Sizzle Pi Pizza

Drove over an hour to get there… PORK Bar B Que was the best I’ve ever had… and the Pie is Just the Best around. better that Victory Pig Really !!!

Oh, this was tasty stuff but perhaps choosing the sausage for lunch was a bad idea. My tummy was unhappy for hours and I got to enjoy the sausage a few times over and over. Which is not to say that it was bad. It was good! It was just a little (a lot) greasy.
Pizza in NEPA isn’t «slices» they’re «cuts.» And the pizza isn’t a «pie», it’s a «tray.»
Sizzle Pi has been brought to the office for takeout a couple of times, but today we popped over for lunch and they had a great lunch special of 7 cuts with topping for only a few bucks. Really a great deal!

worth the wait, and the two hour drive to get it. even though they have new owners now, the food is still the same. We get so many slices to take home after visiting old forge, and going to Kingston, have to have one slice before the two hour drive home. It’s that good.

So disappointed in the turn Sizzle Pie has taken under new ownership. We’ve tried it about 5 more times, hoping they would work the kinks out and start making the wonderful pizza we have loved for years but the new owners are obviously cutting corners. The crust is too thin and dry, sometimes rock hard. The large chunks of tomato are missing and the cheese combination is dry and usually hard. They are overcooking the trays as well. We get pizza every Friday and Sizzle Pie has fallen out of our Friday rotation.

I’m so glad someone decided to buy and reopen the business. You can’t beat the price, 3 cuts for $ 2.99. The hours are limited, the latest they’re open is 8pm on a couple of days and 7:30 on a few days. I think they’re closed Mondays. I walked in on a whim right at closing time and they had 9 cuts left and I bought 6. They were hour and fresh and just like I remember. Chunky tomato sauce laced with onion and the perfect amount of cheese. Delish!

Amazing and delicious pizza! Worth the drive when ever we are in the area. Cannot get through over the phone to call ahead which is a bummer but the pizza is more than worth a wait. You order it in tray or half tray or individual cuts. The onions in the sauce makes its irresistible! An all around great find.

Let’s talk about the food first. The pizza is delightful. It is a fried pizza, with delicious dough, which makes the pizza. The cheese is goo, crust is delish. As for the sauce, it has onions in it I’m unsure if you can get it without, but they give it a great flavor. I’ve had the hoagies, which are quite large and great for a small price.
The only reason I’m giving Sizzle Pi 4stars is due to the in house dining situation, and bathrooms. They have all booths, and very limited seating. Not all patrons fit in a booth comfortably, not booths of this size, anyway. The bathroom is located outside in the back of the building. That’s just ridiculous! I think it’s obvious they are not courting customers who want to enjoy their product at the restaurant! New owners, same great pizza!

Great Pizza! If you like this style of pizza it is one of the best. Great sauce and just enough onion. Took only 20 mins for a pick-​up and they were busy. Great price for a tray, only about $ 1 a slice!!!

The pepperoni pizza hasn’t disappointed me yet. I haven’t eaten in the restaurant-​only take out-​but the pi is yummy. I especially appreciate the little pieces of onion in the sauce-​nom nom. Reheats really well too!

Just trying this pizza for the first
is great! We will be ordering more. Best Part is they do Delivery Now so that is why we can get it at work.

This is my favorite of the «fried Sicilian» pizzas. Victory Pig might make the claim of being the original, but this is the one to get.
It’s fried pizza, it’s gonna be greasy. But somehow Sizzle Pi is the least greasy of the ones I’ve tried.
Three cuts for under $ 3.00 with tax included might be the best lunch bargain in America.
Side note: They seem to have changed owners. Usually that’s the death nail for any long established business. That’s not the case. The new owners didn’t change the menu. They didn’t screw up the recipes. They didn’t even raise the prices.

Fantastic Pizza. As good as the VP or PL and is far less expensive. Will definitely be going back. Love this place.

I’m from Delaware and we have nothing like this down there. I look forward to getting pizza from here while visiting my in-​laws. The food is fantastic, but the demeanor and service suck. For the price that’s charged for the delicious food, please smile more.

Love this pizza. It’s not Old Forge but it is one of the best pizza in the area. Check it out.

Just got six cut tonight for my wife and I… excellent as always!

mmmmmmmmmmmmmm.
I ordered xtra cheese no onions and light sauce, hubby ordered xtra cheese onions with pepp — dddeeeeelicious!!!

If you want deep fried pizza this is the place to go. It doesn’t look the greatest from the outside but the pizza is amazing and priced right.

Kind of forgot to have lunch today so I headed over the bridge to try Sizzle Pi for a fast slice.
Upon entering, I realized that they do not take debit or credit cards and I asked the woman at the register to confirm this. She did, and I pulled out the only two dollars I had on my person.
She took one look at my two bucks and said, «I can give you two slices for two dollars, no problem!»
How awesome! She gave me a deal and was really sweet. She served me my slices to go with a smile.
To top it all off, the pizza was excellent! Fried pizza, Sicilian style, great cheese and a chunky, savory sauce.
I finished my slices before I even made it back to my office.
I will definitely be back, next time with a coworker or two!

Sizzle Pi is. in my honest opinion. the best pizza in NEPA.
Perfect in every way.
That is all.