Stacked Pickle

Was good.
The waiter was the best we had in a long time. Food was good. We will go back.

This review is for the SR37 location.
The complete lack of energy extends from the front of house to the back. Bland would be a compliment.
I really wanted this location to be a success but management is ensuring that won’t happen.

Nothing to write home about. Typical fried foods. Just ok. I’d come back for happy hour drinks though.
The service was really good though

Service was strange. Had a table for 6 and dinner came out in four different stages, each 5 minutes apart. Wings and burgers weren’t very good. It was the third time I’d been here, the other two times were fine. It seems like the quality of the food had gone way down. On the plus side, there was no wait on a Saturday night and the fries and appetizers were great.

So, we’ve gotta talk about this fried pickle slice thing. It’s genius! Really. If you’ve never had fried pickles slices, definitely come check this place out. I ate more than I should have and loved them.
Beyond the pickles – The atmosphere at this location is not family friendly. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but worth noting as I believe some of the other locations lean more toward the family pub than local watering hole atmosphere. This location does have several jumbo TVs playing various sporting events and ESPN and the atmosphere is comfortable for what it is. The servers were attentive and the food came out so lightening fast that I was almost worried about its freshness. Needn’t have worried, though, it was all tasty and seemed well made and fresh.
The beer selection here is pretty sound. I had a tasty brown ale and there were quite a few options across the range of popular microbrew tastes.
Overall, I’d recommend this Stacked Pickle for someone looking for a local sports bar (rather than family pub) with great food and a decent beer selection.

Not so great. Husband tenderloin was decent. Wings were awful. No sauce just grease. Had to salt then to find flavor. All in all disappointing. Too bad it was our first trip and will likely be the last

I feel like the food has slipped a little here. Worst if all is the flat breads they changed to. Their old pizza was really good for a bar that isn’t a pizza joint. The new is probably more cost efficient and easy to make but is horrible… Last couple times in the burgers didn’t taste like they had any seasoning either. Still the best fries around though.

Loved the patio atmosphere on a pleasant breezy day. Food choices were great and tasted even better. Will recommend and be back myself!

I recently moved here from NYC and our gated community is right behind the strip mall Stacked Pickles is in so we figured we would try them out today. We ordered burgers to go. The staff was very friendly, even offering my partner a soda while he waited for the food to be done. The burgers were juicy and cooked to order. The thin fried onions on top were amazing. I would highly recommend this place to anyone in the area.

Stacked Pickle is the kind of bar & grill where average guys like me go and awkwardly stare at the impossibly attractive servers hoping that the drool isn’t painfully obvious.
Okay, that might be exaggerating a bit. The servers are definitely attractive, though I’m not so much the drooling kind as the socially awkward kind who tries to look them in the eyes despite being in a wheelchair where my gaze inevitably reaches a wee bit lower.
Yeah, you know what I mean.
Stacked Pickle is a Central Indiana mini-​chain with locations in Carmel, West Carmel (I didn’t even know West Carmel exists!), Fishers, Greenwood, the IUPUI Campus, and this location on East 96^th Street. It’s billed as a neighborhood bar & grill with your standard bar & grill fare including sandwiches, appetizers, salads, pizza, wings, etc. They also, of course, have a full bar and have specials throughout the week (both drink and food). They do also offer a «Healthier Side» menu with several options on it. They have a kids menu (12 & under) and apparently do also offer delivery.
The décor is your usual sports bar type of set up with quite a few 50″ widescreen televisions, several 92″ projectors, and a variety of banners & other forms of decoration. You might take note if you’re in a wheelchair that about ²⁄₃ of the place isn’t particularly wheelchair friendly due to having either bar tables or simply higher than usual tables/​chairs. They do, however, have one particular area with lower tables and they also offer outdoor dining that has lower tables. Today, they had their patio doors open so that even those inside got the benefit of some fresh air.
While I’ve been avoiding red meat for almost three weeks now, I must admit that nothing really sounded good in the chicken department and after much debate I decided that a good olé’ hamburger was probably a healthier option than tenderloin. So, I splurged. I also ordered a side of fries and my usual iced tea, despite the temptation to drink away my election day blahs. The entire meal came in at just over $ 11, a pretty darn good value.
The meal was delivered after a few minutes. That’s always a plus to me, because it usually adds up to a fresher meal. The burger was medium-​well, as ordered. The fries aren’t quite shoestring, but are along those lines. They are lightly seasoned.
The meal was definitely good, though there’s not much worse than giving a spastic paraplegic something with sesame seeds. Man, they were flying everywhere. I thought about putting them in my hair and pretending I had sesame lice. I enjoyed the burger quite a bit, though not quite up to the «I can’t wait to go back» standard. The fries? They were okay, but I’ll admit I found them a bit underwhelming and the serving size a touch light. I did get an iced tea refill without asking — definite plus! I didn’t try their fried pickles because, well to be honest, I’m already socially awkward and there’s absolutely no way I’m ordering a fried pickle from an attractive server.
My server was Ariel. In addition to being attractive, she was also a very good server. She was attentive, friendly, got the refill without asking, and didn’t seem to mind my awkward «I swear I’m actually trying to look you in the eyes» look. Thankfully, she was kind of short and that made it easier.
My overall experience comes in at about as 3.5, but that’s not an option and it’s a beautiful day in Indy so I’m feeling generous. Plus, Ariel’s positive service and the fact that a manager (or owner?) held the door despite having their hands full on the way in were definite pluses. This wasn’t a top of the line experience, but it was definitely a good meal, with terrific service and an atmosphere that was laid back and comfortable. They offer periodic live music and other special events. You can find out more by visiting their website.

I was actually enroute to another restaurant that was closed when I got there. As I drove along, I noticed the Stacke Pickle. Their sign listed beer and burgers, just enough for me to stop by. I walked in to the sounds of rock and hip-​hop; cool. I took a seat and was helped quickly. I ordered a cheeseburger and fried pickles. I enjoyed my meal as I watched basketball on a large TV. I’m glad I stopped by. My server, Amelia and manager Drake were both super awesome. They made me feel welcomed there. I will definitely return during my next visit to the area.

Waitress was awesome! The burger was perfect. The nachos & queso was huge! Really enjoyed the homemade salsa. Just the right amount of zing! Looking forward to going back to try their Holiday Drinks soon!

Underwhelmed by a couple things:
1) service was spotty at best, and a little slow for not being particularly busy
2) it’s a big space with high ceilings — yet I came out reeking of grease … should not smell like a fry cook after a 1 hour mid-​day lunch

Overall this place is just ok, agreeing with Holly H, I was underwhelmed by this place as well. It’s definitely a place where a lot of hot guys hang out, but as far as the food, it was just ok. It’s nice that they have outdoor seating, but I just wasn’t impressed. It’s not my favorite. I however have a friend who eats here all the time. Fried pickles are good, but my favorite north side bar off 96^th street, is still Scotty’s.

I was underwhelmed by everything about this place.
The patio: meh
The service: meh
The food: meh
The entire experience was just not memorable. If you are looking for good bar food in this neighborhood, you’re better off heading to Scotty’s.

Food’s pretty good. Competitive prices. Servers were very friendly. Nice selection of TV’s for watching games. Stop trying to upsell me though, Stacked Pickle servers. That’s annoying. Just take my order the way I want it.

Stacked Pickle lands at 3 stars for me. They are consistent, and good… but nothing worthy of more than 3 stars. I’m a fan of going for lunch on Mondays because they have $ 5 burgers. The fried pickles are a must try when you visit.
Good food. Consistent service. But definitely nothing worth bragging over.

Great location to watch the Colts game. I showed up 30 min before game time and they had several large tables available which was great since I needed a table for 8. They let me have the table even though my whole party was not present. The wait staff was very accommodating and took great care of my party as each person arrived.
Tried the fried pickles of course.…they were great, not too greasy and piping hot! I appreciated that you could order them in place of fries with your meal or you could order a ½ order of them.
Split a BBQ chicken wrap which had tons of chicken, bacon, and lettuce in it. My only complaint was that I thought there was too much BBQ sauce so I ended up taking most of it off.
Not a fan of the blackberry margharita which the waitress recommended as a top seller. It seemed really weak and they don’t offer a frozen variety on any margharita. We sampled some of their other mixed drinks and decided the «voodoo» was the best choice.
Will definately be coming back when I need a place to watch the big game and not be pressured to keep adding to my tab while I am there for hours.

Awesome service (ask for Amanda, resident comedian); very friendly staff. Food was really good and beer was cold.

A friend invited me about this eatery. The manager said this location opened up about seven weeks ago. It was packed. The restaurant seemed smaller than the one on 116^th St. and Allisonville. My party did not stay for the 9 PM band.
I tried the Hawaiian chicken (spinach-​flavored) wrap with beer battered fries and a pickle. It tasted great but would have helped if the sauce was not dipping and making my wrap hard to manage. Also, it would have been fine without the fries being beer battered but what can you say about a bar.