Frozen In Time

The place was great and the ice cream was awesome. I would recommend anyone in the area to give it a try. The owner interacted with my children and nephew and they loved it. We will definitely go back even though we live over 40 minutes away.

With «What Would You Do» filming there, we would go there anytime because the proprietor is very aware of what employees could do.

Im the ex girlfriend of the guy who said this place is too expensive and he had to go looking for change in the car. Fast forward a year and the same guy who had to go looking for change in his car is a deadbeat dad trying to get out of paying child support. #cheap …I digress. …the point of this post is to say that I loved the ice cream, and the owner is really nice. My ex is used to his mommy bringing his ice cream home from shop rite on sale… so if that’s any indication, he obviously can’t afford the ice cream at this place Bc mommy and daddy pay for his ice cream, while he refuses to pay for his child. If you’re looking for good ice cream in Livingston, go here.

Ice cream was great and well priced while the service was very nice, funny, and attentive. The ice cream guy seems like he loves his job and I loved the ice cream.

Found this place after Rita’s across the street didn’t have my cake that I preordered. In a bind to go to a birthday dinner with a cake i stopped in here to find redemption. Turns out they have very fresh and festive cakes. The cake has some sprinkles and icing decorations and when you look at it just makes you happy. The man behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. This time I was in a rush but i spotted gelato that I would love to try and will be back next time. There is a happy ending to my almost cake disaster!

This place is great, the ice cream is good and the workers are very friendly! Plentiful selection of Hersey’s brand ice cream and they even have gluten free options!
The owner was super funny and friendly as well, my friend and I were sitting outside and he gave me a dream catcher he recieved in the mail! I have a dream catcher tattooed on my leg and he came outside and just gave it to me! It was a very sweet gesture, will come back again with my gluten free friend!

This is my new favorite ice cream spot! Hershey’s ice cream! Best! If you are in the area it is a great place for a quick stop.

One of the best frozen yogurt places we have ever been too. The owner is super friendly and personable. However, my family and I have walked there three times in the past two weeks and each time they have had a small note written on the door that they closed at 630pm that day for no reason. Really disappointing for the best quality dessert place in the area. Not worth it to try to go anymore.

The ice cream is Hershey’s brand and yogurt is okay. Simple and a decent price. However, the owner was a little rude and unpleasant. Within one minute of us being in the store, he complained about his other customers. The owner/​server explained the products to us first-​timers as if we should have known. Also, next to the register, he displays a sign complaining about the town and community.
I would eat here again, but will try to make my visit as quick as possible to avoid conversation.

Nicest owner ever. Gelato and yogurt are super delicious and hand crafted. You could tell that a lot of love has gone into the place. It appears as though the township is trying to get the man down. Love the place, the attitude, everything. Will come back again and again.

Watch out the frozen yogurt’s addictive

I came here with my family to relax for the evening over some good ice cream and conversation. The ambiance was nice but the ice cream was subpar. We also ordered milk shakes and it was 90% milk with 10% ice cream. Very disappointing especially at $ 6 for a small portion.

In the words of my daughter, «They’re awesome!» I have to say that I dig them too. It’s one of our regular stops for ice cream. Kevin the owner, always greets us with a friendly smile. The ice cream is all fresh and creamy! It’s Hershy’s so I’m not surprised.

The owner is kinda douchey. I asked him what comes with a sundae and he talks to me like I’m retarded. He lists the toppings like fudge, nuts OR whipped cream. When you use a selective conjunction word, it means it’s a choice of the things you listed, you a-​hole. When I asked, «Wait, so it’s not included and it’s a separate charge?» he made it seem like he’s doing me a favor by adding it on — «Don’t worry about it.» He also goes on to explain that a sundae has nuts in it, hot fudge, etc. — yes, they do IF you pay for it.
It’s also $ 5.95 for a small sundae that I literally ate in 3 bites. The hot fudge was super gross. Fluffy is the best word I can use to describe the consistency (there were actual air holes in it, kind of like when marshmallows are really soft) and then it turned clumpy when it got cold — see picture. That’s the bottom of the cup and that’s with me already having spooned out 2 spoonfuls of it.
I MUCH, MUCH preferred Last Licks in East Hanover. Really friendly guy and the whipped cream is super tasty. It actually tastes like cream and has a yellow tone to it so you know it’s not just whatever is in a can.
Between the douchery, the really high price and the quality, NO thanks! I should’ve just left and used my money elsewhere. Oh, no credit cards for under $ 15.

Hershey’s hard ice cream (cappuccino…it was very creamy and delish)…many soft serve yogurt «blends» (vanilla with orange), coffee drinks, shakes, etc. Very clean place with inside seating. The service seemed a bit curt… I asked if they had soft serve and the guy just pointed to a sign behind him… yessss, I know I prob should have looked before I asked but a verbal reply would have been nice… it’s all about customer service! Anyway, a decent place for a dessert outing… would go back!

Great place for ice cream with plenty of flavors that won’t break the bank
The atmosphere was family safe and friendly. Great conversation with the owner.
Watch out when you’re there, you just might be on the next episode of «What Would You Do»? With John Quinones.

Visited last night (Thursday) around 8 pm. An overall great experience.
The gentleman behind the counter, who I assume is the owner, was a funny and super upbeat guy. He couldn’t have been nicer to us and our kids.
There was a short line when we walked in, but it moved quickly, and we were ordering our ice cream within 5 minutes. I am not usually a big fan of Hershey ice cream, but between the number of flavors (big WOW on the Outrageous Oatmeal Cookie), and how fresh the ice cream and toppings were, this place is definitely a winner.
I will definitely return. Great product and great service!

The staff is very friendly, and they have a diverse selection of delicious Hershey ice cream. They also do a nice job with their fro-​yo. While not so diverse in base flavors, they do a nice job of adding flavor mix-​ins and topping mix-​ins which makes a more diverse product base.
The prices are a little high, but they kind of gear it so you get a price break if you buy a larger quantity to take home, like a pint or quart.
I like that they have a loyalty card that they stamp at each visit. However, one stamp per visit is a little silly. One stamp if you buy one item or nine. It doesn’t seem quite fair. Of course they don’t have to have a card at all, so it’s nice to have a small perk.

A welcome change to the Livingston frozen dessert scene which is overloaded with below average (sometimes self-​serve) frozen yogurt places which never seem to deliver on quality, service and cleanliness. Since our buddy Tony from Coloco’s ice cream shop in the King’s shopping plaza left, we have yet to find a decent ice cream shop in town. There are tons of options in the surrounding towns, but Frozen in Time is a great addition. It has a large selection of Hershey flavors, sorbets and sherbets, and their yummy frozen yogurt blend ins. We especially like the vanilla yogurt with peppermint patty! The owner is super friendly and takes really good care of his customers. Apparently he left Mccool’s to open this, so if you’re a fan of those Summit and Madison shops then you’ll really enjoy it here. Last visit, we ordered 2 medium blend ins, a medium coffee cream cup and 2 overstuffed pints of chocolate moose tracks and Cappucino Crunch. The total came to $ 30, but when you think about the number of servings that equates to, it is about 8 – 9. So, the per serving price is around $ 3 – 5. Not sure if anyone could possibly expect an ice cream shop to be less expensive.
The space is not really one for sitting and relaxing while enjoying your desserts though there are a few tables and some outdoor seating in season. This place is perfectly located in the middle of S. Livingston Ave, next to Nana’s and across from Rita’s Ices. So after you’ve had your fix of Italian/​Jewish cuisine next door, grab your dessert at Frozen in Time. You surely won’t be disappointed and or lack for delicious options.
Update to my earlier review: decent but too pricey given that Mccool’s in nearby Summit is better and less expensive. The blend-​ins are also not quite as good as the former. The punch card here is a total racket… we bought three quarts in one purchase and the owner punched our card once… if you can’t venture out of Livingston, this place is good but there are lots of other quality ice cream shops with just as many offerings. Disappointing the last few times we have been.

$ 6 for a small milkshake with no froth or consistency ($ 7+ for a large!). Need I say more? Yeah, probably…
Having frequented many of the other ice creameries and frozen yogurt joints in the area, I decided to give the little independent guy a try. They had a decent selection of Hershey’s ice creams, but there were restrictions on blending anything with nuts due to customer peanut allergies. Um, maybe get another blender? The milkshakes were uneventful — no thickness to it at all. The prices seemed really high for basics. No wonder no one else was there on a hot summer day. On the plus side, the guy behind the counter was decent and it was a very clean establishment.
With all the other options in the area; and cheaper and more varietal selections, I likely wouldn’t return.