Brothers Pizza On Rt. 33

Right next door to my job Route 33 Nissan.
Love the white and plain cheese slices and cheesesteaks the best. Fast and friendly staff they are truly deserving of 5 star rating

Wasn’t crazy about there pizza — way to much cheese. I’ve heard great things about them, so I wanted to try it out — wasn’t to crazy about it. Place Is in a great location though.

I live in the area and tonight was the first time I’ve eaten there… It was awesome! The food was excellent, and the service was exceptional. They have a great eating area out back where you can eat outside. So good.

I have been to Brother’s Pizza in the past however it has been some time since I had been there. At the suggestion if another couple we decided to go there for pizza. The main reason was because of the new outside patio which the restaurant had constructed. The new outside area holds about 10 – 15 tables so people are not on top of each other. Once the sun went down the area was nice and cool with strings of small lights strung under the trellis ceiling.
We ordered a large salad and some fried zucchini sticks. The salad was fresh and easily fed two people with a third person taking some as well. The zucchini sticks were nothing special.
The ladies ordered a veggie pizza which was thick with vegetables. My friend ordered a large pizza with anchovies. I assume it’s good because he knew what he was ordering without looking at the menu.
I ordered a personal sized white pizza with ricotta cheese, prosciutto and arugula. It was the perfect size for me. The crust was thin and crisp and quite to my liking. Next time i will ask them to cook the prosciutto which was added to the pie along with arugula at the time of service.
Our waitress, Gabriella, was warm and friendly. I will definitely return here for another night on the patio.

This place is awesome! Everything I’ve eaten here has been great. Service is ALWAYS top notch. Food is delicious, especially the tomato pie

Id probably have to say that it’s the best pizza place around town! In the summer time you can sit outside in the summer time. What a beautiful scenery. Their staff is great to talk to. Their pizza is good. I’d never had a complaint with this place. Great food. Highly recommended.

Was in the area and stopped into grab a quick bite. I was expecting just another pizzeria experience. I was very surprised, the place was buzzing with activity. It seemed like they have a lot of regular repeat customers. The food was great and the service too. They were very friendly and made me feel like one of the regulars.
I definitely will be back when I am in the area.

i came here the salad tasted like it wasnt washed. then i asked the server about the lunch menu and she told me that the pasta’s are a cheaper price on lunch menu, so i got ravioli. on the bill they charged me the regular dish price. the server should have notified me, when i asked the server she said actually that wasnt a part of lunch menu so why didnt you come tell me. every pizzeria has cheese ravioli on their lunch menu. and then the server expected us to pay full price for her mistake anyway she goes to the back to talk to her manager to see what she can do now and by now we have been waiting 10 mins for this issue to be resolved instead of wasting anymore time we just paid in full what we owed and left.

I have been coming to brothers pizza for 15 years and the food and service were always top notch, Things have changed. Our last few visits, the service was not so great and the food was not the same. The prices have gone up and the accommodations have not improved. Why charge $ 17 for a chicken Parmesan for me to sit on a bench seat. I don’t understand that at all. My family grew up in this place and I’m happy to have dined there in the past but, now, it’s not the same.

Seriously great pizza. Family owned and well made. No complaints, every time I’m in Hamilton and need pizza this is my go to spot. Love them!

Still the best pizza in Hamilton. Great sandwiches and pasta dishes as well. Very reasonable prices. Service is always top notch. Just wish they would finally deliver.

If I could give zero stars I would. We live in the best area for pizza and tomato pies. Why go here with mediocre pizza. Not all toppings are fresh. Had to take a pie back one time, really bad.

Love the pizza. Crispy crust. Great sauce. I refuse to eat pizza anywhere else. They are open late :)

In terms of pizza, they have the best in the area, hands down. They have a nice pasta selection, as well. They’re open late which is nice if you just want to grab a quick bite to eat when most of the other restaurants on 33 have locked their doors. The staff is friendly and the service is casual enough to be inviting without coming off as lazy. The owners and their children are usually present behind the counter appreciatively interacting with both their staff and customers.

Best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had. Pizza has a crisp crust and the pepperoni is to die for. A must try!

Went back last night for the first time in over 3 months. The place was filled with smoke, smelled like something burning in the oven. Ordered a pizza and guess what, tasted like smoke. Really liked it better when the two original brothers ran the place and made the pizza. Also noticed the place was half empty, use to never see that on a Friday night.

With so many pizza parlors in the Hamilton area, it is sometimes difficult to distinguish them from each other. Yes, there are the superstars like DeLo’s, JoJo’s, and even Ivy Tavern and Pete’s Steakhouse Bar Pies, but after them there is a muddle of decent to very good tomato pie joints that are somewhat interchangeable.
So, what makes Brothers Pizza On Rt 33 (Yes. That’s their name.) so special? First, they have been twirling pie dough for a couple of generations at the same location. Second, the space is larger than many pie shops. This one has plenty of room. Third, the staff will go out of their way to be sure you are satisfied. Forth, the pizza is much better than average.
When I went in for a late lunch last week to grab the traditional two slices and a drink, they were out of the regular pie. No sweat! They called the pizza chef over and asked him to build a new pie for my lunch. He did so without a blink, and about 10 minutes later 2 steaming slices of cheesy pizza lay before me. It was firm with nice scorch marks underneath. The cheese was still bubbling, and I actually had to wait a couple of minutes to avoid burning my palate. The point of each slice held firm and the first bite was met with a sound crunch. Just the way I like it. The sauce was mildly sweet to counter the light saltiness of the cheese.
There can be no doubt that fresh from the oven pizza is normally far superior to the warmed over pieces that get tossed in the oven for a couple of minutes to warm it up. Those guys are never hot enough and have lost part of their tastiness. So, getting lunch from a new pie was a real treat.
And, I will not forget that they made that pie just so I could have a good lunch in their house.

Mamma Mia — that’s a delicious pizza! I’ve been a student of pizza for many years. In fact, relatives have owned and operated a pizza business on the NJ boardwalk for many years before they sold out about 10 years ago. I know what good, and bad, pizza is.
Brothers, a staple in Hamilton for over 30 years, serves up a delicious real Italian pizza. The pie is baked so that, if you add toppings, it’s not sloppy and wet like pizza that are made at the other so-​called pizza shops in the area. There’s a big difference in tast, quality and build.
I’ve have enjoyed many pizzas, and Italian dishes, from Brothers over the years, and never left hungry or dissatisfied with the food or the service. When in the Hamilton Township area during lunch or dinner, make it a point to stop in to Brothers Pizza for a good meal.
–Andrew

The red sauce is far too sweet, but the white pizzas are great. The cheesesteak slice was especially addictive.

Went here after trying to go to the original Trenton pie place down the road, you know the place. We wanted red pie and got it here. No complaints, it did the trick!

There were a few things I liked about Brothers Pizza on Rt. 33. But there were a few significant gripes, too.
First the gripes. A regular Unilocal user, I shopped around for local deals and found a coupon for 15% off the total order. Sounded good! So my friend and I forwent Uno’s and headed to Brothers – and were pleasantly surprised to see that the cover of the menu was a wine list with a very good assortment! But then the bad began.
The waitress, who was cordial, had never heard of Unilocal and said she had to consult the manager. He said the coupon would not be offered as it had expired; however, he would honor it if we were paying cash. All I had was my debit card. 2) The wine (and beer) was not really there in the restaurant but had to be purchased in the bar next door which was owned by the same man. Compounding this issue, it was pouring rain. Nevertheless, my friend and I ordered a pizza and went out to fetch a nice pinot. We came back $ 20 poorer and soaking wet. (The bar next door, by the way, was hopping and looked like loads of fun.)
The waitress did not know how to open the bottle, so she asked a cook for assistance, who also did not know how to pop a cork. We stopped him before he could mangle things too badly and corked it ourselves. Then, thank goodness, things changed for the better.
We ordered a medium eggplant pizza. It was absolutely fantastic, and the medium here was the size of a large most places. The crust was just right: new york style, perfectly baked. There was just the right amount of sauce, and the cheese was extremely fresh and oh so gooey. My friend and I proceeded to have a very good meal at a reasonable price. Now that we know the routine, we will very likely return again. (It sure beat the heck out of Uno’s.)
Suggestion: bring your own bottle; be prepared for a louder, younger crowd; and if you are going to be eating for two bring upward of $ 30. Not a bargain, but not a total rip either. But if you are planning on using the Unilocal coupon: forget about it. Shame on Unilocal for allowing them to tease us so. When a coupon expires: pull it!
Now, grab a date. See a movie. And after, treat yourself to the best pie I’ve yet found in the Trenton area. They are open late, and the service, while a bit amateur, is nice.