Toolbox Men’s Supply Company

What guy shouldn’t have an underwear line with color? Leave Fruit of the «Loon» and say no way to Haynes cause the Toolbox has put a spin on the standard tighty whities.
In all seriousness I’m echoing the same comments of my fellow reviewers. Gregory was great along with the store’s mascot Lilly. Lots of styles from briefs, boxer briefs, jocks, suits, hats, socks… And you can try them on to give enough thought to whether you want to go basic or… [insert imagination]. Lots of color and style.
Prices were competitive with inventory you won’t find anywhere else.

Cute shop for boys and some girls. Offering clothing or very little clothing for the Mass Ave type of guy or gal. You may remember it from Broad Ripple. The owner is a very nice guy.

Had to take a second to compliment Toolbox, specifically Gregory. I was looking for a few hard to find items and was excited to find them on their website. I ordered my items and they shipped the following business day and delivered the same week with normal shipping. I loved the personalized thank you note from Gregory! A great gesture, which definitely made me add their website to my favorites, and ensures I’ll be a return customer. :)

Fantastic place. I never thought that I would find an underwear boutique that caters to men in Indianapolis. But here we are! The selection is pretty great, Timoteo, Andrew Christian, Cellblock 13, Doreanse, etc, so styles definitely meet a lot of interests. Neoprene harnesses are a fun new addition, too!
The ability to try on is probably the greatest feature of this boutique. The knowledgable and friendly store owner is another huge asset to the business.
My two complaints are not major but they definitely detract from the business. Fitting rooms, considering the nature of what you’re trying on, are fairly open with a simple curtain that doesn’t quite close all the way at the edges. Call me a prudish gay man but I’d like a little more privacy to try on underwear haha. More substantial is the frequent difficulty with maintaining stock. If you are looking for a small or a medium, finding the hottest items will be difficult in your size. And with he frequent updates about new or incoming styles on social media, those items get cleared out. Quickly.
Shop local! This is an absolutely fantastic business.

Great shop for mens undies, swim trunks and fun-​derwear. Very friendly staff /​owner. Great selection for the twinks to the bears. Great addition to Broadripple area. Great shop for men since the gals have Victorias Secret. Love the made in the USA cotton boxer briefs.

Hrm… how to word this review so it’s «family-​friendly» for grandmas and moms…
Women have Victoria’s Secret. Men in Indianapolis have Toolbox Men’s Supply Company. This is by far the best place I’ve found to buy men’s underwear, swimwear and other apparel from designers you can’t find in the stores. It’s the only place in Indianapolis I’ve been able to find my favorite designer, Andrew Christian (whom I fell in love with in West Hollywood a few years back.)
The shop seems a bit odd in Broadripple. It’s something I would expect to see on Broadway in Chicago) or perhaps even better fit for Mass Ave in Indy (perhaps a second store soon?). Broadripple? Strange, but it works. The building is across from the Broadripple Brew Pub, and features a great selection. No more online ordering and waiting for (or paying) shipping; Toolbox Men’s Supplies has the latest and greatest selections and the prices are right in line with what you see online.

Absolutely love this lil shop in the heart of broad ripple. They specialize in mens swimwear, underwear, outerwear and more. Such a nice addition to the village — and the perfect place to go when shopping for a local gift.
Gregory, the owner is so helpful and friendly. He will most certainly help you if not sure what to go for.
I also love their toolbox candles — in a variety of scents!
Stop on in next time you’re in the area — and i think you’ll be pleasantly surprised we have this gem of a mens boutique.

A successful return trip to a wonderful local shop. Did I remember to say «local»? Great selection and very competitive prices. Wonderful attention by owner Gregory to finding desired items. A «must visit» shop for men.

I LOVE THIS STORE!!! If you want a casual and comfortable environment to shop for men’s underwear this is the place to go. The owner (one of two) is always there and always greets you with a smile and casual conversation. I never know what exactly I am looking for so I’ve never asked him for help. Since buying underwear isn’t a daily or weekly need I don’t go in there very often, but he remembers us every time! The selection is good and I like being able to chose between everyday styles and styles that are a little more special occasion/​risqué. I really like that I was added to a wish list all because they didn’t have my size in a particular style. Overall I can’t praise this store enough. It’s a bit of a drive for me, but it is worth it everytime.

If you are looking for something that makes you feel sexy or spicy this is the place to go. Amazing selection of items that are fun! New items arrive every week and there is always something different. Greg is very welcoming and offers great suggestions.

Visited for first time (across from Brewpub, just off Monon). Owner Gregory was very friendly, helped me find a swimsuit without feeling ashamed or overwhelmed (I don’t have the chiseled body a few of the clothing items look best on). Will definitely be back.

We stumbled across Toolbox in May and became instant fans.
Toolbox is a fantastic little boutique for men just off the beaten path in Broad Ripple and an easy walk from most anywhere in the area. We typically stop in after brunch on Sundays to see what kind of exciting new items they have gotten in.
They carry an impressive selection of men’s underwear, swimwear and active wear from many top designer brands including my favorites, Andrew Christian and Pistol Pete. The store is laid out as 3 separate rooms, so it is easy to shop. Very trendy interior.
They seem to have their finger on the pulse of the fashion industry as they get new styles every couple weeks and as a result, have an ample selection of clearance at great prices.
Greg, one of the owners, has been working every time we’ve been in and is very friendly, knowledgeable and accommodating (we had the puppy with on a hot day and he let her lay down inside while we shopped). I love that we have such a great local small business to support.

Great seleciton of underwear, T shirts, swim suits and the like for men. First of its kind store in Indianapolis. A fun store to shop just north of Broad Ripple Avenue.