Probably the worst pizza I have had in a long time. Little to now sauce. Absolutely no flavor. The wings were soggy. All food items were delivered cold. Very poor experience.
Christopher G.
Rating des Ortes: 5 Orient, OH
Really good pie! They make their pie two ways… traditional(toppings covered by the cheese) and cook that cheese to a golden brown(perfect!) and a pie called the«Topper», where the pep is on top of the cheese, and when baked the edges curl up, get toasty, and form this little pool of grease in each one, outstanding! This is not traditional Midwest pie like Tommy’s or Rotolo’s, but Im giving an extra star specifically for the Topper. I have never had pie like that in C’bus. Once you go «Topper» you wont go «backer»! ;)
Matthew G.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Columbus, OH
The cleanliness of the place isn’t getting better(a number of bugs and small flies in the dining room on my last visit), and some of the staff seems a little hostile. For a lunch buffet, I’d recommend skipping Joseppi’s and going to Massey’s instead, until Joseppi’s get their act together. Edit: the bugs may be coming from the neighboring business, I didn’t mean to imply that the kitchen isn’t clean, but the dining room isn’t exactly a picture of beauty. I really do like the pizza here, it’s very tasty, and I like that they carry Coke products. It’s just that past experiences make it harder to convince my companions to come back.
Brady S.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Columbus, OH
The mascot crept me out at 10 years old and it creeps me out at 24. Pizza was horrible when I was a kid, or so I remember, but it seems to have improved in flavor and texture. Not a location I’d readily frequent but if someone else is paying, I’m not gonna say no.
Liza V.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Columbus, OH
Plain and simple, this is delicious pizza for a decent price. And, the staff is so smiley and helpful. The crust is nice and thin, but not crispy, which can satisfy most tastes. The meat is under the cheese– I usually like my pep nice and crispy on top, but this method works for Joseppi’s. The wings are super saucy and spicy. Garlic bread is freakin delish, and the spaghetti sauce or pizza sauce(you choose) is great for dippin’. They don’t deliver to us, but we make the drive. It’s worth it.
Casey S.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Columbus, OH
Overall a mediocre pizza. Being from Delaware, Ohio and recently moving to the area, I was after pizza that was new to me. It was my first time trying this creation and I don’t see myself eating it again unless I’m intoxicated and starving. When my pizza was first delivered I questioned whether or not it even had pepperoni. Little did I know they put the cheese over the pepperonis(that’s different). However when the sauce has such a lack of flavor or spice and the cheese is rubbery it’s difficult to even notice the slivers of meat between. My crust was also overcooked and I ended up throwing it to my dogs(which they greatly appreciated). In conclusion I will keep my pizza hunt active and keep trying others in the area.
Seth D.
Rating des Ortes: 4 Columbus, OH
Not too much to say about this location that I didn’t already say in my review of the Broad Street location. Great pizza, decent salads and breadsticks. Salami on the toppings menu=they know what’s up! Their lunch buffet is pretty good, or better than any other I’ve had anyways. Not in quantity, but in quality. It’s usually just a few pizzas, but they’re good, and they take requests. It’s not a full service restaurant, more like you order at the counter, go sit down and they bring the food out to you. Definately a great place for Mid-Western style pizza!
R S.
Rating des Ortes: 3 Columbus, OH
Bummer! Nothing special or tasty about this pizza. Most forgettable. Like pizza from Anytown USA. I’ll keep looking around Grove City for a go-to pizza joint. They need flavor in the ketchupy sauce, generous toppings, higher quality cheese. Delivery dude took cell call in middle of paying him and stayed on it while I waited in him at least 3 – 4 minutes, not good service, I eventually shut the door on him.