Alexander’s Guest House

Alexander’s guesthouse is the best. We’ve been here more than once and we will be back again. The staff is so nice and the property is so laid back. The minute you arrive you feel like the place is making you take a deep breath. Key West is a real vacation and Alexander’s will allow you the rest you need. Won’t stay anywhere else.

My partner, cousin and two friends made our first trip to Key West to celebrate my birthday and the staff at Alexander’s made it extra special. Jeff was an amazingly thoughtful and courteous host as was Ryan at the front desk. Their suggestions of what to do and where to go were spot on and they helped us build an itinerary that made every day interesting and wonderful.
In addition to the great staff, the facilities are excellent. The rooms gorgeous and the common areas well maintained and inviting. The pool & hot tub were just heavenly.
I would strong recommend this to anyone; especially couples or anyone celebrating a special occasion.

Alexander’s was as much a part of our vacation as the palm trees and day sails and just as beautiful. Nina, at the front desk, set the tone when we walked… smiling, friendly, helpful. The bartenders at Happy hour were entertaining and knowledgable. Everyone we met there, staff and other guests, made our stay one we wont forget. Key West is great, but it’s Alexander’s I’m coming back for.

WOW!!! This place is amazing! Hands down the best bed and breakfast in the city. My partner and I discovered this place 2 years ago and have been coming back ever since.
The staff at Alexanders is something that you hardly ever come across. They make sure that you are taken care of. They are super friendly and very attentive.
Everything is walking distance from you and if you don’t feel like walking they have bikes you can rent on property. I would recommend this place to anyone who is looking for a true relaxing vacation.

What an incredible establishment! As someone with a hospitality management background, I can testify to this hotel’s dedication to outstanding customer service and great attention to detail. The wonderful staff really goes out of their way to anticipate and fulfill even the unexpressed wishes of each guest. To say that the service level was outstanding would be an understatement as this hotel really sets the bar high for hospitality excellence. I had an unforgettable stay at Alexander’s Guest House and will most certainly be coming back as well as recommending this one-​of-​a-​kind tropical oasis to all of my friends and family!
Each and every member of the staff deserves a round of applause for their high level of professionalism and genuine warmth in welcoming the guests and making them feel at home (if not better!). A special THANK YOU to Orlando, Raul and Nina, who went above and beyond to make our stay so awe-​inspiring and memorable. I cannot wait to plan my next trip here!

Never have I felt so welcome, special and comfortable in a hotel before! The staff was amazing! Without my having to ask, they helped with our bags, offered us beverages and kept our towels stocked. Plus, the rooms were great! They were renovated with luxurious details and I felt like I was truly staying in a home rather than a hotel room. I will only be staying at Alexander’s in Key West from now on!

This is my first Unilocal review as I have never before fallen in love with an establishment so quickly and so completely! The second we walked in, we were greeted with the warmest and most welcoming group of staff imaginable who were genuinely happy to help make our stay completely stress-​free and unbelievably fun, a unique and refreshing distinction from many of the other spots in the area. There is a tropical and cool vibe throughout and I instantly felt like I was at a friend’s home (a friend who happens to have impeccable taste, style and throws an awesome complimentary happy hour). I wish my apartment at home looked half as good as my room at Alexander’s and I felt legitimately sad to leave.

I just returned from another blissful and relaxing stay at Alexander’s. Friends first brought me in 2004 — they’d been coming there for over 10 years back then — and I’ve been back seven times since and made sure to book my 2016 stay before I left this year. Clearly, I love this place!
Over the years, Alexander’s has become a refuge for me, a familiar, relaxing and indulgent vacation spot where I can focus on soaking up the sunshine, cycling around the island (they now rent bikes at the guesthouse, making it even easier for me to hop on a bike the moment I arrive), enjoying the pool, hot tub, happy hour, delicious breakfast and lush and tropical grounds. It attracts guests who are looking for a low key, high quality guesthouse, and many guests come back year after year. If you go the same time every year, you get to know your fellow guests, which makes it all the more welcoming. I appreciate that there’s a warm social vibe where you can connect with other guests but your privacy is also respected.
The guesthouse and grounds are well appointed and maintained, with a classic, fresh décor. It’s such a lovely setting and close enough to the sights of Key West yet just removed enough to make it feel like the perfect island escape.
The overall excellent experience is due in large part to the wonderfully warm, inviting, helpful and on-​top-​of-​it-​before-​you-​even-​knew-​you-​needed-​it staff: Laura (the GM), Nina, Michael, Ryan, Jeff, Vagner, and Dominick. They’re present, ready to help and anticipate your needs. They exemplify hospitality and customer service that truly focuses on the customer.
Finally, a special shout out to Hercules and Junior, the two feline stars at Alexander’s — nothing says Key West like cats lazing in the sun!

Completely exceeded my expectations! Sadly we could only stay one night in Room 6. Loved the chic décor, warm staff, peaceful waterfall plunge pool and friendly cat Hercules. Many return guests who were all very friendly. We were the only straight couple which didn’t bother me one bit. Bikes are available for rent and they got my husband a 6 pack of his favorite IPA for his birthday. We loved our room. Small but great décor, A/​C kept us at the perfect temp and bed was very comfortable. Chocolate chip cookies (a lil stale), Andes mints, bird of paradise and nice tolietries. DVD collection and books in the lobby for guests plus a free happy hour an nice breakfast poolside included. Our room was on the second floor and we had a semi-​private deck overlooking the pool where I enjoyed a cup of cuban coffee while my hubby slept in. I hope to return someday to our little slice of heaven!

This is a RAVING REVIEW. My partner and I spent Christmas week at Alexander’s House and had an incredible experience. After making the telephone reservation with Nina (the most charming southern bartender and front desk team member), I immediately felt like we were going to visit friends. The staff is simply amazing. The property is gorgeous and the over all vibe was heavenly. Breakfast was made with care, happy hour was festive and throughout the week our host (Laura/​Manager) constantly provided pleasant surprises in honor of the holidays. This is a class act! From start to finish the guesthouse exceeded all expectations. At one point we had a repair request for our DVD player and Jorge (maintenance/​cook), was charming while being helpful– something you would expect at the Four Seasons Hotel. This business establishment delivers a very special client experience. We did not get the chance to meet the owners, so lets just say it starts with their GM, Laura. She loves her job, her team, and truly enjoys making the guest feel at home. A couple nights before Christmas, the guesthouse catered dinner, and we watch a movie in an outdoor setting around the pool with about 20 other guest. The event was creative, and made us feel we were at home for Christmas. Its not often you find a business on Unilocal with a five star rating, and it seems almost impossible to find a hospitality business rated as five stars. The Alexander’s Guesthouse deserves 5+ stars. One of the things we Ioved about this «gay guesthouse experience», was there is this amazing yet unusual mix between men and women. We throughly enjoyed the guest experience. Highly recommended. We stayed in a really cool room (#10), pretty special. If you stay in room 10 you will not want to leave.

I truly wish I could leave ten stars… that is how wonderful Alexander’s Guest House really is. The accommodations are beautiful, and the staff is so attentive. Conveniently located to Duval Street, but far enough way from the hustle and bustle of the noise and traffic. Bicycles are available at the property to rent during your stay, so don’t bother driving a car!

Quiet, comfortable, friendly. Great location in «Old Town» Key West (about 6 – 7 blacks from Duval). Stayed two nights in the «crows nest» which is sort of an attic room (slanted, low ceilings) but even this room was cozy and well put together. All the staff were incredibly helpful and hospitable. If you want to find shenanigans, Island House is right across the street. If you want something classy (and if you can afford it), Alexander’s Guest House is the place to stay.

If there was a way to leave more stars I would. Beautiful hotel, great staff and perfect location.
We found this hotel on tripadvisor by chance, and so glad we did! We stayed in room 10 with the private patio area — definitely a unique room!
Overall, this was a GREAT stay! Will definitely be back.

Beautiful place. Nicely furnished and equipped. The staff is super friendly and helpful. I would def go back.

Very nice and relaxing B&B. Everyone is super helpful, the complimentary breakfast is great and the pool/​spa atmosphere was just what we needed with striking up conversations with other guests and enjoying the great weather.
They also do a little happy hour for an hour with free cocktails!
Room #1 was a little smaller than we expected but still charming and clean.
Me and my girlfriend would more than likely stay here again or try another B&B just to get a new experience next time we visit. Love how quiet it is and it’s a short walk or quick bike ride to most places.

I stayed here with my partner over two yra ago and im beating myself up for not going back since! This place is great. The staff is wonderful and the amenitiesn are an addition to how great this place is. Moderately priced and located a few blocks from Duval which is great because less noise. I need to go back soon

My husband and I recently visited this gem to celebrate his 40^th birthday. We had initially discovered Alexander’s Guest House when we celebrated my 40^th — so we knew that we were in for a wonderful time.
Upon check-​in, we were greeted by the friendly staff and given a tour of the facilities. The garden and pool area are lush with tropical foliage and provide a relaxing atmosphere from the daily hustle of the Keys. The upper sun decks, where clothing is optional, provide a beautiful view of the surrounding neighborhood. Even if you want to keep your clothes on, this is a great vantage point for sunrise and sunset.
The accommodations are beyond compare. The rooms are tastefully decorated and kept super cool by individual air conditioning units. The bed was comfortable and the shower refreshing after a long day (and evening) of fun.
We had such a wonderful time meeting the other guests around the delicious breakfasts, the great happy hour, or simply lazing around the pool.
I can’t recommend Alexander’s highly enough. The staff are wonderful, the house and rooms are beautiful, and the guests are always top notch!

It is possible to rate beyond a 5: I hereby so state to all @ Alexander’s Guest House. Bravo. Thank you.
I stayed at Alexander’s for the first time in January 2013. I have already rebooked to return in 2014. I, as so many others, was welcomed most pleasantly the moment I walked through the street gate to the lobby entrance (thank you, Charlie.) Having read previous Unilocal but not having visited the property in advance, I was more than impressed and felt most comfortable.
The Property is beyond the descriptives of it’s website: charming, inviting, quiet, well groomed and convenient to all of the township. Each room is different in décor and views — but most have a wet bar, microwave, refrigerator, TV, free-​wifi (I was in Room 4.) Daily maid service: spot on — an abundance of fresh towels and toiletries (h2o.)
Each morning a complimentary buffet breakfast is offered: hot dishes, cold cereals, fresh fruit, pastries, juices, yogurt, coffee… lovely and filling. A complimentary happy hour is hosted each afternoon @ 5: a GREAT perk and a GREAT way to meet fellow guests. The pool and jacuzzi are available ²⁴⁄₇: NICE.
Alexander’s Guest House has all of the amenities (and more) than a 5 Star property/​major hotel in KW or anywhere. The staff «quietly» goes about their day to make sure that every consideration is afforded every guest.
Thank you to all @ Alexander’s who I may not have met. Thank you Angie, Jeff, Michael! You made my stay most, most enjoyable.

If you’re used to staying at hotels when you travel, staying at a guesthouse requires a change in mind-​set. There may not be a 24-​hour front desk, or a valet to bring the car around whenever. But, be prepared to sacrifice the anonymity of a cookie cutter chain for a more intimate, personalized experience. The very best guesthouses deliver a superb experience with top notch service and leave you wondering what you ever saw in a hotel anyway. And Alexander’s Guesthouse is the cream of the crop at delivering a superb experience.
The very visible front desk employees deliver extraordinary personal service. They know your name, what room you’re in and engage with you as you come and go, offering help with any need along the way. They take your pleasure personally and feel it’s their responsibility to ensure you have a good time, with helpful suggestions catered to your travel personality. Maps, tour tickets, bike rentals, dinner reservations, excursions — they do it all. When Agnes heard that the guided cemetery tour wasn’t happening one morning, I had a printed copy of the self-​guided tour almost immediately. They are a font of knowledge that you won’t get at a hotel chain. It’s not quite Anna Madrigal, but you will feel like family. Kudos to the employees I interacted with the most: Agnes, Jeff and Charlie.
Guesthouses also have a personality. Alexander’s is one of peace and quiet, inclusiveness and relaxation. Everyone is welcome. Period. And that sort of welcome allows everyone to be themselves, to relax and enjoy their vacation. It’s a job they do well.
The rooms are well decorated and cute, the expanded continental breakfast is delicious with a little individual touch each day and the hospitality is unparalleled.
There’s a reason Alexander’s is rated at the top of the travel listing for Key West. It’s their dedication to providing you the best experience possible.

I recently stayed at Alexander’s for my Key West vacay. I’m happy to say that I’m a Key West virgin no more! I was trying to decide between Alexander’s and Island House (which are right across the street from each other), but looking at all the amazing Unilocal reviews for Alexanders, I decided to go with it and I’m glad I did.
Alexander’s requires a 4-​night minimum stay, but they are clear about that policy from the beginning. Besides, you’ll thank them for making you stay 4 nights cause this place is great. Visiting Key West and looking for a gay-​friendly resort that isn’t «day pass-​ish» or «glory holing» is rather hard to come by these days. Alexander’s isn’t cruisy and the people there are so friendly. If you’re looking for gay cruisy classy, check out Island House across the street. I actually toured that property and it’s very nice as well.
Some random things about Alexanders that I observed…
1) Street parking only — but free
2) Room 16 was great — very private
3) Heard to stay away from room 7 — it’s in a busy area during breakfast
4) 5pm happy hour at the pool with free drinks… who can complain?
5) Grounds are beautiful… you’ll feel like you’re in some type of oasis.
6) The products used to clean the rooms are way too overpowering.
7) The water pressure in the shower was really weak… it was like a trickle.
8) Free Wi-​Fi for Guests
9) Breakfast for guests — mostly continental. They make their muffins and eggs from scratch.
10) A 15 minute walk to Duval St. where it all happens. I highly recommended renting a bike, which will make things much easier on your feet. But it is definitely still walkable.
Would I stay at Alexander’s again? HELL YES I WOULD!
Thanks Alexander’s. You took this Key West virgin and turned him into a man!