Nicey Treat

Super friendly bunch with fantastic combos. Coconut is the family fav. Also keep the sticks for free pops!

Great staff. Great popsicles. If they ask if you want your PB pop dipped in chocolate, DO IT! Incredible.

Nicey Treat is now my favorite place for a frozen indulgence. The tiny store front with the bright blue awning is an excellent addition to the fountain square neighborhood. There are vegan options which include fresh twists on traditional fruit Popsicle flavors such as strawberry mint, orange, mojito, etc. There are also creamy options which include dark chocolate sea salt, banana cream, coconut cream, etc. What takes these pops to an even higher level of deliciousness is the chocolate dip option where the pops are dipped in chocolate (complimentary!). I highly recommend stopping at this frozen pop paradise– you won’t regret it!

This has become an every Saturday tradition. Hot chocolate and banana cream pops. It’s like a Popsicle drive-​in for your bicyclers. Highly recommended.

If you like spicey, DON’T go to Nicey! But if you want a treat, Nicey can’t be beat :) I’ll definitely be going back!!! My popsicle was banana cream, and I felt like I was in a dream :0

We got Popsicle here EVERYDAY while my daughter was teething! This place is great! Everyone is so nice and the pops are so delicious!

Oh, Nicey. You shouldn’t have. We’re so flattered that you decided to open your second location in our neighborhood. We now have a popsicle piggy bank…
Top 5 reasons you should stop what your doing and visit this mini business in Fletcher Place:
1.) Jazz, the popmeister/​Nicey staff, is incredibly friendly. You’ll want to be his friend.
2.) Blueberry buttermilk, pumpkin spice, toasted coconut, dark chocolate sea salt — just a few of the incredible flavors that will have you pulling out all your three dollar bills…
3.) It’s conveniently located along the Cultural Trail — guilt free eats — just keep walking/​running/​biking after your pit stop
4.) save 10 popsicle sticks and redeem your free pop
5.) The chocolate dipping machine is coming soon. «Yes, I’d like that dipped in dark chocolate. How’d you know?»

Nicey Treat just turned what was only a once-​in-​a-​while indulgence of mine into an all too accessible location that is smack dab on a part of the Cultural Trail that I frequent.
This new shop is located on the Cultural Trail in the quickly growing Fletcher Place neighborhood, amidst a handful of other fantastic newer businesses. It isn’t really so much a store, as a window to order your pops to-​go. As of them just opening the doors, it didn’t seem like they really have any designated area to sit and enjoy your treat, but fortunately they are easy to eat on the fly. This would be a fairly easy place to walk past without even realizing it is there, but the bright blue awning over the door is the indicator that you are at the right place. They don’t have their hours for this location listed on the website yet, but I’m fairly certain that they said their hours were 4 – 9, although that was just after opening shop so they might change depending on when they get their demand figured out.
While they 12−15ish flavor options aren’t quite as plentiful as their location in Broad Ripple, they do have a wide range of options that cover all of the bases. From decadent, to fruity, to unique (sweet corn, thai coffee, avocado), they have something for everybody, and you know that if it is from Nicey it is definitely going to be fresh and delicious.
Their product stands as a must-​have on its own, but this is yet another great Indy business that has put together a superbly helpful and friendly staff that certainly compliments the top-​notch offerings. There is always a smile on the persons face behind the counter, and they always have a ton of patience while they wait on me to finally narrow my choices down to just one frozen treat (not an easy task).
Their $ 3 price tag for a popsicle is towards the top end of what I would be willing to pay for one of these, but they do have a rewards system that involves collecting 10 of the sticks from your previous pops and cashing them in for a freebie, so hold onto your trash.
I am especially looking forward to having this location open when summer rolls around next year, and hopefully this new popsicle hub also helps them get their products into some of other great local businesses in the area.

Whether you’re boppin’ around the Monon Trail in Broad Ripple or the Cultural Trail in Fletcher Place, Nicey Treat is there for you. Having the second location means more opportunities for THE BEST treats on a stick around, but you better go now before they close up shop for the season.’
(Also: if there’s still sweet corn or PB&J on the menu, snatch it up.)

The only thing that could make Nicey Treat any better would be if you were to move it closer to your house. This location is right in my neighborhood, so I guess they’ve done it. It can’t get any better.
Oh, but wait. Yes it does. The pop peddler Jazz behind the counter is super cool.
Thank you, Nicey Treat for coming to Flethcher Place!

Beyond excited to have a Nicey Treat location downtown! This is by far my favorite place for a post (or pre!) dinner treat. Two of my personal faves are toasted coconut (dipped in dark chocolate) and passion fruit — but I usually get something new every time I go, and I know I’m not going to be disappointed. Best part: the staff is wonderful and never fails to have a smile on their faces. Special shout-​out to Lauren Brown for being extra delightful!

Right on the Cultural Trail, with a bright blue awning, Nicey Treat is a solid addition to the Fletcher Place scene. My favorites are Pineapple Basic and Sweet Corn. The best popsicles in Indy (maybe even the world?). For $ 3 each, you can’t pass up Nicey Treat
Plus, if you save 10 popsicle sticks, you can exchange them for a free popsicle.

I saw the bright blue awning this morning, and did a double take. Did that read «Nicey Treat?!» You-​bet-​your-​bottom-​dollar it did! So, naturally I turned around and rolled my bike up to the «drive thru window» and placed my order.
5 reasons why Nicey Treat rocks:
1. Try and way a popsicle and not smile. Seriously, I dare ya.
2. They offer both fruity and creamy flavors
3. There is no «bad choice» they are all delicious.
4. Their staff always serve you your popsicle with a huge smile– therefore making 1. Impossible.
5. Save 10 popsicle sticks –get 1 free!