after a wedding and not having any real plan of where to go or what to do, I decide to find a place that will cure my hunger, hungover, and expectations of great cheese and beer. What better stop than a pizza joint?
I went here on a Saturday afternoon, like one o’clock and as you might expect, no one is in a pizza place at one (why are they even open??), but they were the perfect place for my needs and cravings. The boy and I were greeted a little slowly, but that didn’t matter since I love checking out the speciality pizzas, or menus in general. The décor is cute, but very sports bar like, with actual nickels under the tables.
First thing that caught our eye, the flight of 4 beers for $ 4 on Saturdays. I mean, was it some secret happy hour awesomeness that randomly appeared at our appearing in Wisconsin? Probably not, but it was awesome, and naturally we ordered 8 of the 10 beers, all from Wisconsin and many that were brewed right down the street. (We had tried the other 2 at some point in the past).
The menu was a ‘normal’ pizza place, and I only mean that in the sense it had breadsticks, salad, pasta, and pizza. The ingredients were fun and some interesting combinations arose. That aside, the food was great! We ordered a mountain of food, so I should know, we started with the Spinach cheese bread, which was basically a mini pizza itself, super cheesy, with the perfect amount of grease. After that was devoured our Acropolis salad (kind of like a greek salad but with more veggies) came (you know to cleanse the palate between beers and cheese!), which was huge and perfect, very fresh veggies. Finally, the pizza, we decided to get their speciality which was the Fetalicious, and it was amazing! The crust was chewy and crunchy and just thick enough as not to overpower the toppings.
This definitely put the boy and I in better spirits to continue on our Wisconsin journey. I usually don’t go for chains, though this is only a Wisconsin chain, so I’ll most likely visit it again if ever in the area!