Luigi’s Famous Pizza

my new favorite pizza in the area. Plus only place that makes potato and egg heros…

They have excellent pizza and it is very reasonable. The plain slice was delicious. I paid only two bucks for it and it was one of the best slices of pizza I have ever tasted. Also I’ve tried the square slices before, which are just as good.

Tonight we ordered the Margherita Pizza. It was very disappointing. In fact it was just plain poor. I called to express our disappointment. I told the guy who answered the phone that we’ve been a customer for over ten years and have always been happy. But not tonight. His response was as disappointing as the pizza, «Oh well… sorry». They know we are a long time customer. There are a million pizza places in the area and you’d think they’d want to be sure to keep us as customers. Good pizza but poor customer service and poor attitude to their long term customers.

I ordered grilled chicken which was not fully done. But I felt everyone deserves one more chance so I ordered again. This time the order was wrong so I simply asked for the ingredients on the side and I would just keep the order. The staff were very rude and unprofessional. Would never recommend this place to clients. If I could I would give them an invisible star. Lol. Tons of pizzerias, no love lost.

Consistently good food tucked away in a strip mall.
I’ve sat down and had dinner and ordered take out as well. A friend even had a catered engagement party here, which was actually quite a good time.
First things first is the food is good. Solid Italian good think pizza, cold & hot subs, and pasta plates.
I generally get the chicken Parm sub or onion rings. Never been disappointed. 11 bucks gets you a whole sub and fountain soda, they are a Pepsi account if that matters to you.
Staff is friendly and gracious, great for a low key meal or a longer hangout with friends. They are BYOB so it can be a cheap Italian meal.

Best pizza around for sure! The dough is soooo good. Crispy, tasty, chewy… the best part of the pizza. Everyone in my family fights over the corners because it’s so tasty. Eggplant roll is a must with every order!

Consistently excellent pizza. We get a medium deep dish for the 2 of us. The toppings are fresh, we’ll portioned and it’s always cheesy. Delivery is reliable. Best leftover pizza the next day too.

The pizzas are good, chicken parm sandwich is yummy, the cheesesteak’s cheese isn’t as melts as it could be. The only downside is one time they forgot a friend’s slice so we had to wait a while for it to be heated up again.

We usually order from guidos but I only like their Roni pie so we Unilocaled and found luigis ! We got a whole chicken parm and a large half chicken vodka half four cheese and everything was delicious! We called an hour before they closed and asked for delivery. very nice very fast and very delicious!!! We will be ordering again. Ordered again and got buffalo chicken pie, so spicey so good! Get ranch on the Side… tortellini alfredo was good, meatball parm good as well!

This place is phenomenal. .the early bird special is Fantastic and the dining is excellent. … the pizza is always cooked perfectly and the staff is very personable

I’ve only had their pizza but it is always great.

not your standard round pizza, its square and the crust is thin the crust is crisp and very tasty lots of cheese too. never had any entrees here but its my go to for pizza

Years ago we ordered from here when there were less pizza places around and it was good. Tonight we ordered at 6:15 p.m. and were wondering where our pizza was after about an hour and 15 minutes (at about 7:30). Called them and asked if our pizza was coming. The person who answered the phone said, «oh he’s leaving now». It’s 7:45 and the food just got here. Awesome job. Just another constant reminder how customer service in America has gone to sh*t. I would highly recommend Gianni’s in Red Bank. Better menu, and the food gets to you faster. Or unless you want to wait an hour and a half for average food at best.

We’ve been ordering their square pie for years. Wouldn’t go anywhere else for pizza! Today I tried the cheesesteak and I was impressed, and am very picky when it comes to cheesesteak sandwiches.

Meh. Pizza is average, but appetizers like mozzarella sticks and fries are great. Delivery is mostly on time but sometimes food is cold on arrival.

Luigi’s is my «go to» pizza joint in the Red Bank area. We order their take out on a regular basis.
We usually will order their extra large pie — which is a large rectangle with a thin-​ner crust. They have a lot of options for toppings. We prefer a sausage peppers and onions, pepperoni, or meatball. If I have to complain, I’d say that since this pizza is so large, grease can pool up towards the center. After time, you may end up with some soggy square slices. Nonetheless, just grab a paper towel and mop it up if it bothers you that much!
In addition to the pizza, we order hot and cold subs and the cold antepast. They make a real nice antepast filled with all sorts of quality ingredients. It is one of my favorites. I get their chicken parm and veal parm subs. They are pretty good, but not my favorites — but still go to orders. My wife likes their peppers and eggs sub.
We pick up and have it delivered. Their delivery service is very reliable — but I believe they do charge a small delivery charge.
Their Little Silver location has a small informal dining area, and an adjoining room. The second room can handle a small casual party or getogether. The smaller dining area is your basic pizzeria, with a few tables across from the counter.
While I only gave Luigi’s a 4 star rating, this has more to do with me being extremely picky with my 5’s and less to do with Luigi’s as an establishment! GO HERE! NOW!

The pizza i’ve had on many occasions has been the highest quality pizza in the local area, and even in the state.

Ah the famous rectangle pizza, sorry pizza fusion luigis was first! Anyway, always loved their pizza it is really a «take out» only place, I don’t even think u could eat in if u wanted. But the pie is always good, not great but good enough to keep u coming back. Slight mishap with the delivery but I think par for the course with teenage delivery «kids»! Price is right and food good enough for a return, just double check ur order when u get it!

This place used to be good. Even on par with the great Luigi’s in Lincroft, I don’t know what happened but I’ll stick with Luigi’s in Lincroft. Ordered their «famous» large rectangle pie half sausage, well done. Well it was a doughy gloppy mess, if I wasn’t so hungry I wouldn’t have even eaten it. Definitely didn’t bother saving the leftovers. I heard they may have changed owners, so that may be the reason for the drop in quality. Either way I’ll stick with the always great pie from Luigi’s of Lincroft.

I had the buffalo chicken pizza here. I was excited when they had specialty pizzas available. Most pizza places in the area have plain, pepperoni, and usually two other choices. However, that excitement was turned quickly into disappointment when I took my first bite. It was a pizza that’s been sitting out for a while and it broke apart when I got about half way through.
With only about 9 tables to sit and combined with a Boar’s Head (really, a chain + another chain?), it suffers a serious case of an identity crisis.