Wolfie’s Pizza Pasta and Catering

It was a horrible place and is out of business. New tenant is Sapporitos pizza which is OK

I had read one review (on another site) that recommended Wolfie’s in Kennesaw as being a great place for «authentic NY style pizza». Well, I’d been to Wolfies, and I have to say, I wasn’t very impressed.
I like hole-​in-​the-​wall, small, individually owned places. They have a home-​like and cozy atmosphere (usually) that feels much more relaxing than larger chain places, and typically you get friendlier service. If the place is good, you feel more like a «guest», than just a «customer». In terms of THAT, Wolfie’s is fine. It’s small, tucked into a larger strip shopping center, with one single dining room that has a mix of booths and tables, with walls covered in framed black and white photos of customers, scenes of New York City, and more.
Seating was comfortable enough, and the table was clean. Our waiter came over to the table and… now… how can I say this in the least politically incorrect way possible? He had what a female coworker at the table called a, «very over-​it tired middle-​aged gay» attitude. I guess that sounds pretty mean, but well… he did, and knowing a ton of gay people, she knows what a tired gay guy acts like I guess.
Kennesaw until only a few years ago was a VERY white, straight, conservative Republican kind of suburb of Atlanta. With Atlanta’s explosive growth, a much larger mix of people are moving into the Kennesaw area. Even so, I’d expect to have this guy wait on me in a restaurant in Midtown rather than Kennesaw, because most in that area still respond better to (and tip better) female servers. He just seemed like he’d rather be anywhere doing anything other than what he was doing. To his credit, he kept our drinks refilled and did check on the table, but did so without any smiles or «friendly fluff» — I guess you get New York attitude with the New York pizza? Or do you get the New York pizza, even… more…
Ok, so «cold» service aside, we order slices of pizza and a house salad at our table. The salad cost more than it should for what you get, but then the pizza arrived. Ok, I’ve been to several places in Atlanta that advertised «New York Style» pizza, and in each case, the slices were HUGE. Even as a bigger guy, it would be all I can do at most of these places to eat two slices. Well, the slices I received at Wolfie’s were small. Very small. About the size of a slice that you’d get from a medium-​sized frozen pizza you get at the grocery store. For reference, I’m uploading a photo of my pair of slices with a dinner fork on top for size reference.
There was very little cheese on either slice, and I had ordered mushrooms and Feta cheese as extra toppings. The Feta wasn’t even melted — almost as if it were tossed on at the last second before going out to the table. Likewise, the slices of the others at my table seemed to lack cheese and were like warmed up slices that had been sitting around a while. They tasted ok I guess. I’ve certainly had much worse, but they were not what I’d call «authentic» New York Style (unless New York is populated by little people). Our bill total was higher than our experience.
So, much as I hate to do it, I can’t recommend Wolfie’s. It’s clean, atmosphere is ok, and service while cold is at least prompt, but you pay too much for tiny portions that seem slapped together.