Colorado Insurance

I worked with Mathew Woodward, it was a great experience. Matt really listened and got me the plan that was best for my situation. After shopping around with other brokers, no one could find me anything close to what he could get me. I fully recommend Matt!

I couldn’t be happier with the service provided by Kyle and Erin Lahey. The two work in tandem to figure out what kind of insurance – including all the little details – I needed upon buying my first home. It was overwhelming to think about, but Kyle covered all the bases and made it painless for me.
Not only were they polite, thorough, and even fun to talk to, they backed up their service by expertly handling a last minute, frantic phone call on a holiday weekend no less! I don’t know any other broker that would spend their Saturday night – right after Christmas – making sure that I was covered. Truly excellent dedication and worthy of my business.
I wouldn’t trust my insurance with anyone else and have recommended their service to everyone I know.

Kristen is knowledgeable and responds quickly to any questions i have had. This company has saved me big time with my auto and homeowners premiums! Can’t recommend Kristen and Colorado Insurance enough!

I had been with colorado insurance for a few years and didn’t require much assitance but when I did, I was very unhappy with the customer service. I was given incorrect information which ended with me having to pay more money that I had been trying to avoid and instead of trying to help, I was made to feel like it was my fault. Wouldnt recommend to anyone.

These are the nicest most pleasant people you could possibly work with. Nick and Kirsten ROCK. I highly recommend!

Stephanie was great to work with. Very responsive and professional. Highly recommend her and the CO Insurance Team!

Kristen is always on top of it and gets the answers to some really strange questions. Plus she make certain that my rates are where I want to be for the coverage that I am getting.

The folks at Colorado insurance have been great to work with! They respond quickly to questions, and have been honest about all the insurance options out there, and what would best fit our needs. I have been very pleased working with them, and send a lot of my best friends their way for coverage.

Colorado Insurance has saved me a ton of money and I have better coverage then I used to. I recommend them to people all of the time!

Colorado Insurance has been saving my clients money for years. Not to mention their great costumer service that surpasses the rest. Keep up the great work!

Erin and Kyle are a great husband/​wife team who treat every policy need like they are insuring a mansion and a Bentley. They offered to look at my current coverage since I had been with my former car insurer for over 13 years and I was insuring lease. They helped me some really critical outstanding issues and found the appropriate company that would reward my clean driving record and protect the first new car I have ever had to insure. This is the difference between using a broker and shopping online for your insurance need. I also just moved and even though my insurable need was very low, Kyle and Erin attended to price and details as if they were insuring the Crown Jewels. They will be in regular communication to keep up with my insurance needs and have definitely become trusted advisors for my business and for my possessions. Thank you two, Caleb and Heather and the rest of the Colorado Insurance team!

William Mayes assisted me with my insurance quote. I was with Farmers and he compared pricing on the same coverage plans and was able to find me coverage through MetLife for less money and the same coverage. He handled everything for me with minimal info needed from me. After the policy was started my mortgage company had questions and William quickly responded to them on my behalf with no issues after. He was professional and friendly and I would recommend him to anyone else to assist in obtaining a new insurance policy for their home/​auto.

Terrible company! I agree completely with other review! There is no service, only sales. They don’t call when they say they will, don’t respond to underwriting errors until months (and e-​mails) later, and are either overworked or don’t care about their customers. I’ve switched to Allstate so I can have good service and a reliable agent, at the same price I was paying before.

Nick was great to work with. He was able to quickly find me insurance that increased my coverage and saved me over $ 300 for my car insurance. Highly recommend!

Do yourself a huge favor and buy your insurance directly from the insurance company rather than these jokers who are terrible at service! Ironic that their full name is Colorado Insurance Sales and Service-it’d be much more accurate to leave off the «Service» from their name as they apparently only care about selling you the policy so they can pad their pockets.
In roughly four years of doing business with them, I have never been able to reach someone on their «service» team by phone (always get a voice mail with no reply to messages left), and they respond to emails weeks after you send one. What good is an insurance broker if they don’t regularly shop your policy for a better rate and respond to your inquiries in a timely fashion???
They’re either understaffed or don’t care… either way, avoid a headache and call Travelers, Safeco, or whichever other company they broker for and do business directly-​these folks simply don’t do their job.