Taylor’s Bakery

They are good enough, better than a grocery store but definitely not bakery level. One thing for sure is that when people want a vanilla cake they want vanilla. Not very many people want almond flavoring in their vanilla cake and icing. It tastes like cherry and ruins the whole experience. Also pumpkin rolls are to be made with cream cheese filling not 90 percent buttercream and a smidge of cream cheese.

This is the ONLY place I go for cakes and cookies for special celebrations. The order is always right, and everything is 100 percent delicious. I’m not sure how is manage without Taylor in my life ! Also, the donuts are delicious as well. I can’t resist the glazed ones!

Great place for cakes! Love to go in and grab fresh donuts! The Fishers location is easy in easy out!

Hey M.A. This is INDIANA. If you don’t like what Taylor’s bakery is doing about the cheater patriots, then don’t spend your money there. Patriots fans are the only nfl fans that have to stand up for their classless team. No other nfl team fans are like that. Late night talk show hosts, ESPN corresponds, newscasters, celebrities, etc, all talk trash about the patriots because they can’t play the game without cheating! You’re team is a joke and the rest of us are laughing at them.

Our first time ever going to Taylor’s was last Tuesday morning. Have heard so many great things from friends and locals. Love the location in Fishers, definitely had that small town feel. The inside was super cute décor and very clean. You could hear the ladies being super friendly but the one that helped us seemed like she had better things to do. My boyfriend said it was our first time coming, kinda hinting around for her to maybe engage us on what to get. But she just stood there and barely answered our questions. We took the doughnuts home and they were so delicious! Very impressed and my boyfriend even liked the plain yeast ones and he never likes those. All and all I would go back I just hope we have a more cheerful greeting and help.

Taylor’s got me with their deflate cake offer. As a tribute to Tom Brady, they offer a delicious football cake with chocolate frosting and your choice of white or chocolate cake. Unfortunately, some of the air has been let out of the football so it’s a bit deflated. But they let some of the air out of the price, too, so you get it for $ 12 instead of $ 24. The promotion’s totally attention grabbing for those of us disappointed Colts fans or really anyone who thinks Tom Brady’s recent antics are worthy of a little derisive humor.
Promotions and gimmicks aside, the cake was absolutely delicious! The cake itself was moist and just the right level between dense and fluffy and the frosting was very rich and lively. The staff were super helpful and more than willing to accommodate my same day cake order. Looking around at what else was available as I waited for them to box up my cake, I couldn’t help but marvel at the level of aesthetic beauty this bakery brings to each of its confectionary creations.
If you need a cake or just some sweet treats, I’d definitely put Taylor’s on the short list of bakeries to try. Great service and great food in a very clean and inviting store. What more could you want?

Taylor’s Bakery is our go to stop for all our sweet needs here in Fishers.
The family owned and operated business makes anything from from cakes, cookies, desserts and our favorite donuts!
This morning we decided to stop in and get a couple dozen of our favorite donut holes. Of course every time we stop in there we always leave with more then what we went in for. And this morning that is exactly what happened. The little sinful donuts caught our attention. They are made with the same batter as their donut holes and stuffed with a cinnamon sugar glaze. They definitely lived up to their name.
Can’t wait for our next trip in to see what we walk out with next!

I just got home from getting my family donuts and cookies. I got the red velvet donut with icing and when I got home and took a bite, there was a hair not just on the donut but was cooked through the icing. I completely understand things happen, but this is just unacceptable. To add to the disgusting surprise, the lady behind the counter had about a 0 in customer service and seemed annoyed my daughter’s wanted to see the selection. Needless to say, they lost my business today.

We tried Taylor’s Bakery today (12÷3÷14). They have donuts, cakes, cookies, and sweets.
I will say that they are not the friendliest people working there. I don’t recall being welcomed when we walked in. I did however ask several questions about the different cookies in the case and she did tell me about each item. They looked pretty, but they taste average at best.
I had the chocolate covered Oreo, sprinkled long sugar cookie, and the peppermint & white chocolate cookies. Which the peppermint one was the best followed by the Oreo.
I also tried a lemon bar. They were a little small and super tart.
Over all it’s nothing to write home about or break your neck to get there before 6pm.

I gotta tell it like it was yesterday. so maybe the bakery had a bad day I don’t know and I don’t care! I was having one as well. I limp in injured and go straight to what I limped in for. I say I’ll have the bd cake is it still 6.00 she said it’s 6.75 what kind do you want chocolate, white I say I don’t care «I just want it fresh» she lies and says it’s fresh baked fresh EVERYDAY. There are 10 – 15 of these miniature bd cakes this was almost 3pm in the afternoon. I don’t believe for a second they sell all those cakes out and bake fresh another 10 –15 more everyday maybe that’s true for the doughnuts or cookies but most of that stuff is the same stuff the had on Wed. if its 2 days old say so! let me decide if I want to waste my money! Or provide the customer a choice baked today vs baked 2 days ago at a discounted price! these cakes are over priced anyway but when their fresh for me it’s worth it.
I get it home that evening I cut a little piece it was old stale tasting! the bottom of the cake was complete wet! soaked is the tall tale sign of a cake that been sitting or stored in a frig and just getting old. I don’t like my cake wet on the bottom when its BD cake! moist is one thing wet and soggy is another and the frosting was hard and crunchy not smooth. I’m disappointed I was counting on that cake to make me feel better!

Taylor’s is a family owned business that takes pride in their work. It’s evident by the creativity and quality of everything they make. I was always familiar with their 62^nd/​Allisonville location that was close to home & easy access for weekend donut runs, but I’ve grown to love them having consumed their cakes on a regular basis as our ‘preferred’ bakery at work from their 116^th/​Fishers location.
A few days ago I needed to grab a cake for an impromptu birthday celebration and was able to call the same day and have it decorated and ready for pick up within hours. Upon arrival, I was greeted with windows full of festive harvest, fall and Halloween decorated cakes that would be perfect for any party. Considering the Frankenstein cake may not go over well, I stuck to the chocolate on chocolate ½ sheet. It was beautifully decorated with sunflowers and piped in orange, but better yet — everyone RAVED about how delicious it was!
Helpful hints: They make their own homemade ice cream and give 10% off with any cake order. They also make their own popcorn and had samples of Pumpkin Spice for me to munch on while I perused the store. Oh, last but not least, they have cards for those who don’t want to make another stop!

I do not like their icing and cakes. Their doughnuts are good. In all fairness, I haven’t tried anything else other than the cookies. They are ok, but most have the icing, and it has a salty taste. Just not my preference.

love this little shop!

I have been here many times. I’m not sure that the cakes are all that special to justify the high cost, but the cookies and donut holes are very good. It’s our favorite place for donut holes around here.

We were in town from Chicago. My boys and I had the carving for sweets, saw the bakery sign. Decided to stop by, very colorful and pretty inside the shop. Too many things to choice. I got one cupcake, small tub of cookies, one sandwich cookie, and one cookie with alligator on top of it. It all tastes yummy and fresh. The cupcake — great frosting! Perfect balance.
I’m sad that it’s in Indiana! Now I have to make an excuse to go back there to stop by the bakery. :)

I have never been a big fan of Taylors. I know people that have worked there and the customer service sucks here. I popped in the other day to see if they could make me a pie, a special pie, a key lime pie. My mother is a huge afn, like me, i asked the associate and she was unsure so she asked the rude manager, which was rude to me saying there not in season. Well excuse me, pumkin pies not in season, but you can find them at Kroger or Marsh bakeries. So, i went one step further, asking if maybe they had the ingredients to put one together, she informed me that the products to make a key lime pie cannot be ordered until April. WOW, I guess this is why i don’t go here, Honestly this would be the last place on my list I would ever go, it just looks sad and dark inside, and again the salespeople are kinda rude.

Plenty of sugary sweets to choose from at this cute little bakery in Fishers. I was on the hunt one day for desserts for a work event. I didn’t feel like going the easy route and buying donuts from Marsh. I wanted something unique because it just so happened that the work event was unique. Taylor’s Bakery is conveniently located on 116^th street pretty closet to McAlister’s Deli. The first time I walked in I was almost knocked over by the wonderful smells. They had cakes, cookies, dessert bars, popcorn, brownies, etc. So many great treats. I ended up opting for a tray of cookies because the looked delicious and cookies are always easy to eat and easy to disseminate. Everyone loves a good cookie.
The event was a success. Because of the cookies? Perhaps. Treats never hurt, though!

I went to Taylor’s to order a cake for my son’s 3^rd birthday. I found the prices to be rather high for the quality of the cake. Don’t get me wrong, it was tasty, but nothing to write home about. The designs offered were supermarket level, which I found surprising for a bakery. Maybe cakes just aren’t the focus of the store? I’ll go elsewhere for bday cake next time.
Also, all 3 women who happened me from the start of the order until pick up were rather rude and unfriendly.

Thanks to a fellow Unilocaler, I have finally found the equivalent of my long-​sought-​after glazed croissant: Taylor’s deep-​fried danish! YES!
Variety: event cakes, cookies (mini to monster), breads/​rolls, donuts, danish, small pastries (cheesecake bars, cannoli)
Service: We arrived on a weekday as soon as they opened & were served with a smile. Found out they’ll even take a special order as little as ONE day ahead…
Quality: Fresh and from scratch. Have tried all but cakes so far, but will soon.
Cake Decorating: Decorating on cakes leans toward the traditional. These aren’t Ben D’Israel Sweet Genius cakes, but they’re neatly done and creative for this price. And you can special order as little as one day ahead! At Taylor’s you can order family favorites: cute-​kitschy doll cakes, sheetcakes with characters, or event cakes that use creative tiering, stands, bridges to get different looks.
Best Technique: Their patterns, textures piped onto the icing look great — very professional, elegant (polka dots, swirls). Square and stacked cakes are neat and stable, too — no leaning towers of Pisa here. My daughter adored the polka-​dot gift cakes.
Angel Food Lovers: Taylor’s bakes angel food cake fresh every day from scratch with a family recipe: white, orange, and raspberry, plus a special weekly flavor. You can choose un-​iced, too.
Giant Cupcake: serves 16! Super cute, but I’m wondering how we’d eat it?
My kids devoured the mini glazed cake doughnuts. If you stop in to discover someone’s purchased all of the deep-​fried danish, then you know I was there before you!

I love treats and sweets, cakes and pies, brownies and cookies… mmmm and chocolate. I love all things chocolate. I am such a cliché of a woman in that way. I have always enjoyed Taylor’s. They make beautiful cakes so I ordered Max’s 1^st birthday cake from here and I requested that they do a football shaped cake. It was awesome! They put a #1 on it and it tasted divine. Ask my son, who devoured it!
I also got cupcakes, which everyone loved as well. IMO the vanilla was boring but still good. However, I did think charging me an additional $ 0.50 per cupcake the write the #1 on them was a bit over-​doing it. I was disappointed in the price, but everything else was awesome!
The cakes were ready on time and the lady who helped me check out was very nice. I will be back… b/​c I love all things sweet and delicious!